Is your child's food allergy real? Tests trigger false alarms

February 22, 2010 By Michele Munz

Food challenges take place every Friday at St. Louis Children's Hospital. Children who have tested positive for food allergies are pitted against the suspected culprits. They spend hours eating increasing amounts and monitored closely for reactions.

In about half the cases, nothing happens. The children are fine to eat the food many have been avoiding for years.

"Parents are very happy because it's a life change," said nurse Tricia Ruhland. They no longer have to analyze food labels, agonize over accidental exposure or send special snacks to school. Many, she said, head straight from the doctor's office to Dairy Queen for a Peanut Buster Parfait.

Food allergies are often misdiagnosed, leaving many parents needlessly worrying about dangerous reactions and painstakingly monitoring food, said Dr. Leonard Bacharier, director of pediatric allergy and immunology at Washington University School of Medicine. "It's a big, ugly issue. We deal with it every day."

A key reason, he said, is many parents rely solely on the results of blood or skin tests, which are increasing in use because of easier access. Blood tests measure IgE antibodies, chemicals present during an allergic reaction. Skin tests involve measuring hives that result from pricking the skin with food extract.

But experts agree blood and skin tests are not reliable. Several recent reports have focused on tests for peanut allergies, a common food allergy one study shows increased twofold among children from 1997 to 2002. Allergies to peanuts and tree nuts are usually lifelong and the leading cause of fatal and near-fatal food allergic reactions. Misdiagnoses appear to be one of many factors behind its increase.

In a study published last month in Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, researchers from the University of Manchester performed food challenges with 79 children who had positive skin or blood tests for peanut allergy. A huge portion -- 66 -- were found not to be allergic. The findings confirm two studies released in 2007 out of Sydney Children's and Johns Hopkins hospitals reporting large discrepancies in the results of skin and blood tests for peanut allergies.

The tests can be wrong because the presence of antibodies doesn't always mean a person will experience symptoms, Bacharier said. "In some people, these antibodies cause disease, and in other people, they don't."

A history of reactions to food must be taken into account, he said. However, many parents seek the tests because a sibling has an allergy or other vague symptoms. Or a pediatrician will screen for food allergies when a patient comes with suspicions of hay fever or a reaction to the cat. Parents are suddenly sent down a road with no easy answers.

"The problem is when patients have a test done without clear reason for doing one," Bacharier said. "These tests are wrong. They give bad advice all the time. When you order one, you have to deal with the result."

Alison Fox, 33, went to the doctor concerned her son was allergic to tomatoes. She returned with positive skin and blood tests for allergies to peanuts, peas and eggs. Her then 3-year-old son had been eating those things with no problem.

The news was disconcerting, Fox said. Her doctor told her the allergy might manifest with continued exposure. "I start freaking out, thinking well, maybe the next time he eats peanuts, he's not going to be able to breathe," she said.

Because Fox was certain of her son's food history, an allergist was willing to do a food challenge in his office. She was lucky to alleviate her fears within a couple of weeks and determine he was not allergic.

Parents with unclear cases, however, must live for months restricting their child's diet. They are unsure when or if their child last ate the food in question, or have a toddler who has never tried peanuts or eggs. In those cases, the hospital is the safest place for a food challenge, but the wait is long. Getting an appointment at Cardinal Glennon Children's Medical Center and St. Louis Children's Hospital can take over a year.

Food challenges are labor-intensive and time-consuming. Patients get 11 doses of food in increasing amounts every 15 minutes. They start their day at 8:30 a.m. and can't leave until six hours later. For some, the prospect is too daunting.

Help may lie in a more accurate . The company Phadia AB has developed a test that can differentiate between the peanut's dangerous and benign antibodies. It can predict whether an allergic reaction will develop with more than 95 percent certainty, said Dr. Henry Homburger, medical director of Phadia's U.S. laboratory. The test is not yet approved by the Food and Drug Administration.

"It would be nice if they were able to advance diagnostics so we could have a lower rate of false-positive results," Bacharier said.

Meanwhile, parents like Lori Kampwerth, 29, lived over a year restricting peanuts from the diet of her 3-year-old daughter, Ellie. When Ellie was 15 months old, she developed splotches on her face after she might have eaten peanut butter cereal at a baby sitter's. She had never eaten peanuts before, so a doctor did a skin-prick test. She tested positive.

The only way to determine whether Ellie was truly allergic was with a food challenge, which she finally passed last October. Ellie now enjoys kid-favorite peanut butter candy, crackers and granola bars. The family was able to ditch the epinephrine injections kept in case of emergency. Said Kampwerth, "It's a big relief."


Related Stories

Recommended for you

Expert: Be concerned about how apps collect, share health data

October 20, 2017
As of 2016 there were more than 165,000 health and wellness apps available though the Apple App Store alone. According to Rice University medical media expert Kirsten Ostherr, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates ...

Three million Americans carry loaded handguns daily, study finds

October 19, 2017
An estimated 3 million adult American handgun owners carry a firearm loaded and on their person on a daily basis, and 9 million do so on a monthly basis, new research indicates. The vast majority cited protection as their ...

More teens than ever aren't getting enough sleep

October 19, 2017
If you're a young person who can't seem to get enough sleep, you're not alone: A new study led by San Diego State University Professor of Psychology Jean Twenge finds that adolescents today are sleeping fewer hours per night ...

Across Asia, liver cancer is linked to herbal remedies: study

October 18, 2017
Researchers have uncovered widespread evidence of a link between traditional Chinese herbal remedies and liver cancer across Asia, a study said Wednesday.

Eating better throughout adult years improves physical fitness in old age, suggests study

October 18, 2017
People who have a healthier diet throughout their adult lives are more likely to be stronger and fitter in older age than those who don't, according to a new study led by the University of Southampton.

Global calcium consumption appears low, especially in Asia

October 18, 2017
Daily calcium intake among adults appears to vary quite widely around the world in distinct regional patterns, according to a new systematic review of research data ahead of World Osteoporosis Day on Friday, Oct. 20.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Feb 22, 2010
FOOD Allergies are rarely Black & White.

Think of a Food Allergy IgE Blood Test Score as an "Order of possible FOOD Allergy Magnitude".

A Food Score of 1 .. 2 or even 3 usually does not mean Carry an Epi Pen..

It must be Correlated with Patient FeedBack and Controlled Food ingestion...

Do not dismiss the Screening Value of Allergy Blood Testing .. while many would like to to the the Tell ALL Solution > ususally it is just one piece,

not rated yet Feb 22, 2010
As an added Note...

Often FOOD Allergy remins the focus of Allergy Parents of Food Allergy Children.. leaving the Progression of Allergy MARCH to move on to Respiratory > Rhinitis and quite possibly Allergic ASTHMA ( See ALLERGY MARCH ).

As such > keep an eye on BOTH presence of FOOD & Enviro / InHalant Allergy Progression.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.