Study finds church congregations blind to mental illness

June 22, 2011, Baylor University

Mental illness of a family member destroys the family's connection with the religious community, a new study by Baylor University psychologists has found, leading many affected families to leave the church and their faith behind.

The study shows that while families with a member who has mental illness have less involvement in faith practices, they would like their congregation to provide assistance with those issues. However, the rest of the church community seemed to overlook their need entirely. In fact, the study found that while help from the church with depression and mental illness was the second priority of families with mental illness, it ranked 42nd on the list of requests from families that did not have a family member with mental illness.

"The difference in response is staggering, especially given the picture of distress painted by the data: families with mental illness reported twice as many problems and tended to ask for assistance with more immediate or crisis needs compared to other families," said study co-author Dr. Matthew Stanford, professor of psychology and at Baylor, who is an expert in mental illness and the church. "The data give the impression that mental illness, while prevalent within a congregation, is also nearly invisible."

The study appears on-line in the journal , Religion and Culture, and is the first study to look at how mental illness of a family member influences an individual's relationship with the church.

The Baylor researchers surveyed nearly 6,000 participants in 24 churches representing four Protestant denominations about their family's stresses, strengths, faith practices and desires for assistance from the congregation. The results showed mental illness in 27 percent of families, with those families reporting double the number of , such as financial strain and problems balancing work and family. Families with mental illness also scored lower on measures of family strength and faith practices, and analysis of desires for assistance found that help with mental illness was a priority for those families affected by it, but virtually ignored by others in the congregation.

"Families with mental illness stand to benefit from their involvement within a congregation, but our findings suggest that faith communities fail to adequately engage these families because they lack awareness of the issues and understanding of the important ways that they can help," said study co-author Dr. Diana Garland, dean of Baylor's School of Social Work. " is not only prevalent in church communities, but is accompanied by significant distress that often goes unnoticed. Partnerships between mental health providers and congregations may help to raise awareness in the community and simultaneously offer assistance to struggling families."

Explore further: Knowledge about mental illness increases likelihood of seeking help

Related Stories

Knowledge about mental illness increases likelihood of seeking help

June 1, 2011
Increased knowledge about mental illness, attitudes of tolerance toward people with mental illness, and support for providing them with care in the community lead to an increased likelihood of individuals seeking help, according ...

Research investment failing mental health

October 3, 2008
More money and effort needs to be directed to understanding the causes and treatment of mental disorders to ensure improvements in the health of the community and the one in five people that experience mental illness in any ...

Social factors, not mental illness, to blame for high male suicide rate

December 1, 2008
( -- The popular assumption that most suicides are the result of depression or other mental illness has been challenged by a study of male suicide which will be launched later today by researchers at the University ...

Retirement funds affected by depression and mental illness

February 3, 2011
( -- Depression and mental illness have a significant financial impact on people who retire early due to these conditions, a study led by the University of Sydney has revealed.

Siblings of mentally disabled face own lifelong challenges, according to researchers

December 9, 2008
People who have a sibling with a mental illness are more likely to suffer episodes of depression at some point in their lives, say researchers who analyzed four decades of data.

Parental mental illness: How are children and adults affected?

May 13, 2011
A University of Western Sydney study will investigate the experiences of adults whose parents suffered mental illness during their childhood.

Recommended for you

College students choose smartphones over food

November 16, 2018
University at Buffalo researchers have found that college students prefer food deprivation over smartphone deprivation, according to results from a paper in Addictive Behaviors.

Study finds mindfulness apps can improve mental health

November 15, 2018
A University of Otago study has found that using mindfulness meditation applications (apps) on phones is associated with improvements in people's mental health.

Social media is affecting the way we view our bodies—and not in a good way

November 15, 2018
Young women who actively engage with social media images of friends who they think are more attractive than themselves report feeling worse about their own appearance afterward, a York University study shows.

New research has revealed we are actually better at remembering names than faces

November 14, 2018
With the Christmas party season fast approaching, there will be plenty of opportunity to re-live the familiar, and excruciatingly-awkward, social situation of not being able to remember an acquaintance's name.

Older adults' abstract reasoning ability predicts depressive symptoms over time

November 14, 2018
Age-related declines in abstract reasoning ability predict increasing depressive symptoms in subsequent years, according to data from a longitudinal study of older adults in Scotland. The research is published in Psychological ...

The illusion of multitasking boosts performance

November 13, 2018
Our ability to do things well suffers when we try to complete several tasks at once, but a series of experiments suggests that merely believing that we're multitasking may boost our performance by making us more engaged in ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jun 22, 2011
Realistically, the study should have been more in depth. They are drawing conclusions from only 2 pieces of data, and it doesn't appear that they fully vetted the connections that they hypothesized.

I see a few plausible scenarios

- Those with mental illness in the family are afraid of shame or being ostracized.
- Those with mental illness in the family tend to be less religious due to unrelated factors arising from contributing to the mental illness.
- Religious people may look down on mental illness as a product of sin.
- Mental illness may be priority one for a family dealing with it, but it may be that the occurrence of major mental illness is small relative to the number of occurrence of other needs.

and I'm sure that there are many more possible explanations. I believe that the study opens up an interesting situation, but it is far too early to draw unsubstantiated conclusions.
4.6 / 5 (11) Jun 22, 2011
Well, of course, 'mental illness' is really only possession by evil spirits, and you cant burn satan out of people any more now can you? At least not in 'civilized' lands...

Few religions are equipped to deal with possession in more 'conventional' ways, although santeria and of course the catholic church do come to mind.

Tolerance of mental illness by superstitious people who are already exhibiting deficits of their own must be especially uncomfortable and difficult I imagine. Is speaking in tongues sane or what? I dont know. But I have opinions.
4.6 / 5 (11) Jun 22, 2011
What do you think?

"Science validates faith." Says the holy babbler.
4.6 / 5 (11) Jun 22, 2011
"When the holy spirit is interceding for us, we are out of control." Says the blessed mumbler.

I can do this too. Blahblabbityblahblahblah Meckaleckahai mecka heiniho.

-But I cannot do it with all the earnestness that a tonguespeaker can. Why not? Because the spirit of god is not within me? Or because the spirit of shecky green is? No, because I know that there are no such things as spirits.

And I recognize the overwhelming power in many many people, of the compulsion to pretend. Is this mental illness I ask you? Is it??
not rated yet Jun 22, 2011
I would tend to agree with your sentiments in many of those situations, but to be scientifically fair, we would want to study whether specific prejudices are the sole cause of this discrepancy, or whether there is another mechanism that produces the majority of this effect.
4.5 / 5 (8) Jun 22, 2011
Indeed. Well, as the major religions are all based on the 'chosen people' concept, which is undeniably prejudicial in nature, and which enables Religionists to parse out the people of the world based upon whether or not they accept the one true path to gods heart, then I would investigate similarities with paranoid schizophrenia to begin with.

Our brains are oversized, damage-prone, and energy-hungry. As such they accumulate defects quickly. This explains the wide range of acumen not found among wild species. It would stand to reason that people who tend to share similar defects would aggregate for comisseration and group denial, under the banner of a credo of some sort.

If a whole churchfull of people is hallucinating then the visions would take on a legitimacy of sorts, yes?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.