Rhode Island Hospital researcher: Broadening bipolar disorder criteria is a bad idea

April 24, 2012, Lifespan

A Rhode Island Hospital psychiatrist and researcher explains the negative impact of broadening the diagnostic criteria for bipolar disorder in the upcoming Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5). In a newly published commentary in the Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, Mark Zimmerman, M.D., explains that lowering the diagnostic threshold for bipolar disorder will likely do more harm than good for patients.

As the debate continues over the revisions to DSM-IV, Zimmerman, the director of outpatient psychiatry at Rhode Island Hospital, says he and his colleagues recognize that the syndrome descriptions in DSM-IV are imperfect representations of an underlying condition. He suggests the DSM criteria should be conceptualized as a type of test for the etiologically defined illnesses (i.e. illnesses that are assigned a cause as determined through ).

is a symptom-based diagnosis, for which a does not exist. "In the absence of that test, must use the to identify the presence of the disease," he says. "Accordingly, as with any other diagnostic test, diagnoses based on DSM-IV criteria produce some false positive and some false negative results. In this context, I consider the controversy over whether the diagnostic threshold for bipolar disorder should be lowered."

"If we accept the proposition that DSM-IV criteria are imperfect in identifying bipolar illness, we must conceptualize these criteria as a type of test for bipolar illness that produces both false positives and false negatives," he says. "Shifting the diagnostic boundary downward, to be sure, will have many negative impacts upon patients, including inaccurate diagnoses and inappropriate treatment, not to mention the increased use of unnecessary medications."

For his research, he reviewed four of the prognostic significance of sub-threshold bipolar disorder. He explains that while sub-threshold bipolarity is a risk factor for the emergence of the disease, the majority of individuals with sub-threshold bipolarity do not develop a future manic or hypomanic episode that is a hallmark of true bipolar disorder.

Zimmerman looked at various sides of the argument in lowering the diagnostic threshold including detecting bipolar disorder in depressed patients, diagnostic uncertainty, and unrecognized and over-diagnosed bipolar disorder. While he recognizes that the goal of lowering the criteria is to better diagnose this disorder, Zimmerman says, "The question is not whether diagnostic error exists, but rather which type of error predominates, and how much will shifting the diagnostic threshold impact the number of each of these diagnostic errors. Also important to consider are the clinical consequences of each type of error, and which error is more difficult to undo after it has been made."

At the end of his analysis Zimmerman indicates that there are four reasons for not broadening the criteria and strongly recommends against doing so because:

-- The results of the longitudinal studies suggest that lowering the diagnostic threshold for bipolar disorder will result in a greater increase in false positives than true positives;
-- There are no controlled studies demonstrating efficacy of mood stabilizers in treating sub-threshold bipolar disorder;
-- If a false negative diagnosis occurs and bipolar disorder is under-diagnosed, diagnosis and treatment can be changed when a manic or hypomanic episode emerges; and
-- If bipolar disorders is overdiagnosed and patients are inappropriately prescribed a mood stabilizer, the absence of a future manic/hypomanic episode would incorrectly be considered evidence of the efficacy of the treatment, and unnecessary medications that might cause medically significant side effects would not be discontinued.

Explore further: Specific criteria improve diagnosis of bipolar disorder, study finds

Related Stories

Specific criteria improve diagnosis of bipolar disorder, study finds

November 7, 2011
Use of criteria such as family history of mania and early onset of illness resulted in the diagnosis of 31 percent more cases of bipolar disorder in individuals experiencing a major depressive episode, according to results ...

The impact of deleting 5 personality disorders in the new DSM-5

January 24, 2012
A newly published paper from Rhode Island Hospital reports on the impact to patients if five personality disorders are removed from the upcoming revision to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, 5th edition (DSM-5). Based ...

Study looks more closely at personality disorders

September 21, 2011
A newly published paper from Rhode Island Hospital argues against the proposed changes to redefine the number of personality disorders in the upcoming Diagnostic Statistical Manual, 5th edition (DSM-5). In their study, the ...

Recommended for you

People with prosthetic arms less affected by common illusion

January 22, 2018
People with prosthetic arms or hands do not experience the "size-weight illusion" as strongly as other people, new research shows.

Study of learning and memory problems in OCD helps young people unlock potential at school

January 22, 2018
Adolescents with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) have widespread learning and memory problems, according to research published today. The findings have already been used to assist adolescents with OCD obtain the help ...

Intensive behavior therapy no better than conventional support in treating teenagers with antisocial behavior

January 19, 2018
Research led by UCL has found that intensive and costly multisystemic therapy is no better than conventional therapy in treating teenagers with moderate to severe antisocial behaviour.

Babies' babbling betters brains, language

January 18, 2018
Babies are adept at getting what they need - including an education. New research shows that babies organize mothers' verbal responses, which promotes more effective language instruction, and infant babbling is the key.

College branding makes beer more salient to underage students

January 18, 2018
In recent years, major beer companies have tried to capitalize on the salience of students' university affiliations, unveiling marketing campaigns and products—such as "fan cans," store displays, and billboard ads—that ...

Inherited IQ can increase in early childhood

January 18, 2018
When it comes to intelligence, environment and education matter – more than we think.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.