Consumers don't understand health insurance, research shows

August 1, 2013

This fall, as part of the 2010 Affordable Care Act (ACA), Americans will have a greater range of health care insurance options to choose from, including, for many, state-based plans. But will they make the right decisions? That's doubtful, according to a new study led by Carnegie Mellon University's George Loewenstein.

Previous research has shown that competition at the consumer level is only likely to result in reduced prices and improved quality when sufficient numbers of consumers make informed decisions. The study led by Loewenstein shows that consumers do not understand and therefore casts doubt on whether they will make the best decisions under the ACA.

Published in the Journal of Health Economics, the researchers report findings from two surveys of representative samples of Americans between the ages of 25 and 64 who have and are the primary or shared decision maker for their own or their families' health care. Behavioral economists at the University of Pennsylvania, Stanford, Harvard and Yale universities and the University of Chicago, as well as professionals at a health insurance company participated in the research.

The first survey was designed, in part, to uncover how well the insurance holders understand four basic traditional health insurance concepts—deductible, copay, co-insurance and out-of-pocket maximum—as well as how well they believe they understand them. Analysis of responses revealed that while insured Americans felt confident about their own understanding of these concepts, their actual understanding was much lower; only 14 percent of all respondents accurately understood all four concepts.

The first survey also found that only 11 percent of respondents presented with a traditional incorporating all four of these elements were able to compute the cost of a four-day hospital stay when given the information that should have enabled them to do so. Finally, the survey revealed that a simplified insurance plan that eliminated deductibles and copays—the two least well understood elements of insurance plan design—would appeal to consumers.

"It is strange, in my opinion, that the insurance market has evolved so, that so few individuals understand the fundamentals of the medical insurance plans they are insured under," said Loewenstein, the Herbert A. Simon University Professor of Economics and Psychology in CMU's Dietrich College of Humanities and Social Sciences. "Insurance plans incorporate all sorts of incentives designed to encourage customers to make specific types of decisions. What is the likelihood that they are going to respond to these incentives if they can't understand the most basic elements of plan design?"

Based on the finding that consumers had trouble understanding deductibles and co-insurance, the researchers then collaborated with the insurance professionals on the team to design a simplified insurance plan using only copays (no deductibles), which was later marketed to the insurer's customers. The second survey then compared the ability of respondents to compute costs under the simplified plan as compared with a traditional plan with similar copays. The survey also asked respondents to make hypothetical health care decisions based on the simplified and traditional insurance plans, such as whether to go to the emergency room or to an urgent care clinic with an earache. Half of the participants gave responses first using the traditional plan, then using the simplified plan, while the other half were exposed to the two plans in the reverse order. Finally, the second survey elicited respondents' preferences between the two plans. Both plans had the same premium.

Analysis of survey responses revealed that respondents were somewhat more likely to make lower cost choices, such as going to an urgent care clinic under the simplified plan, and were much better able to understand the cost ramifications of these decisions under the simplified plan. Examining consumer preferences, the researchers found that respondents were initially relatively indifferent between the two plans, but after attempting to compute costs of services under the two plans, their preferences shifted sharply in favor of the simplified plan.

"The ACA deals with the problem of consumer misunderstanding by requiring insurance companies to publish standardized and simplified information about insurance plans, including what consumers would pay for four basic services," noted lead author Loewenstein. "However, presenting simplified information about something that is inherently complex introduces a risk of 'smoothing over' real complexities. A better approach, in my view, would be to require insurance companies to offer truly simplified products that consumers are capable of understanding."

Explore further: Application for health coverage has been simplified, shortened

Related Stories

Application for health coverage has been simplified, shortened

May 8, 2013
(HealthDay)—The application for health insurance coverage has been simplified and shortened, with the application reduced to three pages for individuals, according to a report released April 30 by the Centers for Medicare ...

Administration: 'Obamacare' to offer more choices

May 30, 2013
(AP)—The White House says insurance companies are showing interest in providing coverage under the new health care law, a development likely to increase market competition and give uninsured people more choices than they ...

Premiums expected to be about 20 percent lower in 2014

July 23, 2013
(HealthDay)—Premiums in the Health Insurance Marketplace are likely to be about 20 percent lower than anticipated in 2014, according to a report published by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).

HHS: marketplaces open new insurance options for consumers

June 6, 2013
(HealthDay)—Health Insurance Marketplaces, due to be introduced in October 2013, will increase the coverage options for many consumers, according to a memo released by the U.S. Department of Human & Health Services.

New research on employment-based insurance sheds light on health care reform

November 2, 2012
Men with employment-contingent health insurance (ECHI) who suffer a health shock, such as a cancer diagnosis or hospitalization, are more likely to feel "locked" into remaining at work and are at greater risk for losing their ...

Many patients would switch doc to cut health care costs

May 17, 2013
(HealthDay)—Many Americans feel that keeping out-of-pocket health care costs is more important than staying with the same primary care physician.

Recommended for you

Blowing smoke? E-cigarettes might help smokers quit

July 26, 2017
People who used e-cigarettes were more likely to kick the habit than those who didn't, a new study found.

Brain disease seen in most football players in large report

July 25, 2017
Research on 202 former football players found evidence of a brain disease linked to repeated head blows in nearly all of them, from athletes in the National Football League, college and even high school.

Safety of medical devices not often evaluated by sex, age, or race

July 25, 2017
Researchers at Yale and the University of California-San Francisco have found that few medical devices are analyzed to consider the influence of their users' sex, age, or race on safety and effectiveness.

Why you should consider more than looks when choosing a fitness tracker

July 25, 2017
A UNSW study of five popular physical activity monitors, including Fitbit and Jawbone models, has found their accuracy differs with the speed of activity, and where they are worn.

Dog walking could be key to ensuring activity in later life

July 24, 2017
A new study has shown that regularly walking a dog boosts levels of physical activity in older people, especially during the winter.

Study finds 275,000 calls to poison control centers for dietary supplement exposures from 2000 through 2012

July 24, 2017
U.S. Poison Control Centers receive a call every 24 minutes, on average, regarding dietary supplement exposures, according to a new study from the Center for Injury Research and Policy and the Central Ohio Poison Center, ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.