Evidence remains inconclusive for the effectiveness of manual therapy

April 1, 2014
Credit: Shutterstock

(Medical Xpress)—A continuing lack of evidence to support the effectiveness of manual therapy continues to prevent a meaningful conclusion on manipulation and mobilisation for conditions of the spine and extremities, according to a new report from Warwick Medical School.

The report, published today in Chiropractic & Manual Therapies, updates the given by the 2010 Bronfort UK Evidence report, and includes new data from systematic reviews, primary comparative studies and qualitative studies of both musculoskeletal and non-musculoskeletal conditions.

Manual therapies, particularly and mobilisation, are commonly used treatment modalities for back pain by physical therapists, osteopaths, and chiropractors.

Back pain alone is a growing health problem with serious societal and economic consequences. In the UK, back pain affects around 29% of the population annually. Over one in ten people who reported back pain consulted with osteopaths and/or chiropractic practitioners.

It is estimated that in the USA, 80% of people will experience back problems at some point in their lifetime.

Manual therapies are being used by patients suffering not only from musculoskeletal problems like back or joint pain, but also for other conditions such as asthma or infant colic.

Drawing on a broader range of research evidence than used by Bronfort et al, and with more recent studies available, the team were able to update, revise or confirm conclusions made in that report, and introduce new categories to be considered.

There was moderate evidence in favour of using manual therapies for acute lower back pain, and in other situations including:

  • Manipulation and/or mobilisation combined with exercise for neck pain, plantar fasciitis (Jogger's Heel), hip osteoarthritis and patellofemoral pain syndrome
  • Combined chiropractic care for low back
  • A combination of mobilisation and exercise for acute whiplash-associated disorder
  • Manual mobilisation combined with exercise for knee osteoarthritis
  • Spinal manipulative therapy for migraines

However, the evidence remains inconclusive for a range of conditions, including:

  • Asthma using osteopathic manual therapy
  • Paediatric nocturnal enuresis using spinal manipulation
  • Infant colic using spinal manipulation
  • Dysmenorrhoea using spinal manipulation
  • Premenstrual syndrome using spinal manipulation
  • Stage 1 hypertension using spinal manipulation added to diet
  • Otitis media and pneumonia in elderly adults using osteopathic manual therapy

Dr Paul Sutcliffe, Deputy Director for Warwick Evidence, explained "We simply require a higher quality body of evidence about the effectiveness of manual therapy. The research needs to be better designed, and with a greater appreciation for the diversity of clinical conditions – particularly those non-musculoskeletal conditions. Until we have that, we are not in any position to be drawing meaningful conclusions."

Explore further: Should spinal manipulation for neck pain be abandoned?

Related Stories

Should spinal manipulation for neck pain be abandoned?

June 7, 2012
The effectiveness of spinal manipulation divides medical opinion. On BMJ today, experts debate whether spinal manipulation for neck pain should be abandoned.

Chiro pain grounds limited says placebo study

January 29, 2014
Adeverse events and reactions after chiropractic treatment may not be the result of the treatment itself, a Murdoch University study has found.

Evidence does not support spinal manipulation for acute lower back pain

September 21, 2012
Manipulating or "adjusting" the spine is a popular way to treat occasional or acute lower back pain and is covered by many health insurance plans, but a recent review by The Cochrane Library finds no evidence to suggest it ...

New report on complementary therapies for arthritis reveals lack of scientific evidence

January 10, 2013
(Medical Xpress)—A new report written by a senior lecturer from the University of Aberdeen into the effectiveness of the complementary therapies that are commonly used for treating arthritis and other musculoskeletal conditions ...

Chiropractic care beats sham therapy for spinal pain

November 19, 2013
(HealthDay)—Short-term chiropractic therapy is more effective than a sham intervention for treating spinal pain, but the difference is not clinically meaningful, according to research published in the Nov. 15 issue of Spine.

Doctors should give greater weight to the effects of low back pain on patients' social lives

March 31, 2014
The way that back pain is assessed and treated needs to change to take into account its impact on the social lives of sufferers, according to a new Arthritis Research UK-funded study.

Recommended for you

Male hepatitis B patients suffer worse liver ailments, regardless of lifestyle

July 25, 2017
Why men with hepatitis B remain more than twice as likely to develop severe liver disease than women remains a mystery, even after a study led by a recent Drexel University graduate took lifestyle choices and environments ...

Mind-body therapies immediately reduce unmanageable pain in hospital patients

July 25, 2017
Mindfulness training and hypnotic suggestion significantly reduced acute pain experienced by hospital patients, according to a new study published in the Journal of General Internal Medicine.

Researchers report new system to study chronic hepatitis B

July 25, 2017
Scientists from Princeton University's Department of Molecular Biology have successfully tested a cell-culture system that will allow researchers to perform laboratory-based studies of long-term hepatitis B virus (HBV) infections. ...

Research examines lung cell turnover as risk factor and target for treatment of influenza pneumonia

July 24, 2017
Influenza is a recurring global health threat that, according to the World Health Organization, is responsible for as many as 500,000 deaths every year, most due to influenza pneumonia, or viral pneumonia. Infection with ...

Scientists propose novel therapy to lessen risk of obesity-linked disease

July 24, 2017
With obesity related illnesses a global pandemic, researchers propose in the Journal of Clinical Investigation using a blood thinner to target molecular drivers of chronic metabolic inflammation in people eating high-fat ...

Raccoon roundworm—a hidden human parasite?

July 24, 2017
The raccoon that topples your trashcan and pillages your garden may leave more than just a mess. More likely than not, it also contaminates your yard with parasites—most notably, raccoon roundworms (Baylisascaris procyonis).

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.