Study examines FDA influence on design of pivotal drug studies

November 25, 2014

An examination of the potential interaction between pharmaceutical companies and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to discuss future studies finds that one-quarter of recent new drug approvals occurred without any meeting, and when such meetings occurred, pharmaceutical companies did not comply with one-quarter of the recommendations made by the FDA regarding study design or primary outcome, according to a study in the November 26 issue of JAMA.

To enhance protocol quality, federal regulations encourage but do not require meetings between and the FDA during the design phase of pivotal studies assessing drug efficacy and safety for the proposed indication. These meetings often generate FDA for improving research, although companies are not bound to follow them, according to background information in the article.

Steven Woloshin, M.D., M.S., of the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice, Lebanon, N.H., and colleagues reviewed and analyzed approximated 200 FDA documents (memos; meeting minutes; filing checklists; and medical, statistical, and summary reviews) for 35 new drugs approved between February 1, 2011, and February 29, 2012. The researchers identified all FDA comments and analyzed recommendations about pivotal study design or primary outcomes and characterized the effect of recommendations on study quality.

Of 35 new , companies met with the FDA to discuss pivotal studies for 28. The FDA made 53 recommendations about design (e.g., controls, doses, study length) or primary outcome for 21 approvals. Fifty-one recommendations were judged as increasing study quality (e.g., adding controls, blinding, or specific measures and frequency for toxicity assessments, lengthening studies to assess outcome durability) and two as having an uncertain effect. Companies complied with 40 of the 53 recommendations. Examples of non-compliance include a request for randomized trials of brentuximab and crizotinib, but the companies conducted uncontrolled studies. Other cases included primary outcome choice (e.g., progression­free instead of overall survival) and drug (active comparator) doses tested.

Companies can also request FDA review of pivotal trial protocols. If FDA endorses the protocol it agrees not to object to any study design issues when reviewing the drug for approval. Companies requested protocol review for only 21 of the 35 new approvals - and FDA endorsed the protocol for 12.

The authors write that instituting mandatory FDA review of pivotal trial protocols with the power to issue binding recommendations could be an effective way to optimize study quality. They believe that such review may be even more important with increasingly flexible approval pathways. "An independent FDA-commissioned report suggested that stronger early FDA involvement could avoid deficiencies that delay approval of effective drugs and more clearly identify ineffective or harmful ones."

Explore further: New drug approvals from FDA declined in 2013

More information: DOI: 10.1001/jama.2014.13329

Related Stories

New drug approvals from FDA declined in 2013

January 2, 2014
(AP)—The Food and Drug Administration approved fewer first-of-a-kind drugs in 2013 compared with 2012, when new drug approvals reached a 15-year high.

Chimerix gets FDA OK to test drug for Ebola

October 17, 2014
(AP)—A North Carolina drugmaker plans to test its experimental antiviral drug in patients who have Ebola, after getting authorization from regulators at the Food and Drug Administration.

FDA withdraws arsenic-based animal drug approvals following study

October 4, 2013
(Medical Xpress)—At the request of two drug companies, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has announced that it will withdraw approvals for three of four arsenic-based drugs currently approved for use in food animal ...

Study finds high percentage of recalled dietary supplements still have banned ingredients

October 21, 2014
About two-thirds of FDA recalled dietary supplements analyzed still contained banned drugs at least 6 months after being recalled, according to a study in the October 22/29 issue of JAMA.

New sleeping pill poised to hit US markets

May 21, 2013
An experimental sleeping pill from US drug company Merck is effective at helping people fall and stay asleep, according to reviewers at the US Food and Drug Administration, which could soon approve the new drug.

FDA enlists companies to head off drug shortages

October 31, 2013
The Food and Drug Administration is announcing a new proposal designed to head off more shortages of crucial medications that have disrupted care at hospitals and health clinics nationwide.

Recommended for you

Sensor-equipped pill raises technological, ethical questions

November 17, 2017
The first drug with a sensor embedded in a pill that alerts doctors when patients have taken their medications was approved by the Food and Drug Administration, raiding issues involving privacy, cost, and whether patients ...

New painkillers reduce overdose risk

November 16, 2017
Scientists on the Florida campus of The Scripps Research Institute (TSRI) have developed new opioid pain relievers that reduce pain on par with morphine but do not slow or stop breathing—the cause of opiate overdose.

Separating side effects could hold key for safer opioids

November 16, 2017
Opioid pain relievers can be extremely effective in relieving pain, but can carry a high risk of addiction and ultimately overdose when breathing is suppressed and stops. Scientists have discovered a way to separate these ...

US regulators approve first digital pill to track patients

November 14, 2017
U.S. regulators have approved the first drug with a sensor that alerts doctors when the medication has been taken, offering a new way of monitoring patients but also raising privacy concerns.

Introduction is different, but top medications for opioid addiction equally effective

November 14, 2017
With opioid addiction officially declared a public health emergency in the U.S., medical intervention to treat the illness is increasingly important in responding to the epidemic. Now, a new study concludes that two of the ...

Drugstore pain pills as effective as opioids in ER patients

November 7, 2017
Emergency rooms are where many patients are first introduced to powerful opioid painkillers, but what if doctors offered over-the-counter pills instead? A new study tested that approach on patients with broken bones and sprains ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.