Could the Pap smear be ousted by HPV testing?

January 19, 2015 by Joyce Tsai, Contra Costa Times

A Pleasanton firm that received FDA approval for a test against cervical cancer said it has gained the support of a panel of medical experts to use the test as a frontline screening for women as young as 25, but the announcement only reopened the debate of whether the mainstay of women's health, the Pap smear, will become a thing of the past.

The Food and Drug Administration in April approved the cobas HPV , which is manufactured by Roche Molecular Systems. Last week, new guidelines for screening were issued by two medical societies, the Society of Gynecologic Oncology and the American Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology, both of which back the use of the test instead of the Pap smear - or to be used with the Pap smear.

The developments have caused some to ask: Could the HPV test do away with the Pap smear all together?

"I think it's headed in that direction," said Dana Chase, a gynecologic oncologist at St. Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center in Phoenix after a forum sponsored by Roche in Pleasanton earlier this week at which she was paid by Roche to speak. "We've needed something better for a long time. The Pap smear is an old test. It's been around since the 1940s. But we're not quite there. This is the first step."

A recent study by Roche of 47,000 women found the test was more effective at predicting risk of cervical cancer than a Pap test alone, and there was an unexpectedly high incidence of cervical disease in women ages 25 to 29, Chase explained, which led a panel of experts from seven medical societies to issue the new guidelines.

But Diana Zuckerman, president of the Cancer Prevention and Treatment Fund in Washington, D.C., said the study's results were misrepresentative because the study did not sample enough women. She said current guidelines, which give women 30 and older the option of having the Pap smear alone every three years or the HPV test with the Pap smear every five years, are more appropriate because testing women at younger ages, 25 to 29, when they tend to be most sexually active, could lead to too many false alarms.

Some 80 percent of women will have an HPV infection by age 50, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. More than 90 percent of all HPV infections are cleared by the body's immune system within two years without causing any serious health problems. Many women, especially those in their 20s, carry HPV, the human papillomavirus, and most will never know it because it doesn't transform into anything serious, according to the CDC.

"For the vast majority, it will go away by itself over time like the common cold," Zuckerman said.

"The reason that early HPV testing is so dangerous is that what will happen is there will be a lot of women with HPV in their 20s who will be frightened by the results, who would have never gotten cancer anyway, but because they get this test, they will get other tests," she said.

These include more invasive procedures, such as a colposcopy, a test to find abnormal cells on the cervix, which are expensive, painful and could interfere with a patient's fertility if done too often, she said.

About 12,900 new cases of are expected to be diagnosed this year, with 4,100 of them fatal due to a lack of Pap smear screening, according to the American Cancer Society. Cervical cancer was once one of the most common causes of cancer deaths for American women. But over the past 30 years, the death rate has declined more than 50 percent, mainly due to the increased use of the Pap test.

However, Chase said 99.9 percent of cervical cancers are caused by HPV, and the new HPV test is sensitive enough to detect the most high risk of HPV strains, such as HPV 16 and 18, which have the highest chance of developing into cervical cancer.

Heather Banks, 39, an elementary school teacher from Indianapolis who also was paid to speak at the Roche forum, said she'd had 13 consecutive years of clean Pap smears before she discovered she had cervical cancer after her second child was born in 2008.

She said if she'd known she had high risk HPV earlier, it's possible her cervical cancer, which led to a hysterectomy and early menopause, wouldn't have progressed so far.

"It's amazing how little I knew about HPV. I knew next to nothing, and the only thing I could do was react to it," she said. "We want to educate and empower to be aware of their options."

Explore further: Screening HPV infection alone more accurate than Pap test in detection of cervical cancer


Related Stories

Screening HPV infection alone more accurate than Pap test in detection of cervical cancer

January 8, 2015
Screening for human papillomavirus (HPV) infection alone gives more accurate results than Pap (smear) testing for cervical cancer, say the authors of two papers to published today in the journal Gynecologic Oncology. HPV ...

New recommendation for cervical cancer screening, using HPV test alone

January 8, 2015
About 80 million U.S. women ages 25 to 65—or 1.2 million women across Alabama—should be screened periodically by their health care providers for cervical cancer. At present, the standard way to do that is a Pap smear ...

What's the best test for cervical cancer? Pap, HPV or both?

June 9, 2014
Should U.S. women be screened for cervical cancer with Pap tests, HPV tests or both? According to researchers from Boston University School of Medicine (BUSM) and Boston Medical Center (BMC) while the merits of screening ...

US OKs first-ever DNA alternative to Pap smear (Update 2)

April 24, 2014
U.S. government health regulators have cleared a genetic test from Roche as a first-choice screening option for cervical cancer. It was a role previously reserved for the Pap smear, the decades-old mainstay of women's health.

FDA experts debate timing of pap test

March 12, 2014
(HealthDay)—The Pap test has been a routine gynecological procedure for generations of American women. But on Wednesday, a Food and Drug Administration advisory panel is considering whether to delay the Pap test and use ...

DNA alternative to Pap smear sparks medical debate (Update)

April 15, 2014
A high-tech screening tool for cervical cancer is facing pushback from more than a dozen American patient groups, who warn that the genetic test could displace a simpler, cheaper and more established mainstay of women's health: ...

Recommended for you

First time mums with an epidural who lie down more likely to have a normal birth

October 18, 2017
Adopting a lying down position rather than being upright in the later stages of labour for first-time mothers who have had a low dose epidural leads to a higher chance of them delivering their baby without any medical intervention, ...

Mice delivered by C-section gain more weight than those delivered naturally

October 11, 2017
Mice born by Caesarian section gained on average 33 percent more weight in the 15 weeks after weaning than mice born vaginally, with females gaining 70 percent more weight.

Study shows epidurals don't slow labor

October 10, 2017
Epidural analgesia - a mix of anesthetics and narcotics delivered by catheter placed close to the nerves of the spine - is the most effective method of labor pain relief. In widespread use since the 1970s, epidurals have ...

Progesterone does not prevent preterm birth or complications, says study

October 3, 2017
An increasingly popular hormonal "treatment" for pregnant women with a history of preterm birth does not work, a major new international study shows.

Study questions practice of placenta eating by new moms

September 29, 2017
(HealthDay)—You may have heard that some new mothers choose to eat their own placenta after childbirth. But there's no indication the trendy practice offers any health benefits, and some evidence it could prove dangerous, ...

Hope for couples suffering IVF miscarriage

September 20, 2017
Women who miscarry during their first full round of IVF are more likely to have a baby after further treatment than women who don't get pregnant at all.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.