Underage drinkers' brand preferences vary by race, age, study finds
Bud Light and Budweiser—are uniformly popular among underage drinkers, regardless of age, gender or ethnicity, while certain other brands appear to have a unique appeal to African-American youth drinkers, according to a new study headed by Boston University School of Public Health researchers.
The study, in the Journal of Substance Use, is the first to examine demographic differences in alcohol brand preferences among underage youth. The study was based on a survey of 1,031 youths, ages 13 to 20, who had consumed at least one drink of alcohol in the prior month. Across all demographic groups, Bud Light was 'overwhelmingly' the most popular brand, with a prevalence of past 30-day consumption ranging from19.3 percent among black respondents to 38.2 percent among Hispanic youths. Bud Light also was the most popular brand among female drinkers, with a reported consumption rate of 27.7 percent.
Similarly, Budweiser was popular across all groups, with a prevalence of 14.5 percent among non-Hispanic whites and 17.3 percent among black youths. Smirnoff Malt Beverages also ranked high among all racial and ethnic groups.
The study found that 12 alcohol brands among the top 25 preferred brands for black youth drinkers did not appear at all on the top 25 list for non-Hispanic white youth—among them, Hennessy cognac, Ciroc vodka and 1800 tequila. Also, there were three popular brands among Hispanic youths that were not among the top 25 for non-Hispanic white drinkers—Dos Equis, Tecate and Modelo Especial.
The authors, led by Michael Siegel, MD, professor of community health sciences at BUSPH, said the difference in brand preferences by race was the most striking finding. The study is the latest in ongoing research into youth drinking by BUSPH and the Center on Alcohol Marketing and Youth at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
"We need to look at the reasons for the observed racial and ethnic differences in brand popularity," Siegel said. He said previous research suggests one possible hypothesis: urban music (rap, hip/hop and R&B), to which black youths are more heavily exposed, disproportionately contains more alcohol brand references. For each of the 12 top brands cited only by black youths, there are either lyrics to popular songs that reference those brands, or direct promotion of the brands through rap artists or concert sponsorships, he said.
Broken down by age, young drinkers favored liquor brands as they got older. For 13- to 15-year olds, only seven of the top 25 brands were liquor, but among 19 to 20 year olds, 13 of the top 25 were liquor. For example, consumption of Jack Daniel's bourbon increased from 5.8 percent among the youngest group to 16.8 percent among the oldest group.
The study found that the popularity of flavored alcohol beverage brands declined generally with age, but there were some exceptions, including Smirnoff vodka and Bacardi run. Certain flavored drinks—especially Smirnoff, Mike's and Bartles & Jaymes—were about twice as popular among female underage drinkers as among males. Generally, liquor was more popular among men than women.
Siegel said the next step in ongoing research into youth drinking is to examine the associations between demographic brand preferences and targeted brand marketing toward different youth subgroups. If brand preferences are fueled by differential advertising exposure, he said, then "public health interventions and policies can be directed towards reducing underage youths' exposure to these brand promotions."