Could campaigns like Dry January do more harm than good?

January 13, 2016

Could alcohol abstinence campaigns like Dry January do more harm than good? Two experts debate the issue in The BMJ today.

Lack of evidence that such campaigns work and don't have unintended consequences, concerns Ian Hamilton, a lecturer at York University.

The Dry January campaign estimates that "Last year over 2 million people cut down their drinking for January," he writes. But popular doesn't necessarily mean effective, and he argues that this type of campaign "has had no rigorous evaluation."

Firstly, it is not clear who Dry January is targeting, he says. Trying to communicate a message about alcohol to the over 65s at the same time as the under 25s "risks the message not being heard, as the way these groups use alcohol is likely to be different."

"Many of us can be economical with the truth when it comes to how much we drink," he adds. If people aren't honest with themselves about their drinking, how can Dry January help?

Dry January also risks sending out an "all or nothing" message about alcohol, and could be adding to the confusion we know exists in communicating messages about alcohol, he warns. For example, in public health advice about safe levels of using recommended maximum daily or weekly units of alcohol.

Although not the intention, people may view their 31 days of abstinence as permission to return to hazardous levels of consumption till next New Year's day, he writes.

He also points out that, for some heavy drinkers, abrupt abstention from alcohol can induce serious symptoms such as seizures.

"In sum, parched of evidence Dry January could have unintended consequences which would do more harm than good," he concludes.

But Ian Gilmore, honorary professor at Liverpool University, thinks such campaigns are likely to help people at least reflect on their drinking.

He points out that in the UK, our per capita consumption of alcohol has doubled over 40 years, and we have 1.5 million heavily dependent drinkers in this country.

So what could possibly be wrong with encouraging and supporting the estimated two million or so adults who decide on Dry January - to take a month off the booze after the festive period and have time to reflect on their drinking, he asks?

He points to an independent evaluation of 2015's Dry January by Public Health England showing that 67% of participants said they had had a sustained drop in their drinking six months on.

An earlier evaluation by the University of Sussex found that 79% of participants said they saved money, 62% said they slept better and had more energy, and 49% said they lost weight.

It should be stressed that the campaign is aimed at social not dependent drinkers, he says, and heavy drinkers are recommended to see their GP before stopping suddenly and completely. "But evaluations indicate that campaigns like Dry January are being used more as a way of people examining their relationship with alcohol and making longer term changes."

Release of the UK chief medical officers' guidelines on drinking is timely, he adds, with their emphasis on having several -free days each week, and this should be a focus for further research.

But until we know of something better, "let's support growing grass-roots movements like Dry January and Dry July in Australia and take a month off," he concludes.

Explore further: Dry January leads to less drinking all year round

More information: Could alcohol abstinence campaigns like Dry January do more harm than good? The BMJ www.bmj.com/cgi/doi/10.1136/bmj.i143

Related Stories

Dry January leads to less drinking all year round

November 17, 2014
Giving up alcohol completely during January reduces harmful drinking all year round, new University of Sussex research has found.

Men told to drink far less alcohol in new UK guidelines

January 7, 2016
Guidelines on alcohol intake for men have been slashed by a third in new advice issued by Britain's chief medical officers Friday.

"None for me, thanks"—social impact of changing alcohol habits

October 26, 2015
Drinking alcohol is a large aspect of Australian culture but what happens when someone decides to stop drinking or cut back their alcohol consumption?

Questions and answers about new UK drinking guidelines

January 8, 2016
British health officials say drinking any alcohol regularly increases the risk of cancer, and have issued tough new guidelines that could be hard to swallow in a nation where having a pint is a hallowed tradition.

One in five over-65s who drink alcohol do so at unsafe levels

August 23, 2015
One in five older people who drink alcohol are consuming it at unsafe levels - over 21 units of alcohol for men and 14 units for women each week - according to a study by King's College London. The research in inner-city ...

New smartphone app warns drinkers if they go over recommended daily/weekly units

July 6, 2015
A new smartphone app warns drinkers if they go over the recommended maximum daily/weekly units of alcohol, to help them better manage their intake, reveals a commentary published in the online journal BMJ Innovations.

Recommended for you

New shoe makes running 4 percent easier, 2-hour marathon possible, study shows

November 17, 2017
Eleven days after Boulder-born Shalane Flanagan won the New York City Marathon in new state-of-the-art racing flats known as "4%s," University of Colorado Boulder researchers have published the study that inspired the shoes' ...

Vaping while pregnant could cause craniofacial birth defects, study shows

November 16, 2017
Using e-cigarettes during pregnancy could cause birth defects of the oral cavity and face, according to a recent Virginia Commonwealth University study.

Study: For older women, every movement matters

November 16, 2017
Folding your laundry or doing the dishes might not be the most enjoyable parts of your day. But simple activities like these may help prolong your life, according to the findings of a new study in older women led by the University ...

When vegetables are closer in price to chips, people eat healthier, study finds

November 16, 2017
When healthier food, like vegetables and dairy products, is pricier compared to unhealthy items, like salty snacks and sugary sweets, Americans are significantly less likely to have a high-quality diet, a new Drexel University ...

Children's exposure to secondhand smoke may be vastly underestimated by parents

November 15, 2017
Four out of 10 children in the US are exposed to secondhand smoke, according to the American Heart Association. A new Tel Aviv University study suggests that parents who smoke mistakenly rely on their own physical senses ...

How pomegranate extract alters breast cancer stem cell properties

November 15, 2017
A University at Albany research team has found evidence suggesting that the same antioxidant that gives pomegranate fruit their vibrant red color can alter the characteristics of breast cancer stem cells, showing the superfood's ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.