Singing improves speech of people with Parkinson's, but more research needed

June 3, 2016 by Euan Wemyss, University of Aberdeen
Singing may have benefits for people with Parkinson's disease, according to a new review. Credit: University of Aberdeen

There is strong evidence that singing benefits the speech of people with Parkinson's disease, but more research needs to be carried out into the area, according to a review of studies led by researchers at the University of Aberdeen.

In collaboration with clinicians at Guy's and St Thomas's Hospital and St Helier Hospital in London, the team conducted a of published evidence regarding the beneficial effects of for people with Parkinson's. The results have been published in the Journal of Parkinson's Disease.

They found that most studies supported the idea that singing helps the of people with Parkinson's. They also found that more studies are required to assess whether this benefit can lead to functional communication as opposed to just physical speech features in people with Parkinson's disease.

They also concluded that a more thorough assessment needed to be carried out with regard to the impact on quality of life.

Lead researcher Dr Maxwell Barnish noted that, "this is a promising field, but one that requires more research if the maximum benefit is going to be harnessed".

Parkinson's and existing therapies

Parkinson's disease is a common, age-related neurodegenerative condition that affects over 120,000 people in the UK and continues to become more common. Treatment has traditionally focused on drugs. These have improved movement, but have had little impact on many other symptoms of Parkinson's and often have serious side effects.

Allied health services such as speech and language therapy may be beneficial, although evidence for many current techniques is not particularly strong.

In recent years, there has been interest in how performing arts, including singing, may be beneficial for people with conditions such as Parkinson's. Choirs for people with neurological conditions can now be found in many locations.

Singing provides great benefit to many people regardless of their health status. These benefits may be psychosocial as well as physical.

Systematic Review

The review aims to serve two purposes - to encourage further high-quality research into this area and to draw clinicians' attention to the therapeutic possibilities that singing offers.

Dr Barnish adds: "Singing might be an approach that speech and language therapists wish to explore using as part of their therapy and healthcare providers might wish to develop further partnerships with community-based performing arts organisations. These partnerships already exist in some localities and the benefits for the people involved and society are clear to see."

Sharing her personal experiences, investigator Susannah Barran from Guy's and St Thomas' Hospital in London, where she is a speech and language therapist and conducts a choir, said: "Singing provides a vital bolster for our physical, emotional and spiritual wellbeing. It's something we do naturally, without even realising it, when we're happy and it's often infectious. Our voices are instruments we can carry with us everywhere, to share with others, or to sing on our own, and that's empowering. Singing in groups can 'break the ice' - it helps us to feel a sense of belonging and feel less lonely."

Investigator Rachel Atkinson, an adult neurological specialist speech and language therapist at St Helier Hospital in London, added: "You only have to turn on your TV to learn about the potential benefits of choirs for more than just the singing these days. This review is greatly beneficial in highlighting the need for further research in this area and exploring readily accessible community singing groups as a source of support and therapeutic benefit for people with Parkinson's disease.

She adds: "This review reminds us as a profession to think outside the box and encourage community activities in addition to traditional clinic-based therapy to facilitate broader social activity and participation for our client groups."

Explore further: 'Slow thinking' a conversation stopper for people with Parkinson's

Related Stories

'Slow thinking' a conversation stopper for people with Parkinson's

March 17, 2016
Cognitive impairment could affect the conversational ability of people with Parkinson's more than physical speech problems - according to research from the University of East Anglia (UEA) and the University of Aberdeen.

Choral singing therapy may lead to improved quality of life for stroke survivors

September 16, 2015
Singing in a choir can improve the feelings of social isolation and low mood experienced by stroke survivors with aphasia (communication difficulties) according to new research from the University of the West of England (UWE ...

Choir singing boosts immune system activity in cancer patients and carers, study shows

April 5, 2016
Singing in a choir for just one hour boosts levels of immune proteins in people affected by cancer, reduces stress and improves mood, which in turn could have a positive impact on overall health, a new study by Tenovus Cancer ...

Current therapy for patients with Parkinson's disease shown to be ineffective

January 19, 2016
New research from the University of Birmingham has shown that physiotherapy and occupational therapy do not produce improvements in quality of life for patients with mild to moderate Parkinson's disease.

The effects of laxatives may provide new clues concerning Parkinson's disease

May 19, 2016
In a recent retrospective analysis, investigators discovered that the year-on-year increase in rigidity found in Parkinson's disease flattened off with the regular use of laxatives to manage constipation.

First large scale community study into the value of group singing for older people with lung disease

January 30, 2013
The research was undertaken by Canterbury Christ church University's Sidney De Haan Research Centre for Arts and Health, following a grant of £130,000 from The Dunhill Medical Trust.

Recommended for you

Researchers trace Parkinson's damage in the heart

July 13, 2018
A new way to examine stress and inflammation in the heart will help Parkinson's researchers test new therapies and explore an unappreciated way the disease puts people at risk of falls and hospitalization.

Study raises doubts on a previous theory of Parkinson's disease

July 6, 2018
Parkinson's disease was first described by a British doctor more than 200 years ago. The exact causes of this neurodegenerative disease are still unknown. In a study recently published in eLife, a team of researchers led ...

Drug protects neurons in Parkinson's disease

June 27, 2018
Systemic treatment of animal models with israpidine, a calcium channel inhibitor, reduced mitochondrial stress that might cause Parkinson's disease, according to a Northwestern Medicine study published in the Journal of Clinical ...

Half of those on Parkinson's drugs may develop impulse control problems

June 20, 2018
Over time, half of the people taking certain drugs for Parkinson's disease may develop impulse control disorders such as compulsive gambling, shopping or eating, according to a study published in the June 20, 2018, online ...

New evidence sheds light on how Parkinson's disease may happen

June 14, 2018
Researchers at Baylor College of Medicine and Texas Children's Hospital have identified unexpected new key players in the development of an early onset form of Parkinson's disease called Parkinsonism. These key players are ...

Scientists unravel molecular mechanisms of Parkinson's disease

June 12, 2018
Detailed brain cell analysis has helped researchers uncover new mechanisms thought to underlie Parkinson's disease.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.