Concerns over inconsistent palliative care provision across England

February 28, 2017, British Medical Journal

Palliative and end-of-life care are not being considered as core services by clinical commissioning groups (CCGs) in some parts of England, with a vast degree of variation across different services and regions, reveals an analysis published in BMJ Supportive and Palliative Care.

The results show CCGs are not using standardised information about their population to commission services and there is confusion about who is responsible for service provision. This means patient choice at the end of life cannot always be honoured and it creates a 'postcode lottery'.

The study reveals that out-of-hours services rely heavily on hospices rather than NHS funding and less than half of CCGs have plans to review or update services.

Previous work has identified recurrent failings in the provision of end-of-life and specialist . However, since the 2012 Health and Social Care Act came into force, which requires CCGs to provide such services, there has been no assessment on the provision of palliative care services across England.

Therefore, a team led by Professor Baroness Ilora Finlay sent freedom of information requests to all 209 CCGs across England in 2015 to assess their commissioning of palliative and end-of-life care services.

The findings reveal:

  • Of 81 CCG respondents, only 29 provided information about the number of patients with palliative care needs in their population
  • CCGs had budgets ranging from £51.83 to £2,329.19 per patient per annum for palliative care services. The fluctuating budget supports concerns about a 'postcode lottery'
  • Of 204 CCG respondents, 83% commission 7-day specialist palliative care services in patients' own homes, but out-of-hours services rely heavily on hospice-led services
  • Of 204 CCG respondents, 31% commission pain control teams, but the majority of these only operate in regular working hours
  • And 68% reported commissioning palliative care education for healthcare professionals, but the type of educational support was hugely varied
  • Under half (45%) of the 194 CCGs that responded said they do not have plans to update or review their . Furthermore, there is "no current national initiative in place to monitor how often services are reviewed, or to support CCGs in developing their services and sharing best practice"

"This study goes some way to provide evidence that while there is excellent specialist palliative care provision in parts of England, there is a vast degree of variation across the country," explain the researchers.

"Most strikingly, there is little uniformity in the data CCGs are required to hold, and disparity in the responsibility of service provision between CCGs, Trusts and local hospices."

"As a result, a paucity of services means that patient choice at the end of life cannot always be honoured and unless national guidelines are put in place to support CCGs in commissioning care, the deficits described in the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman report Dying without Dignity will not be addressed," they warn.

They recommend the Welsh Palliative Care Strategy should be used as a best practice model, in which staffing levels have been determined within the available funding, and a dedicated number of palliative care beds ensures fair access to palliative care across 7 days.

The authors conclude "devolution of decision making down to CCGs suggests that palliative care provision is not being considered as a core in some parts of England. Despite much evidence of its cost efficacy, the provision of specialist palliative care is in need of a national framework to ensure that patients achieve good everywhere."

Explore further: The BMJ reveals private firms run one-third of CCGs' schemes to screen GP referrals

More information: Commissioning of specialist palliative care services in England, BMJ Supportive & Palliative Care, spcare.bmj.com/lookup/doi/10.1 … mjspcare-2016-001119

Related Stories

The BMJ reveals private firms run one-third of CCGs' schemes to screen GP referrals

January 4, 2017
Clinical commissioning groups (CCGs) in England are spending millions of pounds on schemes that screen patient referrals from GPs to specialist services, reveals an investigation by The BMJ today.

Researchers call for improving end-of-life care at home

July 6, 2016
A study from Oxford University has looked at how out-of-hours GP services are being used to support patients dying at home.

ASCO updates guidelines on integration of palliative care

November 2, 2016
(HealthDay)—The American Society of Clinical Oncology Clinical Practice Guideline on the integration of palliative care into standard oncology care has been updated. The update was published online Oct. 28 in the Journal ...

Scotland launches world's first national atlas of palliative care

September 23, 2016
The first Scottish Atlas of Palliative Care has been by University of Glasgow academics at a major palliative care conference in Edinburgh.

'Mystery shopper' study finds barriers to palliative care at major cancer centers

September 7, 2016
A team of researchers, using a novel approach, found that while many cancer centers offer palliative and supportive care services, patients may face challenges when trying to access them. The study showed that expanding awareness ...

Some cancer center staff uncertain of services offered

September 21, 2016
(HealthDay)—Staff members at nearly one in 10 major U.S. cancer centers—all of which provide palliative care services—weren't certain such symptom-management and supportive care was actually available there, according ...

Recommended for you

Experts caution study on plastics in humans is premature

October 23, 2018
Scientists in Austria say they've detected tiny bits of plastic in people's stool for the first time, but experts caution the study is too small and premature to draw any credible conclusion.

Can organic food help you reduce your risk of cancer? A new study suggests the answer may be yes

October 22, 2018
To reduce your risk of cancer, you know you should quit smoking, exercise regularly, wear sunscreen, and take advantage of screening tests. New research suggests another item might be added to this list: Choose organic foods ...

A topical gel that can prevent nerve damage due to spraying crops with pesticides

October 22, 2018
A team of researchers affiliated with several institutions in India has developed a topical get that can be used by farmers to prevent nerve damage due to chemical crop spraying. In their paper published in the journal Science ...

Moderate exercise before conception resulted in lower body weight, increased insulin sensitivity of offspring

October 22, 2018
Men who want to have children in the near future should consider hitting the gym.

Modern conflict: Screen time vs. nature

October 22, 2018
Even rural kids today spend more time in front of screens and less time outdoors, according to a new study of middle-school students in South Carolina.

Community health workers can reduce hospitalizations by 65 percent and double patient satisfaction with primary care

October 22, 2018
Community health workers—trusted laypeople from local communities who help high-risk patients to address social issues like food and housing insecurity—can help reduce hospital stays by 65 percent and double the rate ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.