Is transgender identity inherited?

March 3, 2017 by Ricki Lewis, Phd, Plos Blogs
Is transgender identity inherited?

The recent return of the "which bathroom?" issue regarding transgender individuals' use of public restrooms has made me think about how I've handled sex and gender in my human genetics textbook. Over the editions, the two topics have diverged. And that's at the crux of misunderstanding.

Sex and gender through the editions

When I wrote the first edition in 1993, coverage of the X and Y chromosomes that make us female or male (sex determination) was squished into a chapter on genetic linkage. I didn't mention at all.

By the second edition, "Matters of Sex" was its own chapter, starting with a table called "Sexual Identity." The last entry was "gender identity," defined as "Strong feelings of being male or female, from childhood."

In early 1998, while writing the third edition, I read John Colapinto's unforgettable article in Rolling Stone (summarized by Colapinto here) about David Reimer (1965-2004). After David's penis was removed following a botched circumcision, his parents were pressured into raising him as a girl, and the infant underwent the first "sex reassignment" surgery performed on an anatomically normal individual. It's a complex tale. The physician regarded David (then named Brenda) as part of a science experiment of sorts by comparing her to his identical twin Brian.

Brenda/David, however, always knew he was a he, preferring boys' games and attire, even peeing standing up without knowing why. When a psychiatrist finally told him of his beginnings at age 14, David sought surgery to return to his male origin.

With David's help, Colapinto published "As Nature Made Him: The Boy Who Was Raised As A Girl " in 2000. About that time, I wrote an article, "Reevaluating Sex Reassignment", for The Scientist, concluding from interviewing experts that "Both clinical trials and case reports powerfully argue for nature over nurture in establishing gender identity." On the surface, that statement could mean that a baby with a penis becomes a man and a baby with a vagina becomes a woman, no matter what. But it also argues for the power of knowing one's gender, whether one has the corresponding anatomy or not.

David Reimer's sad story entered my textbook with the third edition. The next leap in my coverage of gender happened after I met Jennifer Finney Boylan, who was born James.

My daughter Heather and I met Jennifer at a bookstore in 2003, just before publication of Jennifer's book She's Not There: A Life in Two Genders. Today she's an outspoken transgender author who predicted in a New York Times op-ed just after the election that the new president would throw out President Obama's protection of the right of transgender students to use school bathrooms matching their gender identity. Sadly she was right, even though just last April candidate Trump said that people should "use the bathroom they feel is appropriate."

At the bookstore all those years ago, Jennifer stayed afterwards to talk with Heather, who was at the time contemplating her future career as a social worker. Jennifer's bravery and kindness impressed both of us. No one would go through what she did for something trivial, for just a feeling.

So my next textbook edition included this paragraph:

"Transgender is a poorly understood condition related to . A transgendered individual has the phenotype and sex chromosomes of one gender, but identifies extremely strongly with the opposite gender. It is a much more profound condition than transvestitism, which refers to a male who prefers women's clothing. The genetic or physical basis of transgender is not known. Some affected individuals have surgery to better match their physical selves with the gender that they feel certain they are."

It was a start. I should have replaced "feel" with "are." To my astonishment, when drafts of that edition were reviewed, instructors asked that the paragraph be removed, because they felt identifying as transgender had nothing to do with genetics.

I refused. We can't say a characteristic isn't genetic just because we don't yet have any evidence. But in the next few editions, I fielded the same request, and again ignored it. Writing a textbook brings an authority beyond a mere article or blog post, and I wanted people wondering about the role of genetics in transgender identities, and taking a course in human genetics to at least find a definition in their textbook.

Is transgender identity inherited?

Meanwhile, I started to wonder if certain genotypes in some way contribute to the overwhelming sense that gender doesn't match genes, chromosomes, or gonads.

Here's what we know: Bio 101

Sex is set, or "determined," when an X chromosome from an egg finds itself in a nucleus with an X or a Y from a sperm. XX=female: XY=male.

For six weeks, the embryo unfurls two sets of "indifferent" gonads, with two sets of plumbing. At week 6, a gene on the Y called SRY, for "sex determining region of the Y," turns on and the fledgling female parts shrivel away. Without SRY, and under guidance of other genes, the male structures vanish instead. So anatomically we all start out with a bit of both.

Mess with the genes and chromosomes behind our sexuality, and mismatches arise. A mutation in a gene called Wnt4, for example, disables the switch to femaleness, and an XX embryo drowns in testosterone. Vagina, cervix, and uterus never develop. In fact, SRY was discovered in people who looked female but were XYs missing SRY, and people who looked male but were XXs with an SRY gene plunked onto one of the X's. Another type of female with XY chromosomes has androgen insensitivity syndrome, lacking receptors on cells that bind testosterone, cutting of the hormonal signals necessary for maleness. Several historical figures supposedly had this condition.

Most fascinating is 5-alpha reductase deficiency, in which life begins as a girl, based on appearance. The enzyme to convert testosterone into the form needed to sculpt a penis isn't there, and so external male structures don't develop early on, although interior structures are male. At puberty, the adrenal glands release testosterone, as they normally do, and then the voice deepens, facial hair grows, muscles become leaner, and instead of developing breasts and menstruating, the clitoris swells into a penis and sperm are produced.

In the Dominican Republic, where 5-alpha reductase deficiency is more common due to relatives marrying relatives awhile back, these special adolescents are given their own gender name— guevedoces, for "penis at age 12" – and are fully accepted as whatever they want to be. Most become fertile males. Discovery of the fact that guevedoces have small prostates led to development of the drug finasteride, which inhibits 5-alpha reductase and is used to treat enlarged prostate. The Pulitzer-prize-winning novel Middlesex, by Jeffrey Eugenides, tells the story of a young man with the condition. It's one of my all-time favorite books.

So the X and Y chromosomes determine sex, unless a single-gene mutation intervenes and then they don't. Could gene variants, perhaps specific sets of them, somehow set the stage for the gestation of a transgender individual? For the upcoming twelfth edition of my textbook, I took a look.

Scant evidence for transgender genes

A genome-wide association study (GWAS) might be the way to go to identify genes that have variants that affect gender identity. Scan the genomes of a few hundred or thousand transgender individuals and a similar number of controls, perhaps their cisgender siblings, for a few million SNPs (single nucleotide polymorphisms; places in the genome where a DNA base varies in a population). Identify gene variants shared only among the trans. Then look in those genome regions for genes whose functions make sense – this might be more objective than rounding up the usual suspects, such as hormone receptors and enzymes needed to synthesize steroids.

Here's what I found:

23andme indeed conducted a GWAS in 2005, but on sexual orientation — hetero, homo, and bi. Not the same thing.

A 2008 study found a SNP in CYP17, making it a "candidate" gene for transgender individuals. Trans men were more likely to have the variant than cis women. The gene controls sex hormone production.

A just-completed clinical trial ruled out the 5-alpha reductase penis-at-12 gene (SRD5A2) as a candidate.

That's it. Or at least all I could find. Although clinicaltrials.gov lists 58 studies under "transgender," nothing much comes up in the way of genetics. The closest was the "exploration of the neovagina" study to investigate ways to entice a vaginal microbiome to flourish in a surgically created organ.

A genomewide SNP screen, or even genome sequencing, might one day identify a genetic "signature" for individuals more likely to identify as transgender. Should we even go there? I don't think so. What good could it do? People who identify as already know it – it's certain others who have a problem with it. And imagine new parents of a girl told she will identify as a boy, or vice versa. What would they do? I'd say just wait and see. Let it be.

I'm not a psychologist and clearly out of my depth when matters get beyond genes and . Comments welcome! (Are any other nerds glad to hear cis and trans outside of the context of rotation around a double carbon bond or the orientation of allele pairs?)

Explore further: The transgender 'bathroom bill': Who wants it—men or women?

More information: Teenus Paramel Jayaprakash et al. High Diversity and Variability in the Vaginal Microbiome in Women following Preterm Premature Rupture of Membranes (PPROM): A Prospective Cohort Study, PLOS ONE (2016). DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0166794

Related Stories

The transgender 'bathroom bill': Who wants it—men or women?

December 19, 2016
Most women are not bothered much about the fact that they might at times share public bathrooms designated for females with transgender women who were registered as men at birth. Men on the other hand take umbrage, and worry ...

Study uncovers high prevalence of military sexual trauma among transgender veterans

November 21, 2016
New research found a high prevalence of military sexual trauma (MST) among transgender veterans and an association between the experience of MST and certain mental health conditions.

Trans and gender-fluid teens left with few 'safe harbors'

February 28, 2017
Transgender and gender-fluid teens, particularly those born male, face up to three times more mental and physical abuse at school and at home than their gender-conforming peers, according to a new study from UC Berkeley.

Review article provides evidence on the biological nature of gender identity

February 13, 2015
Medical care of transgender patients, including surgical and hormonal treatment, has largely been met with resistance by physicians in favor of psychiatric treatment, owing to misconceptions that gender identity can be changed. ...

New study highlights high rates of suicide and self-harm among transgender youth

August 31, 2016
In a new study, 30 percent of transgender youth report a history of at least one suicide attempt, and nearly 42 percent report a history of self-injury, such as cutting.

Recommended for you

Pickled in 'cognac', Chopin's heart gives up its secrets

November 26, 2017
The heart of Frederic Chopin, among the world's most cherished musical virtuosos, may finally have given up the cause of his untimely death.

Sugar industry withheld evidence of sucrose's health effects nearly 50 years ago

November 21, 2017
A U.S. sugar industry trade group appears to have pulled the plug on a study that was producing animal evidence linking sucrose to disease nearly 50 years ago, researchers argue in a paper publishing on November 21 in the ...

Female researchers pay more attention to sex and gender in medicine

November 7, 2017
When women participate in a medical research paper, that research is more likely to take into account the differences between the way men and women react to diseases and treatments, according to a new study by Stanford researchers.

Drug therapy from lethal bacteria could reduce kidney transplant rejection

August 3, 2017
An experimental treatment derived from a potentially deadly microorganism may provide lifesaving help for kidney transplant patients, according to an international study led by investigators at Cedars-Sinai.

Exploring the potential of human echolocation

June 25, 2017
People who are visually impaired will often use a cane to feel out their surroundings. With training and practice, people can learn to use the pitch, loudness and timbre of echoes from the cane or other sounds to navigate ...

Team eradicates hepatitis C in 10 patients following lifesaving transplants from infected donors

April 30, 2017
Ten patients at Penn Medicine have been cured of the Hepatitis C virus (HCV) following lifesaving kidney transplants from deceased donors who were infected with the disease. The findings point to new strategies for increasing ...

2 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

tchase
not rated yet Mar 03, 2017
For a while I psychologically needed a biological basis. Now, I would like some biological affirmation as a tool to use against bigotry, but also because also to satisfy my scientific curiosity.

On the other hand, there might be multiple paths to which one becomes transgender. Identification of a specific gene or gene combination would result in an inappropriate classification of "true gender identity" from "pretender".

This could make it even more difficult for those that do not possess the genetic traits to "confirm" their deeply felt gender identity. I am conflicted, but am leaning towards keeping this as something better off not known for the safety of those that would be excluded.
BubbaNicholson
1 / 5 (1) Mar 04, 2017
Transgender feelings result from a paternal facial skin surface pheromone deficiency. Pheromone reception habits are transmitted culturally. Pheromone reception difficulties (e.g. PBP in tears) can be inherited. The paternal facial skin surface pheromone deficiency is cured by 250mg of healthy adult male facial skin surface sebaceous lipid p.o. on fresh, un-chewed chewing gum (used both to collect and administer the pheromone).
The collected skin surface pheromone emits an airborne subset of it's 735 chemicals which causes irritation, arrogance, suspicion, and distrust. (Chems have pheromonal stereochemistry.) Thus, sealed packaging of the gum with activated charcoal, fume hood storage, and both supplied air respirators and oscillating fans for administering personnel are all needed countermeasures.
Osculation partners of trans pheromone recipients become artificially jealous, so isolate socially for the 40 days needed to clear the pheromone from saliva.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.