Respiratory experts urge rethink of 'outdated' asthma categorisation

September 12, 2017 by Ryan O'hare, Imperial College London
Credit: Imperial College London

A group of respiratory medicine experts have called for an overhaul of how asthma and other airways diseases are categorised and treated.

The team, which includes researchers from the University of Oxford and Imperial College London, says the current approach is outdated and does not reflect advances in treating these conditions.

Outlining their views in a specially commissioned article in The Lancet, the 23 international experts – co-chaired by University of Oxford Professor of Respiratory Medicine Ian Pavord, and Andy Bush, Professor of Paediatric Respirology at Imperial –  say that progress in treating asthma has slowed in the past 10 years despite increased spending on treatments, and has not matched that enjoyed in other medical fields.

"We believe that the most important cause of this stagnation is a continued reliance on outdated and unhelpful labels, treatment and research frameworks, and monitoring strategies, which have reached the stage of unchallenged veneration and have subsequently stifled new thinking," the experts in the Lancet Commission say.

Asthma is responsible for considerable global morbidity and health-care costs. A study by Asthma UK last year found that asthma costs the UK health service at least £1.1 billion each year, and that more than 270 people are admitted to hospital each day because of asthma attacks.

Slow progress

Professor Pavord, who leads the Respiratory Theme of the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Oxford Biomedical Research Centre (BRC), said: "Despite considerable progress being made against key outcomes such as mortality and hospital admissions in the 1990s and early 2000s, we've seen far too little progress in the past 10 years, despite escalating treatment costs and the availability of highly effective treatments."

"This Commission has sought to identify entrenched areas of asthma management and treatment in which progress has stalled, and to challenge current principles. It's a call to action for all clinicians involved in this field."

Writing in The Lancet, the authors argue that the physiology-based classification system for airways diseases is obsolete because it provides a limited view of the distinct causes of morbidity and mortality in patients with asthma.

Instead, they believe airways diseases should be deconstructed into traits that can be measured and, in some cases, modified.

A new approach

Looking at how this new approach can be made a reality in all healthcare settings, the commission calls for a fundamental rethink of the current guidelines, with greater emphasis on traits that can be measured and treated, and less emphasis on arbitrary disease labels.

This means that inhaled corticosteroids – the standard for controlling – would be used in a more targeted and efficient way, based on biomarkers, and should not be escalated unless the biomarker profile suggests treatment will be successful.

In addition, they call for a rethink around how asthma attacks are treated, arguing that should be considered as a prompt for "thorough re-evaluation of asthma management in the patient".

Finally, the respiratory experts call for an ambitious "revolution in thinking about asthma that is generalisable to all airways diseases". This would lead to the delivery of better and more precise care to each patient, separating airways diseases into component parts and addressing each in turn, stratified by risk.

Commenting on the findings, Professor Bush said: "Challenging how we think about asthma and how the condition is classified will, we believe, lead to an important step change in the management of the disease. 

"We want patients to be asking 'what sort of asthma do I have?', just as a patient with red, painful joints will ask 'what sort of arthritis do I have?', because we believe asthma is a clinical description of symptoms, for which there are many different causes.

He added: "Ultimately, by looking at the components of airway disease in each individual, rather than being satisfied with the umbrella term 'asthma', we believe  will enable treatment to be personalised allowing patients  of all ages living with asthma to lead fuller, healthier lives."

Professor Pavord concluded: "This commission feels it is time for a new era in , where it is more about getting the right to the right – so, a precision medicine approach rather than the one-size-fits-all approach we've been doing up until now."

Explore further: Study compares treatment and outcomes in asthma patients in two countries

More information: Ian D Pavord et al. After asthma: redefining airways diseases, The Lancet (2017). DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(17)30879-6

Related Stories

Study compares treatment and outcomes in asthma patients in two countries

August 9, 2017
In two countries with a Western lifestyle, similar health systems, and similar asthma prevalence, investigators observed differences in asthma management and treatment costs, despite comparable outcomes.

Maternal uncontrolled asthma ups risk of asthma in offspring

July 17, 2017
(HealthDay)—Children whose mothers have uncontrolled asthma during pregnancy are at increased risk of developing the disease at a young age, according to a study published online July 13 in the Journal of Allergy and Clinical ...

Study links optimal asthma control with reduced health-care costs

November 10, 2016
In a study of 736 asthma patients in Singapore, good asthma control resulted in a saving of S$65 (US$48) per physician visit. Compared with an average cost of S$214 (US$158) per visit, this reduction represents a cost saving ...

Study brings hope of a new treatment for asthma sufferers

March 1, 2017
Improved treatments for people with severe asthma are a 'step closer' after a research team led by the University of Leicester identified a breakthrough in the cause of airway narrowing.

There's fun and fitness in the pool for asthmatic kids

February 20, 2017
(HealthDay)—Safe, healthy fun for kids with asthma may be as near as the neighborhood pool, one respiratory specialist says.

Bitter taste receptors hold key to treating asthma

April 27, 2017
One in nine Australians, among more than 300 million people worldwide, suffer from asthma. They experience a wide range of debilitating, even life-threatening respiratory symptoms from a disease that can be controlled but ...

Recommended for you

Nicotine mimics may have therapeutic effect on inflammatory diseases

July 12, 2018
Stanford researchers discovered that a receptor that binds to nicotine and to clusters of beta-amyloid molecules is found on certain types of immune cells that can act as suppressors and regulators of the immune system.

Study shows BPA risk factor for inflammatory bowel disease

July 5, 2018
A recent study in a preclinical model of inflammatory bowel disease shows dietary exposure to bisphenol-A, or BPA, found in polycarbonate plastics and epoxy resins, can increase mortality and worsen its symptoms.

Mid- to late-life increases in marker of chronic inflammation tied to dementia

July 2, 2018
Researchers at Johns Hopkins have added to evidence that rising and chronic inflammation as measured by a biomarker in the blood in middle and late age are linked to visible structural changes in the brains of people with ...

Research team diagnoses asthma with nasal brush test

June 11, 2018
Mount Sinai researchers have identified a genetic biomarker of asthma that can be tested for using a simple nasal brush and basic follow-up data analysis. This inexpensive diagnostic test can accurately identify mild to moderate ...

Eosinophilic esophagitis may be due to missing protein

June 7, 2018
Scientists have discovered that the absence of a specific protein in cells lining the esophagus may cause inflammation and tissue damage in people with eosinophilic esophagitis (EoE). EoE affects as many as 150,000 people ...

Mouse study links triclosan, a common antimicrobial, to colonic inflammation

May 30, 2018
A large research team led by senior author Guodong Zhang at the University of Massachusetts Amherst reports that the antimicrobial ingredient triclosan, found in hand soaps and toothpastes among other products, could have ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.