Futile hospital treatments cost millions

October 17, 2017 by Niki Widdowson, Queensland University of Technology
Futile hospital treatments cost millions
Credit: Queensland University of Technology

Non-beneficial treatment of patients who are at the end of their life costs Australia approximately $153.1 million a year, a study published in the British Medical Journal Open today has found.

  • Australia spends an estimated $153 million on non-beneficial, end-of life hospital
  • 41,000 acute hospital bed days each year given to non-beneficial treatment
  • Scarce health resources should bring largest benefit to patients
  • Alternatives to acute hospital stays need to be considered.

The study, led by researchers from The University of Queensland and QUT, analysed the treatment of 907 adult patients who died in three Australian public hospitals over a six-month period in 2012.

Dr Hannah Carter, health economist from QUT and lead author of the article, said that the incidence, duration and cost of non-beneficial treatment varied among the hospitals.

"But we found that, on average, 12.1 per cent of end-of-life patients received non-beneficial treatment during their hospital stay," Dr Carter said.

"For those patients, non-beneficial treatment was provided for an average of 15 days, including 5 days in intensive care.

"If we extrapolate those figures to estimate the national impact of non-beneficial treatment, it comes to 41,222 bed days per year."

Dr Carter said this was the first study to estimate the economic costs of non-beneficial treatment across the whole of a hospital, not just the ICU.

"A total of 55 consultants from many specialities including emergency medicine, internal medicine, oncology, cardiology and palliative care reviewed the cases and indicated the date they believed non-beneficial treatment had begun," she said.

"Our estimates of the number of days of non-beneficial treatment were based on a consensus by these doctors."

Dr Carter said the study did not take into account emotional hardship or pain and suffering to patients and families.

"These aspects would represent additional costs but increasing awareness of the may raise support for alternative end-of-life care that reduces both the financial and emotional ."

Previous studies by the researchers, led by Professors Ben White and Lindy Willmott from QUT's Australian Centre for Health Law Research identified reasons hospitals might provide non-beneficial treatment.

"Non-beneficial or 'futile' treatment is a value-laden and contested term," Professor Willmott said.

"This treatment can prevent from experiencing a 'good death', cause distress to family and medical staff besides using up scarce resources.

"Our research found hospital-specific factors contributed to variability in provision of non-beneficial treatment including the 's degree of specialisation, the availability of routine tests and certain treatments as well as organisational barriers to a palliative pathway.

"To ensure the healthcare system remains sustainable it is important that scarce resources are allocated to treatments that deliver the most patient benefit."

Explore further: End-of-life care doctors consider patient and family needs when deciding to end treatment

Related Stories

End-of-life care doctors consider patient and family needs when deciding to end treatment

May 2, 2016
The first Australian study on how end-of-life care doctors use the term "futile treatment" to make decisions on whether further treatment should be given when a person has no hope of recovery and death is near, has been published ...

New health law website vital for doctors, patients making end-of-life decisions

June 15, 2016
Doctors are trained to treat and cure. It's the key reason why many say they have given futile treatment to dying patients, a QUT study of 96 Brisbane doctors who make end-of-life treatment decisions has found.

New referral pathway cuts palliative radiotherapy wait

September 7, 2017
(HealthDay)—Use of an advanced practice radiation therapist (APRT) may help reduce radiotherapy waiting times for palliative patients, according to a study published Aug. 29 in the Journal of Medical Radiation Sciences.

Acupuncture relieves pain in emergency patients: study

June 19, 2017
The world's largest randomised controlled trial of the use of acupuncture in emergency departments has found the treatment is a safe and effective alternative to pain-relieving drugs for some patients.

Global analysis finds unnecessary end-of-life treatment in hospitals is widespread

June 27, 2016
The largest systematic review of the care of elderly patients hospitalised at the end of their life has found more than a third received invasive and potentially harmful medical treatments.

Burden of futile care in ICU studied: Patients waiting for care affected negatively, study presented

October 28, 2013
Researchers at UCLA studied the opportunity costs of providing futile care to patients in the ICU, finding that care was delayed or compromised for waiting patients when futile care was being provided in a full ICU. Futile ...

Recommended for you

Accurate measurements of sodium intake confirm relationship with mortality

June 21, 2018
Eating foods high in salt is known to contribute to high blood pressure, but does that linear relationship extend to increased risk of cardiovascular disease and death? Recent cohort studies have contested that relationship, ...

Fruit and vegetables linked to changes in skin colour, new research finds

June 21, 2018
Skin colour in young Caucasian men is strongly linked to high levels of fruit and vegetable consumption, new research by Curtin University has found.

Fans of yoga therapy have yet to win over doctors

June 21, 2018
Yoga practitioners often tout the unique health benefits of the ancient discipline—from relieving stress and pain to improving vascular health—but most doctors remain sceptical in the absence of hard proof.

What a pain: The iPad neck plagues women more

June 20, 2018
Is your iPad being a literal pain in the neck?

Medicaid work requirements and health savings accounts may impact people's coverage

June 20, 2018
Current experimental approaches in Medicaid programs—including requirements to pay premiums, contribute to health savings accounts, or to work—may lead to unintended consequences for patient coverage and access, such ...

Introduction of alcohol found to adversely impact fertility rates in hunter-gatherer community

June 19, 2018
Fernando Ramirez Rozzi, a research director with the French National Centre for Scientific Research has found that the introduction of alcohol to a Baka pygmy hunter-gatherer society caused fertility rates to fall. In his ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.