New insights into vaccination debate

October 18, 2017, Flinders University
Credit: Flinders University

Governments wielding a 'big stick' for compliance is unlikely to solve the problem of making parents vaccinate their children.

Flinders University and research colleagues are investigating a less polarising approach to the issue of childhood vaccination refusal or hesitancy.

The findings are described in the paper "Understanding the perceived logic of care by vaccine-hesitant and vaccine-refusing : A qualitative study in Australia" just published in the leading science journal PLOS ONE.

It's estimated that about 2 percent of parents don't vaccinate their children for reasons of refusal. The remainder who are affected by a lack of opportunity or access make up about 4 percent.

"The 2 percent tend to cluster in certain regions – there is clearly a social pattern we need to better understand," says Professor Ward, who says the research team is taking an 'empathic neutral' position in their engagement with participants.

"We need more ethically sustainable ways to address this public issue. This starts with a better understanding – of moving beyond stereotypes and castigation," says Flinders Professor of Public Health Paul Ward.

This could start with a recognition the non-vaccinating parents are conscientious, acknowledging their efforts at intensive parenting, and engage intelligently with them.

Based on in-depth interviews with 29 non-vaccinating parents over three years in Australia, the researchers found many parents who opted for selective or non-vaccination were well educated, middle class and often were distrustful of science, medicine and 'big pharma' marketing.

Credit: Flinders University

"There's been a lack of focus on trying to understand parental decision-making or even creating stereotypes, which to some extent has led to an escalation of the situation and to negative responses such as peer shaming, judgement, or over-emphasising the 'facts' or science," Professor Ward says.

"Our research shows that parents who make decisions not to vaccinate their children are simply trying to do their best for their child's health."

This seems to go hand in hand with various other parenting practices such as eating organic food, breastfeeding longer, reducing harmful chemicals, reducing screen-time, consulting complimentary and alternative practitioners, and so on.

"We interpret our data as a 'logic of care," which is seen by parents as internally consistent, logically inter-related and inter-dependent.

"While not wanting to valorise the decisions not to vaccinate, we argue that an understanding of their attitudes towards health and well-being is imperative for any efforts to engage with their vaccine refusal at a policy level," Professor Ward says.

As well as a new toolkit for communication and messaging, other strategies might include working through trusted health professionals such as midwives and Child and Adolescent health services which support vaccination.

Supporting GPs and nurses to give advice that maintains the relationship with the health care system is also important – as well as working constructively with local communities on issues where there is a shared goal, like child health and illness prevention.

Further research will focus on these strategies in non-vaccination hotspots, including the Northern Rivers area in NSW, Adelaide Hills suburbs in SA, and parts of WA.

Explore further: To overcome vaccination standoffs, doctors should listen to reluctant parents

More information: Paul R. Ward et al. Understanding the perceived logic of care by vaccine-hesitant and vaccine-refusing parents: A qualitative study in Australia, PLOS ONE (2017). DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0185955

Related Stories

To overcome vaccination standoffs, doctors should listen to reluctant parents

August 23, 2017
Vaccines save between two and three million lives per year by protecting individuals from diseases such as measles, mumps, diphtheria, pertussis, tetanus and others. Clean water is the only other public intervention to save ...

Expectant first-time mothers uncertain about vaccinating their children

September 11, 2017
First-time mums are more hesitant and undecided about childhood vaccinations compared to mothers with children and only two thirds of all mothers believe they receive enough information on vaccines during pregnancy.

Why do parents who usually vaccinate their children hesitate or refuse?

December 18, 2014
A new study by Dr. Anat Gesser-Edelsburg, Dr. Yaffa Shir-Raz and Prof. Manfred S. Green from University of Haifa, School of Public Health, published in the Journal of Risk Research suggests that even parents who are not "vaccine ...

A doctor's words key to whether child gets HPV vaccine

September 30, 2016
(HealthDay)—The language doctors use when recommending the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine can influence whether parents will have their children immunized, a new study finds.

Teens may be missing vaccines because parents aren't aware they need one

July 17, 2017
Parents may be up to speed on what vaccines their children need for kindergarten, but may be less sure during high school years, a new national poll suggests.

Vaccinate against measles

March 9, 2015
Future outbreaks of measles can only be prevented by vaccination.

Recommended for you

Just a few minutes of light intensity exercise linked to lower death risk in older men

February 19, 2018
Clocking up just a few minutes at a time of any level of physical activity, including of light intensity, is linked to a lower risk of death in older men, suggests research published online in the British Journal of Sports ...

Calcium and Vitamin D supplements are not associated with risk of heart attacks

February 16, 2018
New research from the University of Southampton has found no association between the use of calcium or vitamin D supplementation and cardiovascular events such as heart attacks.

Women who clean at home or work face increased lung function decline

February 16, 2018
Women who work as cleaners or regularly use cleaning sprays or other cleaning products at home appear to experience a greater decline in lung function over time than women who do not clean, according to new research published ...

Study shows options to decrease risk of motor vehicle crashes for adolescent drivers

February 16, 2018
Adolescents who receive comprehensive and challenging on-road driving assessments prior to taking the license test might be protected from future motor vehicle crashes, according to a University of Alabama at Birmingham study ...

Being a single dad can shorten your life: study

February 15, 2018
The risk of dying prematurely more than doubles for single fathers compared to single mothers or paired-up dads, according to a study of Canadian families published Thursday.

Keeping an eye on the entire ageing process

February 15, 2018
Medical researchers often only focus on a single disease. As older people often suffer from multiple diseases at the same time, however, we need to rethink this approach, writes Ralph Müller.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.