Medicare shift to quality over quantity presents challenges

December 4, 2017 by Julia Evangelou Strait, Washington University School of Medicine
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

A new study hints that even large physician practices may have trouble moving to a payment system that rewards quality of health care over quantity of services delivered. The analysis included data from the first year of a program run by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) and known as the Physician Value-Based Payment Modifier program.

Under the Affordable Care Act, CMS in 2012 began reimbursing U.S. hospitals based on the quality of care they deliver, rather than the quantity. For example, Medicare gives financial bonuses to hospitals that keep readmission rates low, and it does not pay for hospital-acquired conditions, such as bed sores, providing an incentive to prevent them. For CMS to assess quality of care, hospitals must report certain types of data, such as rates of hospital-acquired infections, as indicators of their performance. In 2013, the program expanded to include that provide outside of hospital settings.

Published in the December issue of the journal Health Affairs, the study was conducted by researchers at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis, the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

Across the country, 1,010 practices have at least 100 physicians per practice, which was the threshold for being included in the program's first year. Of these, 899 practices treated at least one Medicare beneficiary and were included in the analysis. Of the 899 practices included, 263 (about 30 percent) did not report data to the program as required by CMS and were penalized for failing to do so. For practices failing to report, CMS withheld 1 percent of their 2015 Medicare physician fee schedule billings.

"Almost one-third of practices got a 1 percent payment penalty because they failed to report performance data," said first author Karen E. Joynt Maddox, MD, an assistant professor of medicine at Washington University. "That's a meaningful amount of money. Why take that financial hit if you don't have to? It suggests that reporting was hard enough that some practices couldn't do it, or elected not to because it was too expensive. This program has the potential to be a big burden.

"We started with the largest practices," Joynt Maddox added. "These are theoretically the most well-resourced and well-equipped practices across the country. And even among these, a large number failed to report. This may reflect the current state of infrastructure in U.S. outpatient practices."

The researchers suggested that CMS should focus on improving this infrastructure by, for example, helping practices obtain electronic data systems that may reduce the time and cost associated with reporting performance data. Such help would be especially important for smaller practices and those that serve racial and ethnic minority groups, practices the study found less likely to report data.

"As this program expands to include all clinicians, I'm concerned there could be unintended consequences, particularly for smaller, under-resourced practices," said Joynt Maddox, also a cardiologist who sees patients at Barnes-Jewish Hospital. "However, CMS recently broadened exemptions so small practices will likely not have to participate initially."

The study also suggests that practices with provide higher quality care at lower cost, and as a result, these practices were less likely to receive financial penalties under the program, and more likely to receive bonuses. Electronic record systems are not necessarily the cause of the improved performance, according to the investigators; it could be that higher performing practices tend to invest in technology.

"In theory, having an electronic health record system should make reporting performance data more straightforward," Joynt Maddox said. "But electronic health record systems are not created equal—some have made it easier than others. And in practices without such systems, a nurse or office manager may be trying to do all the reporting in addition to regular job duties. I think many people are in favor of moving toward a value-based payment system but are also appropriately concerned about how to do it without unfairly harming some physician practices."

Explore further: New RISE registry dashboard will help rheumatologists monitor MIPS quality scores

More information: Joynt Maddox KE, Epstein AM, Samson LW, Chen LM. Performance and participation of physicians in year one of Medicare's value-based payment modifier program. Health Affairs. Dec. 4, 2017.

Related Stories

New RISE registry dashboard will help rheumatologists monitor MIPS quality scores

November 5, 2017
Quality measures reported by rheumatology practices using the RISE registry significantly varied in the first quarter of 2017, with financial repercussions for practices through the new Merit-Based Incentive Payment System ...

2016 physician quality reporting system reports available

October 10, 2017
(HealthDay)—The 2016 Physician Quality Reporting System (PQRS) and the 2016 annual Quality and Resource Use reports have been released for individuals and group practices, according to a report published by the American ...

Pay-for-performance fails to perform

November 28, 2017
A prototype Medicare program designed to improve value of care by paying more to physicians who perform better on measures of health care quality and spending has failed to deliver on its central promise and, in the process, ...

Primary care practices use 4 complementary methods to identify high-risk patients

September 12, 2017
Risk stratified care management—assigning a patient to a risk category on which care is based—is increasingly viewed as a way to improve care and reduce costs.

Care costs lower for practices with more high-needs patients

March 17, 2017
(HealthDay)—Lower spending and utilization are seen for practices with a higher proportion of high-needs patients, according to a study published in the March issue of Health Affairs.

ACR acknowledges CMS efforts to increase flexibility and reduce regulatory burdens

June 22, 2017
The American College of Rheumatology (ACR) today welcomed components of a new proposed rule from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) regarding the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015 (MACRA) ...

Recommended for you

Early physical therapy benefits low-back pain patients

May 22, 2018
Patients with low-back pain are better off seeing a physical therapist first, according to a study of 150,000 insurance claims.

Closing coal, oil power plants leads to healthier babies

May 22, 2018
Shuttering coal- and oil-fired power plants lowers the rate of preterm births in neighboring communities and improves fertility, according to two new University of California, Berkeley, studies.

Insufficient sleep, even without extended wakefulness, leads to performance impairments

May 21, 2018
Millions of individuals obtain insufficient sleep on a daily basis, which can lead to impaired performance and other adverse physiological outcomes. To what extent these impairments are caused by the short sleep duration ...

Avoiding the car for travel could significantly lower risk of illness and death

May 21, 2018
People who are more active when commuting to work by walking or cycling could be cutting their relative risk of developing ischaemic heart disease or stroke by 11% and their relative risk of dying from these diseases by 30%, ...

New study shows higher formaldehyde risk in e-cigarettes than previously thought

May 21, 2018
Portland State University researchers who published an article three years ago in the New England Journal of Medicine about the presence of previously undiscovered forms of formaldehyde in e-cigarette vapor revisited their ...

Sleep better, parent better: Study shows link between maternal sleep and permissive parenting

May 21, 2018
Research has shown that consistently not getting enough sleep, or getting poor quality sleep, can put you at risk for a number of health conditions. But how does sleep, or the lack of it, affect how you parent?

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.