Patients and doctors often disagree in evaluation of surgical scarring

February 1, 2018, Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania
A facial scar immediately after surgery. Credit: Penn Medicine

When it comes to the physical scars surgery leaves behind, a new study shows patients and doctors often don't assess their severity the same way. Researchers from the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania found patients and physicians disagreed in their scar evaluations 28 percent of the time, with patients more likely to focus on the depth of the scar while physicians were more likely to emphasize coloration and texture. The study's authors say these findings point to the need for better evaluation methods and improved preoperative counseling.

JAMA Facial and Plastic Surgery published the results today.

About 230 million surgical procedures are performed worldwide each year overall. That includes surgeries that are gender-specific like cesarean sections or breast reconstruction, as well as procedures that are the same for all such as skin cancer surgery. In addition to the type of procedure, there are multiple other factors that impact the scars various procedures leave on a person's body, such as method of skin incision, method of wound closure, suturing technique, or postoperative wound care.

"Our analysis includes results across multiple specialties and using multiple methods, which shows this patient-surgeon discrepancy is not limited to any particular discipline or intervention," said the study's senior author Joseph F. Sobanko, MD, an assistant professor of Dermatology and director of Dermatologic Surgery Education at Penn.

Sobanko and his team used studies from 1972 through 2015 that specifically looked at assessment of surgical scars for which surgeons tried two different methods of intervention, either incising the skin or suturing the skin with two different methods. They ended up with 29 studies involving 4,485 patients.

The same scar after one week. Credit: Penn Medicine

In the 72 percent of cases in which doctors and patients had similar scar evaluations, the two groups were indifferent in terms of the intervention used. However, in the 28 percent of studies with disagreement, six out of eight patient cohorts (75 percent) rated one intervention as superior, while the physicians rated the interventions as equivalent. There were no studies where patients preferred one while physicians preferred another.

"It is somewhat common for patients to have post-surgical scars that are considered clinically acceptable but patients may still feel disfigured," Sobanko said. "Many of the scales currently used to evaluate scars are insufficient to measure subtle scar features and patient satisfaction."; they ."

Sobanko says one problem with the scales is that they were not originally designed to measure surgical scars. Several of them were developed to evaluate burn scars instead. They also don't take into account the difference in points of emphasis between patients and physicians. In studies using patient and observer scar assessment scale (POSAS) to rate scars, patients weighted scar depth as more important, while physicians emphasized scar pigmentation and texture/surface irregularities. By taking these priorities into account, surgeons can better set expectations.

The same scar at three months. Credit: Penn Medicine

"These findings may help to improve preoperative counseling and highlight the importance of developing scar measures that balance the perceptions of patients and physicians," Sobanko said.

To that end, Sobanko said further research is needed to understand patient and expectations during initial visits, as well as how the anatomic location of the affects perception.

Explore further: Newer treatments can make scars less scary

More information: JAMA Facial and Plastic Surgery (2018) DOI: 10.1001/jamafacial.2017.2314

Related Stories

Newer treatments can make scars less scary

August 3, 2016
(HealthDay)—Scars can alter your appearance and remind you of a difficult time, potentially diminishing your quality of life, a skin specialist says.

Addition of peel to microneedling improves acne scar treatment

November 9, 2017
(HealthDay)—The combination of sequential 70 percent glycolic acid peel and microneedling results in better acne scar improvement than microneedling alone, according to a study published online Oct. 26 in the Journal of ...

Medical tattooing improves perception of scar/graft appearance, quality of life

September 22, 2016
Medical tattooing, also known as dermatography, is routinely used by plastic surgeons for nipple reconstruction after mastectomy. The procedure also can be used to improve color mismatch and the appearance of scars and skin ...

Ablative fractional laser beneficial for C-section scars

November 16, 2016
(HealthDay)—Ablative fractional laser (AFXL) treatment is beneficial for patients with cesarean section (C-section) scars, according to a study published online Nov. 8 in Lasers in Surgery and Medicine.

Skin closure options for cesarean delivery: Glue vs. subcuticular sutures

January 23, 2017
In a study to be presented Thursday, Jan. 26, in the oral concurrent session, at the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine's annual meeting, The Pregnancy Meeting, researchers will present their findings in a study titled, ...

Non-ablative laser treatments improve mature burn scars

September 12, 2014
(HealthDay)—Non-ablative fractional laser treatment may provide long-term improvement of mature burn scars, according to research published online Aug. 22 in Lasers in Surgery and Medicine.

Recommended for you

Clues found to early lung transplant failure

May 21, 2018
Among organ transplant patients, those receiving new lungs face a higher rate of organ failure and death compared with people undergoing heart, kidney and liver transplants. One of the culprits is inflammation that damages ...

In breakthrough, surgeon builds windpipes from arteries

May 20, 2018
Where others failed, sometimes spectacularly, French surgeon Emmanuel Martinod has helped people whose windpipes have been ravaged by cancer and other diseases to live and breathe normally again.

Blood type O patients may have higher risk of death from severe trauma

May 1, 2018
Blood type O is associated with high death rates in severe trauma patients, according to a study published in the open access journal Critical Care that involved 901 Japanese emergency care patients.

Brains, eyes, testes: off-limits for transplants?

April 28, 2018
Since the world's first successful organ transplant in 1954—a kidney—the discipline has advanced to the point where a wounded soldier could have his penis and scrotum replaced in a groundbreaking operation last month.

Emergency treatment by older surgeons linked to slightly lower death rates

April 26, 2018
Patients undergoing emergency surgery who are treated by older surgeons (aged 60 or over) have slightly lower death rates in the first few weeks after their operation than patients treated by younger surgeons (aged less than ...

Bionic suit helps paralyzed patients stand and walk again

April 25, 2018
Patients undergoing physical rehabilitation at Rush for paralyzing injuries are being aided by a robotic suit designed to help raise people to full height and walk.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

michbaskett
not rated yet Feb 01, 2018
It's interesting the suture was not subcuticular when the patient was clearly a young female. They tend to be far and away the most sensitive about such matters since most of them believe their worth is partly connected to their visual attractiveness. At least the suture appears to be a rather fine one as opposed to a standard skin suture thickness.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.