Mental health declining among disadvantaged American adults

June 19, 2018 by B. Rose Kelly, Princeton University
Illustration byEgan Jimenez, Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs. Credit: Princeton University

American adults of low socioeconomic status report increasing mental distress and worsening well-being, according to a new study by Princeton University and Georgetown University.

Between the mid-1990s and early 2010s, self-reports of declined among disadvantaged Americans ages 24 to 76. However, as increased, mental health deterioration lessened or, in some cases, even improved.

The study, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, is among the first to investigate if the of Americans has worsened over time, as suggested by the "deaths of despair" narrative, linking rising mortality in midlife to drugs, alcohol and suicide.

The results show that is not just a midlife phenomenon but a scenario plaguing disadvantaged Americans across the life course. The findings should be taken into account in terms of policy and advocacy efforts, the researchers said.

"Our results paint a picture of substantial social stratification in the psychological health of American adults, one that has been widening as declines in mental health have occurred unevenly across the socioeconomic spectrum," said co-lead author Noreen Goldman, the Hughes-Rogers Professor of Demography and Public Affairs at Princeton's Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs. "The findings are consistent with overdose death rates and underscore the dire need for improved access to, and affordability of, for low-income and less-educated American adults of all ages."

Goldman, along with Dana Glei and Maxine Weinstein of Georgetown's Center for Population and Health, wanted to investigate whether mental health had deteriorated since the mid-1990s, a period known for boosted opioid use and rising mortality from suicide, drugs and alcohol.

They used data from two cross-sectional waves of the Midlife in the U.S. Study (MIDUS) to assess trends in psychological distress and well-being. MIDUS conducted interviews with national samples of adults in 1995 and 1996 and another sample between 2011 and 2014, which closely spans the period of rising substance abuse.

The researchers looked at measures of distress and well-being to better capture overall mental health. Distress was represented by two measures: depression and what's called "negative affect," which includes reports of sadness, hopelessness and worthlessness. Well-being was assessed by four measures that reflect emotions such as happiness, fulfillment, life satisfaction and meaning in life.

The results revealed the influence of socioeconomic status. In both time periods studied, disadvantaged Americans reported higher levels of distress and lower levels of well-being compared with those of higher socioeconomic status. Between the two waves of people studied, distress increased substantially among disadvantaged Americans, while those of higher socioeconomic status saw less change and even improvement. When the researchers made predictions for ages 30, 50 and 70, the results matched those of the entire sample: heightened distress and diminished well-being were felt across the life course.

"In the past few years, references to the opioid epidemic, drug poisonings and associated feelings of despair among Americans, primarily working-class whites, have flooded the media," Glei said. "Yet, despite recurring references to distress or despair, there has been little analysis of whether psychological health among American adults has worsened over the past two decades. We wondered: Are Americans suffering from a rising tide of despair?"

While the results do not show direct links between worsening mental health and increased substance abuse, the researchers said it is possible the drug epidemic affected the psychological well-being of these Americans.

Drug use that ravages families could plausibly weaken the social and economic fabric of communities. The drug epidemic could also have reduced one's income and assets through job loss, a decline in earnings, high costs of drugs and treatment, and needing to care for those with addiction issues. This could also work in reverse: The of Americans could have influenced drug use.

"The paper certainly underscores a two-directional causality," said Goldman, "but this is one of our study's limitations: We do not attempt to establish direct causality and could never do so using this kind of data—two cross-sectional waves."

The researchers point to possible limitations with the study. As with all surveys, the findings could be biased by data problems or response errors. For example, some participants may have been less willing to report . Other participants might have been biased by media reports about the working class.

Nevertheless, the results point to a number of avenues for future research, especially exploring differences in distress and well-being by race, sex and region.

The paper, "Declining mental among disadvantaged Americans" was published in PNAS on June 18.

Explore further: People experiencing mental distress less likely to have health insurance

More information: Noreen Goldman el al., "Declining mental health among disadvantaged Americans," PNAS (2018).

Related Stories

People experiencing mental distress less likely to have health insurance

October 4, 2011
People with frequent mental distress are markedly more likely that than those with frequent physical distress to lack health insurance, according to research appearing the October issue of Psychiatric Services, a journal ...

Women, poor, uninsured face higher risk of psychological distress: CDC

May 28, 2015
(HealthDay)—Women, people with chronic medical conditions, the poor and those without health insurance are more likely to struggle with "serious psychological distress," U.S. health officials reported Thursday.

Study paints somber picture of US mental health status and access to care

April 17, 2017
More Americans than ever before suffer from serious psychological distress, and the country's ability to meet the growing demand for mental health services is rapidly eroding.

Mental health issues impact retirement saving behavior

October 14, 2017
(HealthDay)—Mental health, as assessed by psychological distress, is associated with retirement saving behavior, according to a report published online Aug. 29 in Health Economics.

Combined depression, substance abuse linked to lower income

November 14, 2014
(Medical Xpress)—Young adults with co-occurring depression and substance abuse have a higher likelihood of being unemployed and having lower income in midlife than those with neither disorder, according to a study by Dr. ...

Lower socioeconomic status is linked to obesity through distress and emotional eating

May 18, 2017
New research presented at this year's European Congress on Obesity in Porto, Portugal (17-20 May) shows that lower socioeconomic status is associated with higher body-mass index (BMI) through its effects on distress and subsequent ...

Recommended for you

Largest ever study of psychological sex differences and autistic traits

November 12, 2018
Scientists at the University of Cambridge have completed the world's largest ever study of typical sex differences and autistic traits. They tested and confirmed two long-standing psychological theories: the Empathizing-Systemizing ...

Major traumatic injury increases risk of mental health diagnoses, suicide

November 12, 2018
People who experience major injuries requiring hospital admission, such as car crashes and falls, are at substantially increased risk of being admitted to hospital for mental health disorders, found a study in CMAJ (Canadian ...

Nearly one in ten Americans struggles to control sexual urges

November 9, 2018
(HealthDay)—The #MeToo movement has given many Americans a glimpse into an unfamiliar world that may have left many wondering, "What were they thinking?"

Brain activity pattern may be early sign of schizophrenia

November 8, 2018
Schizophrenia, a brain disorder that produces hallucinations, delusions, and cognitive impairments, usually strikes during adolescence or young adulthood. While some signs can suggest that a person is at high risk for developing ...

Social media use increases depression and loneliness

November 8, 2018
The link between the two has been talked about for years, but a causal connection had never been proven. For the first time, University of Pennsylvania research based on experimental data connects Facebook, Snapchat, and ...

Double whammy for grieving spouses with sleep problems

November 8, 2018
Sleep disturbances have a strong negative impact on the immune system of people who have recently lost a spouse, reports a new study from Northwestern Medicine and Rice University.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jun 19, 2018
Cause, effect, or epiphenomenon?
not rated yet Jun 21, 2018
because, capitalism=fuk us. Think you understand and disagree? fuk u. Conservatism=antisocial, selfish, unhealthy attitudes, policies, behaviors. period. Human is not us vs them .We aer are all what makes up human. When we compete with each other at the expense of each other, humanity suffers. When we help and share with each other, despite that some may not, we benefit. And we could mandate sharing except too many of us are=fuk everyone else. They will vote for = fuk us. The only enemy of humanity is humanity (it's tolerance of anti-social mentality).

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.