Naloxone remains controversial to some, but here's why it shouldn't be

July 20, 2018 by Cyrus Ahalt, The Conversation
A Narcan package. Many states report a shortage or difficulty obtaining the drug. Credit: PureRadiancePhotos/

The overdose-reversing drug naloxone saves thousands of lives each year and is more widely available today than ever. So why do overdose deaths across the U.S. continue to rise?

According to a recent study, naloxone itself is partly to blame. Naloxone, the authors of the study wrote, increases opioid use and does not reduce opioid-related mortality overall because it provides users with a "safety net" and thus encourages riskier drug use. The paper set off a Twitterstorm and controversy even among those who don't air their disagreements digitally.

From the perspective of a public health researcher, I can say the weight of evidence suggests that naloxone, which is often sold as the brand name Narcan, is a vital tool in fighting the overdose epidemic and, in fact, is too often not available where it is needed most.

Scant evidence of moral hazard

The "moral hazard" discussed in this study is an economic term, not an ethical one. It describes increasingly risky behavior in response to policies or innovations that lessen associated consequences. An example? Driving more recklessly with auto insurance than without.

The authors infer increased risk-taking based on trends such as ER use, crime and death, that they otherwise cannot explain. They marshal a few journalistic accounts of parties where users intentionally overdose and revive each other with naloxone. They also cite a health risk behavior literature describing increased sexual risk taking in response to anti-retroviral treatment.

But harm reduction experts have said that journalistic accounts of "Narcan parties" are inaccurate and public officials who have warned of their danger acknowledge, on follow-up, that the parties are urban legend.

Other studies of increased sexual risk behavior in response to anti-retroviral treatment conclude that this is a patient-education problem. In fact, though the relevant research on naloxone is limited, the few studies that have been conducted echo the anti-retroviral literature in emphasizing education as critical to achieving harm reduction. Providing education and training alongside naloxone improves users' ability to accurately identify and confidently respond to overdoses. But more research is needed to ensure that the overdose education and naloxone distribution model achieves harm reduction beyond reversing overdoses.

Problems with naloxone availability

The moral hazard study also assumes that naloxone is widely available in states that have passed naloxone laws allowing broader distribution. Yet there is evidence that access often remains critically limited despite these laws. New Hampshire's Anyone Anytime program, for example, provides a wealth of resources but the drug is still often not on hand because "consumers report significant barriers to access … high cost, fear of police, fear of stigmatization, lack of knowledge, fear of withdrawal. Responders report mixed feelings about making it available to the public."

After Ohio passed its naloxone law in 2014, surged. But the Cuyahoga County Sheriff's and Cleveland Police departments did not start carrying naloxone until mid-2017, and as the Cleveland Plain Dealer reported as recently as April 2018, "Narcan should be available across northeast Ohio, but it's not." A recent study in Ohio found persistent barriers to naloxone distribution similar to those experienced in New Hampshire, including cost, stigma and legal fears.

The law enforcement community concurs. Though many states had passed naloxone laws, a 2017 Police Executive Research Forum report underscored the persistent need for greater distribution. The first of its "10 Actions Police Chiefs and Sheriffs Can Take" read: "Equip officers with naloxone." That report went further, arguing that naloxone should be distributed as broadly as possible, including to the general public: "Police chiefs and sheriffs also can use their positions of leadership in the community to call for widespread distribution of naloxone … at drug treatment facilities, homeless shelters, and other locations."

The real hazard: Fentanyl

There is a better explanation for the continued rise in overdose deaths, and I believe it suggests that naloxone should be far more widely distributed.

From 2013 to 2016 – when most states passed naloxone laws – fentanyl seizures at the border rose astronomically. In 2017, nearly 1,800 pounds were seized. To put that in perspective, consider that a lethal dose weighs 2 milligrams. By then, fentanyl was already the drug most commonly involved in overdose deaths.

The study's authors assert that "broadening naloxone access increased the use of fentanyl." But evidence suggests that fentanyl deaths commonly occur among unknowing users because heroin and other drugs are easily and often adulterated with cheaper, more potent fentanyl. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention notes that fentanyl follows the supply of white powder heroin in the U.S. precisely because it can be easily concealed and passed off as pure heroin. As a result, fentanyl is far less common in states, such as California, where black tar or brown powder heroin are predominant.

Indeed, the federally funded Fentanyl HotSpot study describes the drug's rise as a supply issue: "Consumers report buying any opioid that is available from their dealer, and widely acknowledge that fentanyl-laced heroin is most available."

These perspectives from people on the ground – users, first responders and others – are particularly critical to understanding the complex relationships between fentanyl, naloxone and drug use behavior because secondary data on fentanyl are unusually unreliable. That is why the authors of the "moral hazard" study cannot control for it. Instead, their claim that is driving use is an inference, one that dangerously belies the fact that naloxone has not been widely distributed in many places—like New Hampshire and Cuyahoga County, Ohio—where overdose deaths continue to rise.

Missed opportunity

A few public officials, like Maine's Governor Paul LePage, believe that naloxone does not, on balance, benefit society. But naloxone skepticism is rare among experts. No professional organization has taken the position that distribution should be limited in order to prevent riskier drug use. The American Public Health Association and the U.S. surgeon general have issued unambiguous statements in support of naloxone's broadest possible use.

Naloxone is not itself the answer to the country's drug crisis. Nor can making it so widely available be achieved without costs – from the financial cost of Narcan kits to an increased burden on emergency services to the psychological toll that reviving the same person time and again can exact on responders.

Undoubtedly, another cost is that some users will use naloxone as a "safety net." But it remains a powerful tool. It saves hundreds of lives every day and, if distributed with appropriate education and training, has the potential to save many thousands more. The research needed now would identify strategies to mitigate those costs and to distribute as widely as possible.

Explore further: Study: Wide distribution of naloxone can slash overdose deaths during epidemics

Related Stories

Study: Wide distribution of naloxone can slash overdose deaths during epidemics

April 18, 2018
A new study in The Lancet Public Health shows the rapid expansion of British Columbia's Take Home Naloxone program significantly reduced the number of fentanyl-related overdose deaths in 2016.

Overdose antidote promotes stroke recovery in rats

April 16, 2018
The life-saving drug used to treat opioid overdose, naloxone, reduces brain inflammation in the aftermath of stroke in male rats. The preclinical research, published in eNeuro, lays the groundwork for developing the first ...

US surgeon general urges Americans to carry opioid antidote

April 5, 2018
The top US doctor on Thursday urged more Americans to carry naloxone, an antidote to opioid overdose, as the nation grapples with a surge in deaths due to potent prescription painkillers and heroin.

Let's talk about Rx use—recognizing and reversing an overdose

March 23, 2018
According to the National Institute on Drug Abuse, the misuse of and addiction to opioids is a serious national crisis, with more than 115 Americans dying from opioid overdose every day. Knowing how to prevent and recognize ...

Frequent, public drug users may be good candidates for overdose-treatment training

March 26, 2018
In response to America's opioid crisis, public health departments and community organizations across the country have started to train opioid users to reverse overdoses in other users with the opioid-blocker naloxone. The ...

FDA: opioid antidote naloxone recalled

June 6, 2018
(HealthDay)—A recall of the opioid overdose antidote Naloxone was announced Monday. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration said the recall was triggered by the possibility of "loose particulate matter on the syringe plunger" ...

Recommended for you

Rapid response inpatient education boosts use of needed blood-thinning drugs

November 16, 2018
A new study designed to reach hospitalized patients at risk shows that a "real-time" educational conversation, video or leaflet can lower the missed dose rates of drugs that can prevent potentially lethal blood clots in their ...

Drug overdose epidemic goes far beyond opioids, requires new policies

November 7, 2018
Most government-funded initiatives to address the overdose epidemic in the United States have targeted opioids specifically and have neglected other drugs that are increasingly implicated in overdoses, such as cocaine and ...

Zebrafish larvae help in search for appetite suppressants

November 2, 2018
Researchers at the University of Zurich and Harvard University have developed a new strategy in the search for psychoactive drugs. By analyzing the behavior of larval zebrafish, they can filter out substances with unwanted ...

FDA OKs powerful opioid pill as alternative to IV painkiller

November 2, 2018
U.S. regulators on Friday approved a fast-acting, super-potent opioid tablet as an alternative to IV painkillers used in hospitals.

Amphetamine-related hospitalizations surged between 2003 and 2015

November 2, 2018
An analysis conducted by Hennepin Healthcare, University of Minnesota School of Public Health and University of Michigan researchers shows amphetamine-related hospitalizations increased more than 270 percent from 2008 to ...

Cocaine-fentanyl overdoses underscore need for more 'test strips' and rapid response

November 1, 2018
Penn Medicine emergency department physicians are calling for more readily available testing strips to identify the presence of fentanyl in patients experiencing a drug overdose, and a rapid, coordinated response among health ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.