Antidepressant efficacy is the new fake news

August 2, 2018, University of New South Wales
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Are antidepressants an effective treatment for major depression? According to Professor Gordon Parker AO, a professor of psychiatry at UNSW and the founder of the Black Dog Institute, the answer is irrelevant—because we're asking the wrong question.

In a British Journal of Psychiatry editorial published this month, Parker challenges the findings of several studies that analysed the outcomes of multiple clinical trials of . Collectively, these trials spanned hundreds of thousands of patients who received either antidepressants or placebos to treat a diagnosis of .

The aggregated trial data were interpreted in the earlier studies as indicating that antidepressants were no more effective than placebos, leading to widespread public confusion about the validity of these drugs, while the most recent analysis argued for their effectiveness.

The problem, Parker argues, is that trialling antidepressants against a target condition of major produces, if not guarantees, flawed results. 'Major depression' is an umbrella term that refers to a range of depressive illnesses with varying causes, trajectories and treatment responses, rather than to a single condition.

"The conclusions that these studies have drawn are, in a sense, beside the point," Parker says.

"Basically, the target diagnosis of major depression captures multiple types of depressions—some biological, some psychological, some social—and not all would be expected to respond to medication.

"By bundling those with depression due to social and psychological causes in with the biological conditions, the signal benefits of antidepressant medication are swamped and effectively lost."

Parker likens using an antidepressant to treat all types of depression as equivalent to using a Ventolin inhaler to treat all types of lung conditions, regardless of whether a patient has asthma, where an inhaler may be effective, or pneumonia or a pulmonary embolus, where an inhaler would be ineffective and an entirely different treatment might be required.

"For patients with depression, if you narrow down to those who have a biologically-based depressive sub-type, the antidepressants are distinctly effective," he says.

"For example, biological depression or melancholia shows a 60 per cent response to medication, compared to only a 10 per cent response to placebo. If, however, you include other depressive disorders with no primary biological basis—as occurs, if not dominates, in most studies—antidepressants appear to be ineffective."

Parker's editorial also raises serious questions about the design of antidepressant clinical trials, in which patients with serious conditions—such as suicidal ideation, drug and alcohol problems or personality disorders—are ruled out in favour of those with mild symptoms.

Despite meeting the major depression criteria, these low-acuity participants are highly likely to go into spontaneous remission or to respond to placebos, thereby skewing the trial results and subsequent analyses of a drug's efficacy.

"This approach doesn't respect the real world, where there are multiple types of depressive ," Parker says.

"It should not be a simplistic question—are antidepressants effective or ineffective? No treatment should be tested as if it has universal application for multiple differing depressive disorders."

"It's all about saying, what are the circumstances in which they're effective, and when are they irrelevant?"

The editorial was published on August 1 in The British Journal of Psychiatry, Volume 213/Issue 2.

Explore further: Study identifies a link between antidepressant treatment resistance and inflammation

More information: Gordon Parker. The benefits of antidepressants: news or fake news?, The British Journal of Psychiatry (2018). DOI: 10.1192/bjp.2018.98

Related Stories

Study identifies a link between antidepressant treatment resistance and inflammation

June 11, 2018
Researchers at Emory University have found that depressed patients who have not responded to multiple antidepressants exhibit evidence of increased inflammation. Findings were recently published online in the journal, Psychoneuroendocrinology.

How the DSM-5 has come to grief

April 3, 2013
(Medical Xpress)—Widespread confusion about what constitutes grief, 'normaI' depression and clinical depression risks being exacerbated under the American Psychiatry Association's newest classification system, professor ...

New study on the placebo effect and antidepressants in children and adolescents

September 15, 2017
Although the clinical efficacy of antidepressants in children and adolescents is proven, it is frequently accompanied by side effects. In addition, the influence of the placebo effect on the efficacy of antidepressants is ...

Better prediction for effectiveness of paroxetine

April 13, 2017
A third of patients with depression do not respond to the first antidepressant medication prescribed. Currently, the only approach available is one of trial and error. In this study, Max Planck scientists have identified ...

Antidepressants beneficial for women with postnatal depression

May 19, 2015
Antidepressants are associated with better rates of treatment response and remission for women with postnatal depression, when compared to a placebo, according to a new systematic review by the Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology ...

No treatment difference between some antidepressants and CBT for severe depression

December 8, 2015
The available evidence suggests no difference in treatment effects of second generation antidepressants and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) either alone or in combination, for patients with major depressive disorder, finds ...

Recommended for you

FDA approves brain stimulation device for OCD

August 17, 2018
(HealthDay)—A brain stimulation device to treat obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) has received approval for marketing Friday by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

People are more honest when using a foreign tongue, research finds

August 17, 2018
New UChicago-led research suggests that someone who speaks in a foreign language is probably more credible than the average native speaker.

16 going on 66: Will you be the same person 50 years from now?

August 17, 2018
How much do you change between high school and retirement? The answer depends on whether you're comparing yourself to others or to your younger self.

Research eyes role of stress in mental illnesses

August 17, 2018
We all face stress in our lives. Even researchers seeking to understand why some people shrug it off while others face battles against disorders like depression or PTSD.

It's okay when you're not okay: Study re-evaluates resilience in adults

August 16, 2018
Adversity is part of life: Loved ones die. Soldiers deploy to war. Patients receive terminal diagnoses.

Expecting to learn: Language acquisition in toddlers improved by predictable situations

August 16, 2018
The first few years of a child's life are crucial for learning language, and though scientists know the "when," the "how" is still up for debate. The sheer number of words a child hears is important; that number predicts ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Aug 03, 2018
And then there is 'depression' which is really un-diagnosed 'bipolar' which may 'spontaneously' resolve...
Who'd be a medical trials statistician ??

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.