Moderate drinking associated with lower risk of heart disease but consistency matters

drinking
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Unstable drinking patterns over time may be associated with a higher risk of heart disease, whereas consistent moderate drinking within recommended health guidelines may have a cardioprotective effect, according to a study published in the open access journal BMC Medicine that examined data on 35,132 individuals.

A team of researchers led by University College London and the University of Cambridge found that compared to individuals who consistently followed UK sensible guidelines over a period of ten years, those who inconsistently drank in moderation, those who had stopped drinking (former drinkers) and those who reported no drinking had a higher risk of coronary heart disease (CHD), although the effect observed in non-drinkers may be confined to women.

Dr. Dara O'Neill, the corresponding author from University College London said: "This study uses long-term data to distinguish between persistent non-drinkers and former drinkers, allowing us to test the established theory that only the latter have an elevated risk of CHD. We did not find this to be the case but we did observe a sex-related difference. Amongst consistent non-drinkers, women showed higher risk of developing CHD compared to consistently moderate drinkers, but their male counterparts did not."

Overall, 1,718 (4.9%) out of the 35,132 individuals included in the six cohorts that were examined in this study developed CHD during the study period, of which 325 (0.9%) were fatal CHD events. Observed CHD incidence was highest for former drinkers, 6.1% of whom experienced a CHD event of which 1.2% were fatal, and lowest for consistently heavy drinkers, 3.8% of whom experienced a CHD event of which 0.6% were fatal. The authors caution that there is considerable doubt around the estimates of CHD risk in heavy drinkers due to an under-representation of heavy drinkers in the study sample, especially among women.

Dr. O'Neill said: "Given that heavy drinkers are known to be under sampled in population level surveys, interpretation of the absence of effect amongst heavy drinkers in the current study should be done very cautiously, particularly in light of the known wider health impact of heavy levels."

The findings suggest that instability in over time is associated with CHD risk. This may be because unstable drinking patterns reflect wider lifestyle changes across the course of people's lives, including periods of ill-health or life stress, according to the authors. Lifestyle changes may also account for variations in risk the authors observed when they compared different age groups.

Dr. O'Neill said: "When we split the sample by age, we found that the elevated risk of incident CHD amongst inconsistently moderate drinkers was observed in participants aged over 55, but not those aged below. It may be that the older group experienced lifestyle changes, such as retirement, which are known to co-occur with increases in alcohol intake and that these could have played a role in the differing risk."

In order to examine associations between CHD and drinking behavior over time, the authors analyzed prospectively collected, longitudinal data on self-reported weekly alcohol consumption from six studies—five from the UK and one French study—which included information on alcohol intake over a period of ten years, together with information on CHD events.

Drinking behavior over time was assessed by measuring intake based on the alcohol content in reported drinks; half pints of beer or cider, small glasses of wine and a single serving of spirits were recorded as containing 8g of ethanol in the UK cohorts and 10g of ethanol in the French cohort. Moderate drinking was considered to be up to 168g/ethanol per week for men and up to 112g ethanol/week for women.

The authors note that a lack of information on alcohol intake prior to the beginning of the 10-year assessment period could mean that the long-term abstainers identified in this study include some former drinkers. Sick may also not have been captured in the study sample due to possible dropout from the investigation at an earlier stage. The observational nature of the individual studies included in this analysis does not allow for conclusions to be drawn about cause and effect.


Explore further

Study examines sickness absence from work among abstainers, low-risk drinkers and at-risk drinkers

More information: Dara O'Neill et al, Association of longitudinal alcohol consumption trajectories with coronary heart disease: a meta-analysis of six cohort studies using individual participant data, BMC Medicine (2018). DOI: 10.1186/s12916-018-1123-6
Journal information: BMC Medicine

Provided by BioMed Central
Citation: Moderate drinking associated with lower risk of heart disease but consistency matters (2018, August 21) retrieved 22 May 2019 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2018-08-moderate-heart-disease.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
1135 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Aug 21, 2018
You keep publishing this as if it is truth.
It does not begin to touch upon the reasons or the possibilities.
The writers do not recognize their own somatoform biases.

The real truth is closer in the sentence that the authors reiterate:
The findings suggest that instability in drinking behavior over time is associated with CHD risk.

Aug 23, 2018
What about practicing an overall healthy lifestyle rather than focusing on getting smashed? Is there no such thing as toxemia or cirrhosis of the liver in this study?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more