Commonly used concussion test useful in confirming—but not making—diagnosis for pro athletes

November 27, 2018 by Michael Brown, University of Alberta
The King-Devick concussion test, a quick assessment that can be used on the sidelines, may be useful in confirming a medical diagnosis but should not be used alone because it may not indicate more serious brain injuries, say U of A researchers. Credit: Shawn McCready via Flickr, CC BY-ND 2.0

One of the more prominent sideline concussion assessment tools being piloted in professional sports may be useful as a tool to confirm, not make, clinical diagnoses, according to University of Alberta researchers.

A research team, led by Martin Mrazik and Dhiren Naidu, set out to evaluate the effectiveness of the King-Devick test, a screening test that measures visual tracking and complex attention. The study assessed concussions in Canadian Football League players over two seasons.

"The King-Devick was hailed as a great sideline test, so it is being used in professional sport leagues across North America," said Mrazik, a professor in the Department of Educational Psychology. "However, our study combined with [others] have clearly suggested it's not a stand-alone test but may provide additional clinical information."

Originally designed as a learning test for determining mental disabilities, the King-Devick test became part of the sport concussion-diagnosis arsenal after the Mayo Clinic reached a licensing agreement with the test's licence holders in January 2015 and proclaimed it as the gold standard of concussion testing.

"The data was quite good for the King-Devick in previous studies, but those studies involved different sports and different age groups—mostly youth," said Naidu, a U of A researcher and the head team physician for the Edmonton Oilers, Edmonton Eskimos and U of A Golden Bears football team. "We wanted to see how it worked in professional sport."

For the study, researchers performed a baseline version of the test on 306 players in 2015 and 917 for the 2016 season and then on players who had a suspected concussion.

As each season progressed, in situations where players were diagnosed by a physician as having suffered a concussion, the King-Devick test accurately predicted that a player had a concussion (the test's sensitivity) 84 per cent of the time. It was only able to predict a player didn't have a concussion (the test's specificity) in 62 per cent of cases.

"In medicine, we want to see these numbers a lot higher, especially when it comes to concussions," said Naidu. "In the end, the King-Devick test presents as a reliable measure, although sensitivity and specificity data from our sample indicate it should be used in conjunction with other measures for diagnosing concussion."

Naidu said he still feels this test is a good tool to reinforce a clinical diagnosis.

"We know subjectively that a lot of therapists and doctors say when they didn't feel someone had a concussion and then the player passed the King-Devick, it really gave them that extra bit of confidence that the player was ready to go back."

Naidu said further studies are needed to see whether the King-Devick and the industry-standard Sport Concussion Assessment Tool (SCAT) version 5 can work in conjunction with each other.

The researchers also sought to find out whether the King-Devick could help determine how long it may take individual athletes to return to play.

"Whether you are a pro athlete or a bantam hockey player, if you have a head injury, the first question people ask is, 'How long will I be out?' In other sport injuries, we have really good guidelines of timelines, but with concussions we don't," noted Naidu.

The British Journal of Sports Medicine published a similar study earlier this year that showed the King-Devick test performs poorly as a screening tool in elite rugby union .

Naidu warned there are no shortcuts when it comes to recognizing concussions, and diagnosis should be left in the hands of someone who knows how to do a proper neurologic exam.

"The King-Devick could prove to be very helpful, but it doesn't replace a proper medical exam because that's how you miss things like bleeds and more severe brain injuries," he said.

The study, "Sideline Concussion Assessment: The King-Devick Test in Canadian Professional Football," was published in The Journal of Neurotrauma in October.

Explore further: More evidence that vision test on sidelines may help diagnose concussion

More information: Dhiren Naidu et al. Sideline Concussion Assessment: The King-Devick Test in Canadian Professional Football, Journal of Neurotrauma (2018). DOI: 10.1089/neu.2017.5490

Related Stories

More evidence that vision test on sidelines may help diagnose concussion

February 26, 2014
A simple vision test performed on the sidelines may help determine whether athletes have suffered a concussion, according to a study released today that will be presented at the American Academy of Neurology's 66th Annual ...

Rugby players take part in ground-breaking concussion study

August 30, 2017
Rugby and the Rugby Players' Association, will run throughout the 2017/18 rugby season and is the biggest of its kind to take place in the history of UK sport. It is a key element in the University of Birmingham's research ...

Simple test helps doctors catch more concussions on the field

July 28, 2014
On the football field, sometimes the signs of a concussion are subtle. A player may have taken a tough hit but isn't showing symptoms yet, and either doesn't notice anything is wrong or won't report it for fear of being taken ...

Teleconcussion assessments are feasible for football players

May 1, 2017
(HealthDay)—Teleconcussion assessment with a remote neurologist assessing football players using a telemedicine robot is feasible for sideline concussion assessments, with high levels of agreement with face-to-face providers, ...

Vision testing an effective tool for detecting concussion on the sidelines

September 10, 2015
A timed vision test that involves rapidly reading numbers off of cards can be a valuable sideline tool for detecting whether a concussion occurred while playing sports, according to a meta-analysis and systematic review led ...

Football players' concussions linked to dyslexia gene

October 23, 2018
A gene associated with dyslexia, a learning disorder, may make some athletes less susceptible to concussions, reports a new study from Penn State University and Northwestern Medicine.

Recommended for you

Wiring diagram of the brain provides a clearer picture of brain scan data

December 14, 2018
Already affecting more than five million Americans older than 65, Alzheimer's disease is on the rise and expected to impact more than 13 million people by 2050. Over the last three decades, researchers have relied on neuroimaging—brain ...

Scientists identify method to study resilience to pain

December 14, 2018
Scientists at the Yale School of Medicine and Veterans Affairs Connecticut Healthcare System have successfully demonstrated that it is possible to pinpoint genes that contribute to inter-individual differences in pain.

Parents' brain activity 'echoes' their infant's brain activity when they play together

December 13, 2018
When infants are playing with objects, their early attempts to pay attention to things are accompanied by bursts of high-frequency activity in their brain. But what happens when parents play together with them? New research, ...

In the developing brain, scientists find roots of neuropsychiatric diseases

December 13, 2018
The most comprehensive genomic analysis of the human brain ever undertaken has revealed new insights into the changes it undergoes through development, how it varies among individuals, and the roots of neuropsychiatric illnesses ...

Researchers discover abundant source for neuronal cells

December 13, 2018
USC researchers seeking a way to study genetic activity associated with psychiatric disorders have discovered an abundant source of human cells—the nose.

Researchers find the cause of and cure for brain injury associated with gut condition

December 13, 2018
Using a mouse model of necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC)—a potentially fatal condition that causes a premature infant's gut to suddenly die—researchers at Johns Hopkins say they have uncovered the molecular causes of the ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.