To beat cholera, what is most needed is a reliable drinking water supply

December 5, 2018 by Florent Bédécarrats, The Conversation
The city of Uvira, in the South Kivu province, study site for new research on cholera. Credit: MONUSCO Photos / Flickr, CC BY-SA

In fighting cholera, the international community usually favours responsive actions which have limited and short-term effectiveness. Such actions are often mobilised in responses to sudden epidemics, such as those in Yemen and Zimbabwe. However, there is a profound lack of evidence for how longer-term interventions, which are usually harder to achieve, can be delivered effectively.

New research addressing this gap is currently under way in the city of Uvira, South Kivu, DRC, to provide evidence for improving the supply of safe drinking as a public health priority.

A critical issue in guiding the public fight against cholera

According to the World Health Organisation (WHO), diarrhoeal diseases relating to unsafe water, sanitation and hygiene cause over 1,000 deaths a day in Africa. And, every year, alone accounts for the deaths of 100,000 to 120,000 people.

Yet, the debate as to what is the most efficient way to prevent and control cholera persists. Some favour a focus on rapid short-term responses, where the cost of interventions is relatively low – home chlorination/filtration kits, the distribution of small quantities of water intended exclusively for drinking, raising hygiene awareness, etc. Moreover, oral cholera vaccines (OCV) are increasingly presented as a priority. There are many new OCV studies that have attracted substantial attention; but, while the findings are generally positive, the effectiveness of these vaccines can be limited and short-lived.

Uvira - RDC. Credit: Isabelle Serro Photography - Fondation Veolia

To date though there has been limited rigorous research to evaluate the effectiveness of investment in drinking water supply infrastructure to prevent cholera. There are two reasons behind this: on the one hand, the cholera disease burden is concentrated in low income settings, many of which are affected by political instability, where building and maintaining largescale public health infrastructure is challenging.

On the other hand, public health research increasingly values experimental trials which require a random allocation of treatment and control groups. Whilst pills or awareness-raising sessions can be randomly allocated with relative ease, doing this with piped water connections presents various logistical and ethical challenges. At a time when the evidence-based policy paradigm reigns supreme (requiring that public investment decisions be founded upon high quality scientific evidence), these challenges may discourage national and international investment in preventive actions as we lack strong scientific evaluations of their effectiveness.

Changes in attitude are evident. The humanitarian sector is increasingly committed to the urgency-reconstruction-development continuum. One example in DRC is the "Manifesto to Finally Eradicate Cholera in DRC" launched by the NGO, Solidarités International, in April 2018, and in posts published in such blogs as défishumanitaires. And, in late 2017, the WHO launched a new global roadmap to eliminate cholera by 2030 that calls for a global inter-sectoral response to cholera.

Uvira: new results that challenging some preconceptions about cholera

Cholera is endemic in the city of Uvira, located on the shores of Lake Tanganyika, and is often presented as one of the starting points for the epidemic outbreaks affecting this region of DRC. Supported by the French Development Agency, the Veolia Foundation, the European Union and OXFAM Great Britain, a project to rehabilitate Uvira's drinking water supply network has provided a unique opportunity to perform a rigorous health impact evaluation of this investment.

Chronological series showing the volume of drinking water produced for the Uvira distribution network (bottom left hand corner), the number of cholera cases admitted in the city (top left hand corner) and the statistical relation between both (right). Credit: Jeandron A. et al. (2018), Author provided

This city of 250,000 lies between a lake and mountains which surround it. Residents suffering from seek help at cholera treatment centres (CTC) managed by the general hospital.

With help from the national water company (Regideso) and the Congolese Ministry of Health, the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine has exploited the building works schedule for this water supply network improvement works to design a pragmatic but rigorous evaluation. The assessment relies on a "stepped wedge" trial based on the randomised rollout of the improved water supply network to understand both the impact on cholera and how behaviours change when drinking water sources are closer and run continuously. The assessment also includes a time-space analysis to measure the impact on cholera incidence, as well as a biomolecular sub-study to assess the causes of acute diarrhoea among patients attending the CTCs and to gain insights into the transmission pathways for these diseases.

Initial findings have already been published in well-respected peer-reviewed scientific journals (PLOS Medicine and PLOS ONE). One article demonstrates that 23% of cholera cases in the city were caused by interruptions in water supply, and that hygiene habits in this population are diverse and directly related to both the type of water connection and continuity of service households have. Another article, used rapid diagnostic tests to confirm cholera infection among CTC patients and found that 40% of suspected cholera cases were actually positive. This finding demonstrates the high burden of other acute diarrhoeal diseases and the need for comprehensive strategies which can address both cholera and other diarrhoeal diseases.

The research continues despite challenging conditions

Forthcoming findings should help to assess the relative health benefits of different levels of water supply connections and improved continuity of water supply; for example, between after a shared standpipe and an individual household connection. Molecular biology will help to better understand the ways in which cholera spreads, as well as to understand the other causes of acute diarrhoea that affect this population.

Unfortunately, the political situation remains volatile in DRC as a whole and in South Kivu, in particular, and security issues continue to affect the works schedule. Against such a difficult backdrop, it is important to remember that this project continues due to the determination of the women and men who, in these very challenging conditions and with , continue to collect samples, conduct surveys and work to improve the water supply infrastructure. They are to be praised for their commitment to improving public health.

Explore further: UN warns of a possible new cholera epidemic in Yemen

Related Stories

UN warns of a possible new cholera epidemic in Yemen

August 22, 2018
The United Nations is warning of a possible "third wave" of the cholera epidemic in Yemen, which is already "the largest outbreak on record."

Zimbabwe launches cholera vaccination drive after 49 deaths: WHO

October 5, 2018
Zimbabwe has begun an oral vaccination drive to curb a cholera outbreak which has claimed at least 49 lives over the past month, a WHO official said Friday.

Cholera outbreak kills 6 in Cameroon

July 15, 2018
Six people have died in Cameroon from a cholera outbreak that has infected 43 people since May, the health ministry said.

Toll from cholera outbreak in Lake Chad region now more than 500

September 19, 2018
More than 500 people have died from cholera in the Lake Chad region since the start of the year, representing the worst outbreak to hit the area in four years, the UN said on Wednesday.

Cholera scare on Algeria-France flight

September 5, 2018
A sick eight-year-old triggered a cholera scare onboard a flight from the Algerian city of Oran to Perpignan in southern France on Wednesday.

Zimbabwe declares cholera outbreak after 20 deaths

September 11, 2018
A cholera emergency has been declared in Zimbabwe's capital after 20 people have died, the health minister said Tuesday.

Recommended for you

PET scans to optimize tuberculosis meningitis treatments and personalize care, study finds

December 6, 2018
Although relatively rare in the United States, and accounting for fewer than 5 percent of tuberculosis cases worldwide, TB of the brain—or tuberculosis meningitis (TBM)—is often deadly, always hard to treat, and a particular ...

Silicosis is on the rise, but is there a therapeutic target?

December 6, 2018
Researchers from the CNRS, the University of Orléans, and the company Artimmune, in collaboration with Turkish clinicians from Atatürk University, have identified a key mechanism of lung inflammation induced by silica exposure, ...

Infectivity of different HIV-1 strains may depend on which cell receptors they target

December 6, 2018
Distinct HIV-1 strains may differ in the nature of the CCR5 molecules to which they bind, affecting which cells they can infect and their ability to enter cells, according to a study published December 6 in the open-access ...

Protecting cell powerhouse paves way to better treatment of acute kidney injury

December 6, 2018
For the first time, scientists have described the body's natural mechanism for temporarily protecting the powerhouses of kidney cells when injury or disease means they aren't getting enough blood or oxygen.

New study uncovers why Rift Valley fever is catastrophic to developing fetuses

December 5, 2018
Like Zika, infection with Rift Valley fever virus can go unnoticed during pregnancy, all the while doing irreparable—often lethal—harm to the fetus. The results of a new study, led by researchers at the University of ...

Study highlights potential role of bioaerosol sampling to address airborne biological threats

December 5, 2018
As a leading global city with a high population density, Singapore is vulnerable to the introduction of biological threats. Initiating an early emergency response to such threats calls for the rapid identification of the ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.