Study busts myths about gossip

gossip
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

A new UC Riverside study asserts that women don't engage in "tear-down" gossip any more than men, and lower income people don't gossip more than their more well-to-do counterparts. It also holds younger people are more likely to gossip negatively than their older counterparts.

It's the first-ever study to dig deep into who gossips the most, what topics they gossip about, and how often people gossip—52 minutes a day on average.

"There is a surprising dearth of information about who gossips and how, given public interest and opinion on the subject," said Megan Robbins, an assistant psychology professor who led the study along with Alexander Karan, a in her lab.

If you're going to look at gossip like an academic, remove the value judgment we assign to the word. Gossip, in the academic's view, is not bad. It's simply talking about someone who isn't present. That talk could be positive, neutral, or negative.

"With that definition, it would be hard to think of a person who never gossips because that would mean the only time they mention someone is in their presence," Robbins said. "They could never talk about a celebrity unless the celebrity was present for the conversation; they would only mention any detail about anyone else if they are present."

"Not only would this be difficult, but it would probably seem strange to people they interact with."

In the research, Robbins and Karan looked at data from 467 people—269 women, 198 men—who participated in one of five studies. Participants were 18 to 58 years old.

Participants wore a portable listening device Robbins employs in her research called the Electronically Activated Recorder, or EAR. The EAR samples what people say throughout the day; about 10 percent of their conversation is recorded, then analyzed by research assistants.

The research assistants counted conversation as gossip if it was about someone not present. In all, there were 4,003 instances of gossip. They then filtered the gossip into three categories: positive, negative, or neutral.

The assistants further coded the gossip depending on whether it was about a celebrity or acquaintance; the topic; and the gender of the partner.

Among the results:

  • Younger people engage in more negative gossip than older adults. There was no correlation with overall frequency of gossip when all three categories were combined.
  • About 14 percent of participants' conversations were gossip, or just under an hour in 16 waking hours
  • Almost three-fourths of gossip was neutral. Negative gossip (604 instances) was twice as prevalent as positive (376)
  • Gossip overwhelmingly was about an acquaintance and not a celebrity, with a comparison of 3,292 samples vs. 369
  • Extraverts gossip far more frequently than introverts, across all three types of gossip
  • Women gossip more than men, but only in neutral, information-sharing, gossip
  • Poorer, less education people don't more than wealthier, better-educated people. This runs contrary to assertions found in popular "best habits of the rich" books.

A final result? Everyone gossips. "Gossip is ubiquitous," the study concludes.


Explore further

Receiving gossip about others promotes self-reflection and growth

More information: Megan L. Robbins et al. Who Gossips and How in Everyday Life?, Social Psychological and Personality Science (2019). DOI: 10.1177/1948550619837000
Citation: Study busts myths about gossip (2019, May 3) retrieved 18 June 2019 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2019-05-myths-gossip.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
255 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

May 04, 2019
As usual its all about reproduction. Women have much more invested in each child they wish to bear; men can potentially mate several times a day. So the community of women is much more interested in evaluating potential mates than men are, and have much to gain by sharing info about the relative quality of men.

And again, this all happens within the context of the tribe. Another behavior we have been artificially selected for over the course of 1000s of gens.

'A woman will prefer 1/10 of a champion than all of a mediocre man.' -Indicating that the harem is the preferred mating arrangement for both sexes. But this runs directly counter to the stability and harmony of the tribe.

All men need a reason to fight and sacrifice for the tribe, repro rights being the most compelling. And so marriage developed to increase the size and cohesiveness of tribes.

May 04, 2019
The above quote is paraphrase of oscar wilde as I cant find the original.

"Younger people engage in more negative gossip than older adults. There was no correlation with overall frequency of gossip when all three categories were combined."

-Of course - younger women are much more interested in reproducing than older women.

"Extraverts gossip" -psst the author is a bad speller

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more