Children exposed to disasters in the womb have higher rates of developmental psychopathology in a sex-specific manner

New research shows children exposed to natural disasters in the womb have higher rates of developmental psychopathology in a sex
The top panels show the patterns of onset of disorders over time for anxiety disorders, attention deficit/disruptive behavioral disorders, and any of the disorders we examined in relation to exposure to SS in-utero. The bottom panels show sex-specific age of onset for anxiety disorders, attention deficit/disruptive behavioral disorders, and any disorder. Solid lines represent exposed [SS(+)] and dotted lines unexposed [SS(-)]. Red lines represent female, and blue lines male children. Credit: Yoko Nomura

New data from the longitudinal Stress in Pregnancy Study (SIP Study) have identified earlier onset and higher rates of developmental psychopathology among children whose mothers were pregnant with them during Superstorm Sandy. In addition, the child's biological sex determined specific patterns of elevated risks.

According to the findings, published today in the Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, children prenatally exposed to Superstorm Sandy, the natural disaster that hit metropolitan New York in October 2012, had substantially increased risks for depression, anxiety, and attention deficit/ compared to children who were not.

Further, male children had distinctly and substantially elevated risks for attention deficit and disruptive behavioral disorders (including attention deficit/, , and oppositional defiant disorder), while female children had elevated risks for anxiety disorders, phobia, and depressive disorders (including separation anxiety disorder, generalized anxiety disorder, and dysthymia).

Researchers analyzed data collected from 163 preschool-aged children from diverse racial and economic backgrounds, 40.5% of whom were exposed to Superstorm Sandy in utero and 59.5% of whom were not. The team conducted structured clinical interviews with the children's parents and reviewed available diagnostic health data on the participating children, whose median age at the initial clinical interview was 3.19 years.

"We've known for some time that maternal stress during pregnancy plays a key role in the mental health development of the child," said the study's principal investigator Yoko Nomura, a at the CUNY Graduate Center and Queens College.

"The SIP Study leveraged an unfortunate climate-related disaster and conducted a natural experiment to examine the impact of prenatal stress in utero on subsequent development and risks for developmental psychopathology during early childhood. Understanding these connections and distinctions grows more necessary every day with the increased frequency of natural disasters driven by climate change."

The team's recent findings, as well as those from a previous SIP Study examining underlying differences in placental transcriptomes, could help clarify the link between exposure to the effects of a natural disaster in the womb and the early risks of developmental psychopathology. Although the underlying mechanisms through which in-utero exposure to a natural disaster negatively impacts early mental health development are still unclear, the growing body of research points to the important relationship between environmental and genetic effects.

"Our ongoing study elucidates the impact of environmental stress on the psychiatric development of preschool children and the elevated risks for early psychopathology in this population," said Jeffrey Newcorn, M.D., professor of psychiatry and pediatrics, and director of the Division of ADHD and Learning Disorders at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, a co-author on the study.

"Most strikingly, the type of mental health problems very much depended on the biological sex of the child."

Taken together, the SIP Study findings should serve as an important resiliency-strategy resource that informs , policymakers, and educational institutions on the need for infrastructure that supports pregnant women and families exposed to climate-related natural disasters in order to mitigate early mental health risks and promote healthy childhood development.

More information: Yoko Nomura et al, Prenatal exposure to a natural disaster and early development of psychiatric disorders during the preschool years: stress in pregnancy study, Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry (2022). DOI: 10.1111/jcpp.13698

Citation: Children exposed to disasters in the womb have higher rates of developmental psychopathology in a sex-specific manner (2022, September 21) retrieved 27 September 2023 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Problems persist for kids exposed to cannabis in the womb


Feedback to editors