This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:


trusted source


Dismissed and discharged: Australian health systems still failing people with poor mental health, says study

emergency room
Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

A serious disconnect between emergency departments and the NDIS is failing people with mental health conditions, as new research from the University of South Australia shows that they frequently receive inadequate care within emergency departments, potentially putting thousands of vulnerable people at risk.

The world-first study found that people with psychosocial disabilities—people who live with disabilities as a result of poor mental health—not only experience distress when dealing with the NDIS, but also face "service pullback" when they present to emergency departments when requiring .

The findings are published in the International Journal of Mental Health Nursing.

Speaking with NDIS participants, the nationwide study found that when participants disclosed that they had NDIS support, clinicians wrongly assumed the NDIS provides medical and mental health crisis care.

It's a concerning finding, particularly following the discrimination, non-inclusivity and lack of equality experienced by people with a disability, identified in the NDIS review and the disability royal commission.

In Australia, 1.1 million people have a psychosocial disability which causes limitations or restrictions in their everyday activities. Additionally, 58% of these people also have a nervous or emotional condition, 42% have problems with memory or periods of confusion, 41% have behavioral conditions, and 40% have a mental illness (such as schizophrenia).

A full 86% also have at least one other disabling condition (63% ; 38% ; and 33% sensory disability).

UniSA researcher and Ph.D. candidate Heather McIntyre says that the disconnect between the NDIS and emergency departments is failing people with psychosocial disabilities.

"Time and time again we hear about people experiencing distress when they contact the NDIS—they fight to be heard, fight for support, and are often dismissed, so the last thing they need is to go through this again when they require emergency care," McIntyre says.

"This is particularly concerning for people with a mental health condition, especially those with fluctuating psychosocial disabilities who may struggle with communication.

"Because many emergency department staff aren't aware of the limitations of NDIS supports, they wrongly assume that the NDIS provides a higher level of care than it does.

"This leaves many people with a psychosocial disability being discharged at emergency without appropriate treatment and returned to the situation that caused them to present in the first place.

"It's an inequitable and unsafe approach that is putting thousands of people at risk."

McIntyre says there is an urgent need to strengthen service integration between the NDIS and emergency departments.

"Communication between the two services is not occurring seamlessly, which affects continuity of care. This needs to change," McIntyre says.

"We must start at the pointy end: emergency department clinicians need more training and education to better understand how the NDIS works and how to best support people with a disability.

"They need to learn how to support people with neurodiversity and hearing impairments, how to build trust and how to really listen, as well as to provide low sensory environments.

"But equally, stronger connections and pathways must be established between NDIS providers and emergency departments so that everyone is on the same page.

"With to the NDIS of 14 billion over the next four years, peoples' disability supports will further be reduced, resulting in more emergency department presentations when supports are insufficient.

"In emergency departments we need to step up care, not ration care, if we are to support people with disabilities who already feel abandoned by the health system."

More information: Heather McIntyre et al, 'Everything would have gone a lot better if someone had listened to me': A nationwide study of emergency department contact by people with a psychosocial disability and a National Disability Insurance Scheme plan, International Journal of Mental Health Nursing (2024). DOI: 10.1111/inm.13309

Citation: Dismissed and discharged: Australian health systems still failing people with poor mental health, says study (2024, May 22) retrieved 14 July 2024 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

'On my worst day ...' How the NDIS fosters a deficit mindset and why that should change


Feedback to editors