Research shows phonics not always the best reading tonic
July 4, 2011 in Psychology & Psychiatry(Medical Xpress) -- Ground-breaking research in learning has found that children are primarily geared towards learning to read through storing words in the brain, and that phonics, used for sounding out words, is not necessary past the initial stages of learning to read.
The results of two research projects, conducted by Dr Brian Thompson, of Victoria University, and Associate Professor Claire Fletcher-Flinn of the University of Otago College of Education, will be announced at the 17th Biennial Australasian Human Development Association (AHDA) Conference, which starts in Dunedin today.
The AHDA is the preeminent think-tank in the area of developmental psychology in the Australasian region.
In the first research finding, Dr Thompson, and Associate Professor Claire Fletcher-Flinn, and colleagues found that six-year-old Scottish children taught through phonics read at a much slower speed than comparable children taught through New Zealands more book-centred approach.
They also performed more poorly in deciding whether words were real or not at ages eight and 11, with non-words such as blud being picked more often as real words, for example.
The researchers also found that Scottish university students who had been taught through phonics as children were worse at reading new or unfamiliar words that do not follow regular taught letter-sounds than their New Zealand counterparts.
It is becoming clear that explicit phonics instruction leaves a cognitive footprint, resulting in a long-term disadvantage when the reader attempts new words.
These findings suggest that educators and policymakers need to look beyond any claimed short-term advantages of particular teaching methods, and take into account longer-term effects when considering the merits of different approaches to teaching reading, says Associate Professor Fletcher-Flinn.
The second finding stems from a study of Grade 1 Japanese Kindergarten children, Japanese adults learning to read and New Zealand students taking Japanese in high school as a second language.
Associate Professor Fletcher-Flinn, Dr. Thompson and colleagues found that the same cognitive processes in learning to read words in a writing system based on the alphabet (letters), such as in English, occur in children learning to read a writing system based mainly on characters for syllables, called Japanese Hiragana.
This means that the same process of learning to read occurs in both children learning English and those learning Japanese, despite these being two different writing systems.
This is a very important finding which suggests a general learning process for learning to read, regardless of the way the language is written, says Associate Professor Fletcher-Flinn.
Both researchers agree that from the beginning, teachers should strongly support the childs storage of vocabulary of print words, which have been connected to words in their spoken vocabulary.
This is already a feature of the Japanese teaching of beginning reading, and it is an important consideration for teaching here.
More information: Dr Thompson and Associate Professor Fletcher-Flinn will present papers on their research at this weeks AHDA Conference, which finishes on Wednesday.
Provided by University of Otago
-
For English learners, reading isn't always
Apr 11, 2011 |
not rated yet |
0
-
'Motherese' important for children's language development
May 06, 2011 |
not rated yet |
0
-
In learning to read and write, dialogue important
Feb 18, 2011 |
not rated yet |
0
-
Reading to kids a crucial tool in English language development
Feb 16, 2010 |
not rated yet |
0
-
Psychologist to study how we put stress into words
Dec 06, 2006 |
not rated yet |
0
-
Of mice and mental models: Neuroscientific implications of risk-optimized behavior in the mouse
6 hours ago |
not rated yet |
0
-
Limits to growth: Scientists identify key metastasis-enabling enzyme
May 22, 2012 |
5 / 5 (3) |
0
-
Seeing is as seeing does: Spatially-structured retinal input in early development of cortical maps
Apr 26, 2012 |
5 / 5 (4) |
1
-
Dreamless nights: Brain activity during nonrapid eye movement sleep
Apr 09, 2012 |
4.4 / 5 (12) |
0
-
Take your time: Neurobiology sheds light on the superiority of spaced vs. massed learning
Mar 28, 2012 |
4.5 / 5 (21) |
3
-
A question about drug tolerance
May 23, 2012
-
Poor nutrition leading to overeating?
May 23, 2012
-
Math and dyslexia?
May 21, 2012
-
portable metabolism meter?
May 21, 2012
-
Rare medical conditions on 20/20 tonight
May 18, 2012
-
"Good" Cholesterol in Doubt
May 17, 2012
- More from Physics Forums - Medical Sciences
More news stories
More mental health care urged for kids who self-harm
(HealthDay) -- Doctors have long known that some kids suffering severe emotional turmoil find relief in physical pain -- cutting or burning or sticking themselves with pins to achieve a form of release.
Psychology & Psychiatry
2 hours ago |
not rated yet |
0
Questionable research practices surprisingly common
(Medical Xpress) -- Not all scientific misconduct is flat-out fraud. Much falls into the murkier realm of questionable research practices. A new study finds that in one field, psychology, these practices are surprisingly ...
Psychology & Psychiatry
6 hours ago |
not rated yet |
0
|
Feeling strong emotions makes peoples' brains 'tick together'
Experiencing strong emotions synchronises brain activity across individuals, research team at Aalto University and Turku PET Centre in Finland has revealed.
Psychology & Psychiatry
May 24, 2012 |
not rated yet |
0
Formal recognition of PMDD will lift stigma for women
A decision to recognise premenstrual dysphoric disorder as a genuine psychiatric condition will finally provide validation for this awful and poorly understood syndrome and alleviate the stigma ...
Psychology & Psychiatry
May 24, 2012 |
2 / 5 (1) |
1
Long-term meditation leads to different brain organization
(Medical Xpress) -- People who practice mindfulness meditation learn to accept their feelings, emotions, and states of mind without judging or resisting them. They simply live in the moment.
Psychology & Psychiatry
May 24, 2012 |
5 / 5 (4) |
0
|
Skp2 activates cancer-promoting, glucose-processing Akt
HER2 and its epidermal growth factor receptor cousins mobilize a specialized protein to activate a major player in cancer development and sugar metabolism, scientists report in the May 25 issue of Cell.
Early physical therapist treatment associated with reduced risk of healthcare utilization and reduced overall healthcare
A new study published in Spine shows that early treatment by a physical therapist for low back pain (LBP), as compared to delayed treatment, was associated with reduced risk of subsequent healthcare utilization and lower ...
Flesh-Eating bacteria no cause for panic, experts say
(HealthDay) -- Despite scary headlines by the score, most people don't have to fear that they'll be the next victim of the so-called flesh-eating bacteria disease, experts say.
Of mice and mental models: Neuroscientific implications of risk-optimized behavior in the mouse
(Medical Xpress) -- Regardless of an organism’s biological complexity, every encephalized animal continuously makes under-informed behavioral choices that can have serious consequences. Despite its ubiquity, ...
Cancer may require simpler genetic mutations than previously thought
Chromosomal deletions in DNA often involve just one of two gene copies inherited from either parent. But scientists haven't known how a deletion in one gene from one parent, called a "hemizygous" deletion, can contribute ...
Inherited DNA change explains overactive leukemia gene
A small inherited change in DNA is largely responsible for overactivating a gene linked to poor treatment response in people with acute leukemia.
Jul 04, 2011
Rank: 5 / 5 (1)
Jul 04, 2011
Rank: not rated yet
They also seem to ignore the fact that while it's well known you can carry out a phone conversation with a 1000 word vocabulary, those of us entering tertiary study are likely to come across new vocabularies encompassing 50,000 new words or more. Some very complex. So it's rather useful to be able to sound them out since you will never have seen them before.
Jul 04, 2011
Rank: not rated yet
This is fixable with brief training. Any of the various speed-reading courses cover this.
I agree with Squirrel. Non-peer reviewed bollicks to suit a particular educational agenda.
In the spirit of doing pointless experiements for pre-determined results, why didn't they ask the "book-centered" children to pronounce correctly:
narcissism, prosthesis, methionylglutamine, spondylolisthesis, anesthetic, gammaglobunemia, onomatopoeia, acetaminophen, arcametiourologist, amphitheater, baccalaureate... etc etc
- From a Pissed off Kiwi who has an excessively large vocabulary, has personally found phonics to be incredibly useful and is really tired of the almost fanatical fervor of the anti-phonics hysteria league here.