Mild asthma patients may not need daily inhaled steroid therapy: study

For two decades, asthma treatment for millions of people with a milder form of the disease has consisted of daily inhaled steroid medicine to reduce inflammation. Now, a new study has found that asthmatics who take the low-dose medication as a daily routine do no better than those who turn to their inhalers only when they have symptoms.

The findings suggest a different, personalized, and far less expensive approach to treating the common , according to the researchers.

The report will be published in The on September 12, 2012.

In effect, the study challenges national and international guidelines that have been in place for 20 years. According to those recommendations, if a person's asthma is mild but persistent, he or she should take an inhaled steroid every day to suppress and reduce the risk of .

Mild persistent asthma is one of four types of the disease, which affects as many as one in every 12 people in the United States, according to federal statistics.

"Daily with an has long been believed to be the best treatment for mild persistent asthma, but it is not followed by the majority of patients,'' said senior author Homer A. Boushey, MD, a UCSF professor of medicine in the division of Pulmonary and . A pioneer in the field who has been involved in asthma research for 40 years, Boushey served on the expert committee that developed the current National Institutes of Health's guidelines for managing the disease.

"People don't seem to like taking this type of treatment every day – just a third of the inhaler prescriptions are renewed even once,'' Boushey said. "So we wondered what would happen if people with mild asthma already well controlled by daily treatment with an inhaled corticosteroid instead took a puff only when they used their rescue medication – usually albuterol—for relief of symptoms.''

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
Dr. William J. Calhoun discusses how these findings may change treatment guidelines

The upshot: patients who took inhaled corticosteroid only when they had symptoms wound up using half as much of the medication but did not have more severe symptoms. Nor did they miss more days of work or school, or have more flare-ups.

Called the Best Adjustment Strategy for Asthma in the Longer Term trial (BASALT), the study involved a randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled trial conducted by the Asthma Clinical Research Network at 10 academic medical centers across the country including UCSF and the University of Texas Medical Branch.

Altogether, 342 adults with mild to moderate, took part in the study over nine months between 2007 and 2010. All were diagnosed by physicians and all had either reversible airflow limitation or airway hyperresponsiveness. In each case, the participant's asthma was under control due to low-dose inhaled corticosteroids.

The scientists in the study evaluated three different approaches to the use of inhaled corticosteroids:

  • Inhaler assessments and dosage adjustments made every six weeks by a physician;
  • Inhaler adjustments made every six weeks based on measurements of exhaled nitric oxide, a marker of inflammation of the airwaves;
  • Inhaler usage adjusted by participants based on their day-to-day symptoms – this consisted of taking one puff of their inhaled corticosteroid for every puff of an inhaler taken "as needed'' for relief of symptoms.
The researchers found that the frequency of flare-ups or exacerbations of asthma, symptom severity, and pulmonary function did not differ among the treatment groups. There was, however, a significant association between the effectiveness of self-administered medicine and race: Hispanic participants did not do as well with day-to-day adjusted treatment. The researchers conjectured that this could reflect linguistic or other social or cultural differences.

"The goal of our study was to compare different approaches to adjusting inhaled corticosteroid treatment on the frequency and severity of asthma attacks and on quality of life,'' Boushey said. "This is not a treatment breakthrough but it may possibly open the door to a new approach to treatment, and it will certainly be considered by the expert panel for the NIH's guidelines for .

"This approach allows personalization of treatment and is easy for patients. Also, it could hypothetically result in saving $2 billion a year in medication costs,'' Boushey said.

UCSF co-authors are John V. Fahy, MD, a professor of pulmonary medicine, and Stephen C. Lazarus, MD, a professor of clinical medicine. The lead authors are William J. Calhoun, MD, and Bill T. Ameredes, PhD, of the University of Texas Medical Branch.

"This is a step forward in asthma management,'' Calhoun said. "It enables patients to use their steroids only when they have symptoms. It is 'temporal personalization,' adjusting medication on a day to day basis.''

Asthma has been on the upswing for much of the last century, and is now one of the most common diseases in the world, affecting approximately 300 million people globally including an estimated 24 million people in the U.S., according to the federal Centers for Disease Control and Infection.

More prevalent in western, developed countries, the condition varies in its severity – some people are affected daily, others seasonally or episodically. is classified into four types based on severity: intermittent, mild persistent, moderate persistent, and severe persistent.

More information:
JAMA. 2012;308[10]:987-997.
JAMA. 2012;308[10]:1036-1037.

Related Stories

Treatment for mild asthma leads to improved lung function

Mar 10, 2008

A study by the Woolcock Institute of Medical Research in Sydney is the first to demonstrate that in patients with very mild or well-controlled asthma, regular treatment with low dose ICS leads to significantly better day–to-day ...

Recommended for you

Study reveals nervous system's role in asthma attacks

Jul 22, 2014

(Medical Xpress)—Asthma is a debilitating condition that kills 250,000 people around the world each year. People with asthma have hyperreactive airways and thickened lung walls obstructed with mucus. During ...

New diagnostic test to distinguish psoriasis from eczema

Jul 10, 2014

In some patients, the chronic inflammatory skin diseases psoriasis and eczema are similar in appearance. Up to now, dermatologists have therefore had to base their decision on which treatment should be selected on their own ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

tpb
1 / 5 (1) Sep 11, 2012
"just a third of the inhaler prescriptions are renewed even once"
"Asthma has been on the upswing for much of the last century"

Perhaps it's not asthma itself, but diagnosing of asthma that is on the upswing.
If two thirds of the people diagnosed with asthma don't use the inhalers, perhaps they don't have asthma or need to be treated for it.