Europe-wide study finds death rates after surgery double that of recent estimates

September 20, 2012

National estimates of death following general surgery have been too optimistic, suggests the first large-scale study to explore surgical outcomes across Europe published in the first Article in a special Lancet theme issue on surgery. New estimates generated using a snap-shot of death after surgery in over 46 000 patients from 500 hospitals in 28 European countries indicate that overall crude mortality (death from all causes) is 4%, which is more than double previous estimates.

The overall picture shows that mortality rates vary widely between countries, from 1.2% in Iceland to 21.5% in Latvia. In the UK, the mortality rate was 3.6%, well above the highest previous estimates of 1.

What is more, says Rupert Pearse from Queen Mary, University of London who led the research, "Nearly three-quarters of patients who died were never admitted to intensive care. Failure to allocate critical care resources to patients at greatest risk of death is a serious public health concern for patients undergoing surgery in Europe."

The European Study (EuSOS) measured national in-hospital mortality and examined the allocation of critical care resources during 7 days in April, 2011. (aged 16 years or older) who underwent various non-cardiac procedures in participating centres were enrolled and tracked for up to 60 days after surgery.

Even after adjusting for possible confounding variables (eg, urgency and surgical procedure, age, and presence of metastatic disease) substantial differences in remained between nations. Compared with the UK (the country with the largest dataset), patients in Poland (OR: 6.92), Latvia (OR: 4.98), and Romania (OR: 3.19) had the greatest odds of dying. Within western Europe, patients in Ireland (OR: 2.61), Italy (OR: 1.70), Belgium (1.65), Portugal (1.43), and France (1.36) had a higher risk of dying.

The researchers note that the high mortality they identified across Europe contrasts with the 2% for patients who are routinely admitted to critical care. They speculate that the provision and use of beds may play a vital role in improving survival in patients undergoing non-.

According to Pearse, "The substantial variations in mortality between countries highlight the urgent need for national and international strategies to improve care for this group of patients."

In a linked Comment, René Vonlanthen and Pierre-Alain Clavien from University Hospital Zurich in Switzerland write, "In future studies, we need to learn more about the relevant issues and optimum processes to secure quality [assurance in surgery]. Targets could include the type of intensive care beds needed, volume, university versus community hospitals, and surgeons' qualifications. Costs for the overall postoperative course would also be key, to allow us to propose cost-effective and relevant corrective measures."

Explore further: Body mass index associated with short-term mortality rates following surgery

More information:

Related Stories

Recommended for you

International study proves old blood is as good as new

October 24, 2016

It's been long thought that when blood transfusions are needed, it may be best to use the freshest blood, but McMaster University researchers have led a large international study proving that it is not so.

Study finds mixed results for use of mesh for hernia repair

October 18, 2016

Among patients undergoing incisional hernia repair, the use of mesh to reinforce the repair was associated with a lower risk of hernia recurrence over 5 years compared with when mesh was not used, although with long-term ...

Traditional surgery style worthwhile, says piles trial

October 10, 2016

Results of a five year trial on haemorrhoids (commonly known as piles), jointly sponsored by NHS Highland and the University of Aberdeen, have this week been published in The Lancet, one of the world's oldest and best known ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.