Attitudes to organic labels depend on consumers' values

by Krishna Ramanujan
Attitudes to organic labels depend on consumers' values
Organic labels can lead to positive or negative impressions, in part based on a consumer's personal values. Credit: USDA

Labeling food as "organic" may not always lead to a positive impression, according to a recent Cornell study.

The research, published Nov. 27 online in the journal , flips the notion of a "halo" effect for ethical labels. A refers to a phenomenon where a label leads consumers to have a positive opinion—and in the case of an organic label, a healthful impression—of those foods.

This research finds that such positive impressions are partly based on the personal values of a consumer. The two-part study found that some conditions can produce a negative impression of organic labels among consumers, due to the consumer's values.

In the first part, Jonathon Schuldt, Cornell assistant professor of communication, and Mary Hannahan, a student at the University of Michigan, asked 215 students whether they thought organic food was healthier and also tastier than conventional food. While most agreed that organics were a healthy choice compared with conventional food, fewer expected organic food to taste good by comparison. This latter finding was especially true for participants who had low concern for the environment.

"The personal values of the rater mattered," said Schuldt. "Our data suggest when organic practices do not appeal to a consumer's values, they expect to taste worse."

In part two of the study, the researchers explored whether there were contexts in which people who were pro-environment might have a of organic labels. Here, 156 participants read one of two versions of a fake news article that discussed the development of "a highly engineered drink product designed to relieve the symptoms of African children suffering from severe ," according to the study. To convey the artificial, engineered aspect of the beverage, the article described the drink—named "Relief drink 1.1"—as a "formula" that resulted from a collaboration between "scientists and the ." In one version of the news article, the engineered drink was described as organic every time the drink was mentioned. The other version never mentioned the word organic. Participants were randomly assigned one version of the news story or the other.

The results showed that participants who were highly pro-environment judged the organic version of the drink to be less effective compared with the non-organic version.

"It's a reminder that the halo effect hinges on the values of the perceiver," said Schuldt. "It's not the case that you can label a food organic and expect that everyone will perceive it more positively. Under certain circumstances, ethical labels could have an unintended backfire effect."

Future research may involve taste tests of organic and conventional foods to see if personal values influence a taster's perceptions when actually eating a food, Schuldt added.

Related Stories

Organic food label imparts 'health halo,' study finds

Apr 27, 2011

Don't judge food by its organic label because "organic" doesn't necessarily mean good it's for you. Yet a new study by Jenny Wan-Chen Lee, a graduate student in Cornell's Dyson School of Applied Economics and Management, ...

Organic food can sabotage diet and weight-loss

Jun 30, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- While organic food may contain fewer, if any, pesticides and additives, consumers mistakenly believe it also has fewer calories, say researchers at the University of Michigan.

Can 'organic' labels backfire?

Apr 28, 2010

Could organic labels lead you to overeat? These labels certainly appear to make people think their organic snack has a lot fewer calories than it really does.

Consumers mistake fair-trade foods for lower-calorie

Mar 16, 2012

(Medical Xpress) -- Claims on food labels that a product is organic, locally produced or made by workers subject to fair labor practices may mislead consumers into thinking that such foods are low in calories, ...

Recommended for you

Medicare hospital fund to last 4 years longer

13 hours ago

(AP)—The government says Medicare's finances have improved. The program's hospital trust fund won't be exhausted until 2030—four years later than last year's estimate.

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

skuznetsov
not rated yet Dec 10, 2012
In the case with "organic" label in the fake article perception was distorted by "collaboration between scientists and the food industry". So this study was biased somehow and not really clean experiment.