Uncovering the secrets of 3D vision: How glossy objects can fool the human brain

(Medical Xpress)—It's a familiar sight at the fairground: rows of people gaping at curvy mirrors as they watch their faces and bodies distort. But while mirrored surfaces may be fun to look at, new findings by researchers from the Universities of Birmingham, Cambridge and Giessen, suggest they pose a particular challenge for the human brain in processing images for 3D vision.

The researchers have taken advantage of the unusual visual behaviour of curved mirrors to study stereopsis: the process by which the brain combines images from the two eyes to see in 3D.

The work, published online today in the (PNAS), used and perceptual measurements to show that people often see the 'wrong' shape for glossy objects (like chrome bumpers or brass door knobs) because of the way the brain employs 'quality control' mechanisms when it views the world with two eyes. This reveals how the brain checks the 'usefulness' of the signals it receives from the senses, explaining why we sometimes misperceive shapes and distances. It also has some connections with the design of .

'We often think that the 3D information we get from having two eyes provides the gold standard for seeing in depth; but glossy objects pose a difficult challenge to the brain because the stereoscopic information often indicates depths that don't match the physical shape of the object' explains Dr Andrew Welchman, a Wellcome Trust Senior Research Fellow at the University of Birmingham. 'We found that the brain is sometimes 'fooled' into seeing the wrong 3D shape, but this depends on statistical properties of the that indicate how 'useful' the information is,' he adds.

To carry out the project, the team developed mathematical models that calculate the pattern of reflections seen when viewing glossy objects, and measured the perceived 3D appearance of these shapes.

'When a curved mirrored object reflects its surroundings, the reflections appear at a different depth than the glossy surface itself. This makes it difficult for the brain to work out the true 3D distance to the surface' explains Dr Alex Muryy, a research fellow at Birmingham who conducted the analyses. 'We found that even simple objects can produce very complex depth profiles, and reflections can behave very differently from normal stereoscopic information.' Understanding these differences provided the key to reveal the generalised way in which the brain analyses incoming information to judge the circumstances in which information should be trusted.

'Stereoscopic information is often highly informative, but in certain circumstances it can tell us the wrong thing or be unreliable. The challenge is therefore to understand how the brain knows when it should or should not trust this 3D information,' says Professor Roland Fleming, ,Giessen University in Germany. 'We have uncovered signals that are likely to be important in guiding the brain's use of the information by studying glossy objects. In particular, we can understand people's misperceptions because in these circumstances 3D reflections fall within the normal range of values, meaning that the takes the depth signals at face value.'

Professor Andrew Blake, team member from Microsoft Research Cambridge, adds: 'Understanding human stereo vision is fascinating in its own right and also because of the connections with stereo vision systems used in Robotics today.'

More information: This research is published online, 21 January 2013, in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States, 'Specular reflections and the estimation of shape from binocular disparity' by Muryy, Welchman, Blake & Fleming.

Related Stories

How the brain computes 3D structures

Jan 11, 2012

The incredible ability of our brain to create a three-dimensional (3D) representation from an object's two-dimensional projection on the retina is something that we may take for granted, but the process is not well understood ...

3-D brain centers pinpointed

Aug 01, 2007

In studies with monkeys, researchers have identified in detail the brain regions responsible for the unique ability of primates, including humans, to process visual 3D shapes to guide their sophisticated manipulation of objects.

Paper examines the illusion of the scintillating grid

Dec 19, 2012

(Medical Xpress)—The fascinating but deeply weird illusion of the scintillating grid, where the grid appears to sparkle, has been shown to be more sparkly when you view it with both eyes rather than one ...

Owl study expands understanding of human stereovision

Jul 11, 2011

Using owls as a model, a new research study reveals the advantage of stereopsis, commonly referred to as stereovision, is its ability to discriminate between objects and background; not in perceiving absolute depth. The findings ...

Recommended for you

Common infections tied to some stroke risk in kids

10 hours ago

A new study suggests that colds and other minor infections may temporarily increase stroke risk in children. The study found that the risk of stroke was increased only within a three-day period between a ...

Celebrities in 'Ice Bucket Challenge' to fight disease

21 hours ago

Steven Spielberg, Justin Bieber and Bill Gates are among many celebrities pouring buckets of ice water over their heads and donating to fight Lou Gehrig's disease, in a fundraising effort that has gone viral.

Study helps explain why elderly have trouble sleeping

22 hours ago

As people grow older, they often have difficulty falling asleep and staying asleep, and tend to awaken too early in the morning. In individuals with Alzheimer's disease, this common and troubling symptom ...

Targeted brain training may help you multitask better

Aug 20, 2014

The area of the brain involved in multitasking and ways to train it have been identified by a research team at the IUGM Institut universitaire de gériatrie de Montréal and the University of Montreal.

User comments