Americans frequent victims of 'seafood fraud', report says

Fish sold in the United States is often deliberately mislabeled, making American consumers the unwitting victims of "widespread seafood fraud," according to a report out Thursday.

Fully one-third of 1,215 samples collected by researchers proved to be a different variety than what was written on the label, according to Oceana, an working to protect the world's oceans.

The report was released as Europe is roiling from its own scandal, after millions of prepared food items labeled as containing beef were found to have been made with .

Oceana said tuna and red mullet were among the most frequently misidentified fish varieties in the United States and that of 120 samples labeled as red snapper, just seven were found to be genuine.

"Purchasing seafood has become the ultimate guessing game for US consumers," said Beth Lowell, campaign director at Oceana.

"Whether you live in Florida or Kansas, no one is safe from seafood fraud," she said.

"We need to track our seafood from boat to plate so that consumers can be more confident that the fish they purchase is safe, legal and honestly labeled."

Oceana said cheaper farmed fish frequently are substituted for wild seafood—pangasius for grouper, for example, and sold as red snapper.

Farmed salmon is often passed off as wild or , the group said, and overfished species sometimes are substituted for more sustainable varieties.

Previous studies by Oceana have found widespread mislabeling of , cod, tuna and .

The group said seafood was fraudulently identified as often as not in southern California, which had a mislabeling rate of 52 percent.

Fish was mislabeled 49 percent of the time in the Texan cities of Austin and Houston, and 48 percent of the time in Boston, Massachusetts.

Thirty-nine percent of fish was mislabeled in New York City; 38 percent in northern California and South Florida; 36 percent in Denver, Colorado; 35 percent in Kansas City, Missouri; and 32 percent in Chicago, the study said.

Overall, 44 percent of US retail outlets visited were found to have sold mislabeled fish, according to Oceana, which said the worst offenders were purveyors of sushi, which engaged in mislabeling 74 percent of the time.

Restaurants were found to mislabel their seafood 38 percent of the time, and grocery stores 18 percent.

Kimberly Warner, Oceana's senior scientist and the report's main author, said the findings are disturbing because food shoppers have a right to get what they've paid for.

"Apart from being cheated, many consumers are being denied the right to choose fish wisely based on health or conservation concerns," Warner said.

Europe's food scandal began in Britain and Ireland last month after horse DNA was found in what was labeled as beefburgers, and has spread across the continent and even to Asia, where some of the mislabeled food was exported.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

DNA barcoding reveals mislabeled cod and haddock in Dublin

Apr 22, 2010

Ecological scientists in Ireland recently used DNA barcoding to identify species of fish labeled as either "cod" or "haddock" in fish and chip shops, fresh fish counters and supermarkets in 10 postal districts in Dublin. ...

Restaurants plan DNA-certified premium seafood

Nov 27, 2011

(AP) -- Restaurants around the world will soon use new DNA technology to assure patrons they are being served the genuine fish fillet or caviar they ordered, rather than inferior substitutes, an expert in genetic identification ...

Eco-labeled seafood is not always what it seems

Aug 22, 2011

When you buy what looks to be a nice piece of certified sustainable fish at the supermarket, you'd like to think that's exactly what you're getting. Unfortunately, things aren't always what they seem, according to researchers ...

Recommended for you

User comments