Imbalanced hearing is more than a mild disability

March 12, 2014
Researchers at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis have received a five-year, $3 million grant from the National Institutes of Health to study the effects of asymmetric hearing loss in adults and children. Jill B. Firszt, Ph.D., holds a cochlear implant. She is investigating whether the implant will help patients with notable differences between each ear's ability to detect and process sound. The screen in the background shows an image of a cochlea (green) with the implant after a patient's surgery. Credit: Robert Boston

Researchers at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis have received a five-year, $3 million grant from the National Institutes of Health (NIH) to study the effects of asymmetric hearing loss in adults and children.

Asymmetric is a difference between the two ears' ability to detect and process sound. New studies indicate that people with asymmetric hearing experience greater communication difficulties than previously assumed.

"We have two ears for a reason," said Jill B. Firszt, PhD, associate professor, audiologist and director of the Cochlear Implant Program in the Department of Otolaryngology at the School of Medicine. "A common assumption was that hearing loss in just one ear was minimally disabling. However, our studies and those of others show that listening with just one ear seriously degrades signal segregation and communication, resulting in diminished quality of life."

Firszt's new grant enables continuation of in-depth studies that began in 2008. Patients in these studies have imbalanced hearing in which one ear is deaf and the other ear has varying levels of hearing (from normal to hearing loss augmented with a hearing aid or cochlear implant). Firszt and colleagues showed that individuals who had normal hearing in one ear and deafness in the opposite ear perceived their to be as disabling as those who had one hearing aid or one cochlear implant and deafness in the opposite ear. In other words, patients viewed many of their listening situations as equally difficult regardless of the mode of hearing in the better ear.

According to Firszt, with two equally functioning ears, the brain can use subtle differences in timing and sound intensity between the two ears to identify sound direction and distance from the listener and to understand speech better in the presence of background noise.

But with asymmetric hearing, it is difficult for people to discriminate voices they want to hear from background noise in restaurants, for example, or to sense the relative distance from one's position in traffic to an emergency vehicle's siren.

Firszt said that very little is known about the effect of asymmetric hearing when it occurs during childhood or is present at birth. Imbalanced hearing from early childhood may have developmental effects that differ from those experienced by an adult who has later onset of in one ear.

She said that all "unilateral listeners," particularly in adverse listening conditions, may draw upon cognitive resources in certain brain regions more dynamically than normal hearing listeners.

Through neuroimaging, Firszt hopes to define changes in the brain that accompany unilateral hearing loss as well as to better understand the extra effort required of unilateral listeners.

"We know that the brain copes with asymmetric hearing by reorganizing over time," she said. "We want to learn where and how quickly that reorganization occurs and how it impacts successful outcomes when hearing is restored years later through cochlear implants."

At Washington University, Firszt has observed substantial improvement in speech recognition and other benefits from studies in which a cochlear implant was fitted to the deaf ear and a continued to be used at the better ear of patients whose asymmetric hearing loss occurred in adulthood. However, for patients whose asymmetric hearing loss occurred in childhood, before speech and language were learned, outcomes have been reduced.

The new studies will attempt to better define the critical time period for restoring hearing when the loss is unilateral and to identify patients who will benefit most from the procedure.

In the United States, adult patients who have severe to profound hearing loss in one ear and normal hearing in the other have not been traditionally considered candidates for a cochlear implant, although this treatment has been approved in Europe.

Firszt and colleagues are participating in a clinical trial of this treatment. Washington University is one of four U.S. sites that will enroll individuals with adult-onset in one ear whose other ear has normal to near normal hearing to assess the effectiveness of a cochlear implant in the non-hearing ear. Data from the initial feasibility study may become the basis for a larger study to potentially gain approval for the procedure from the Food and Drug Administration.

"The trial and our grant-funded studies are aimed at discovering how to achieve the best possible outcomes for patients with asymmetric hearing," said Firszt. "The auditory system is designed to be binaural – to receive input from both ears. It is a highly interactive system rather than two independently operating ears. The system as a whole should be the focus of treatment; what happens to an individual ear affects that system. We now believe that restoring each individual ear's hearing to the feasible extent, and doing so as soon as possible, may be the best course for treating the system."

Explore further: Two bionic ears are better than the sum of their parts

Related Stories

Two bionic ears are better than the sum of their parts

September 20, 2012

Cochlear implants—electronic devices surgically implanted in the ear to help provide a sense of sound—have been successfully used since the late 1980's. But questions remain as to whether bilateral cochlear implants, ...

Short-term hearing loss can cause long-term problem

September 30, 2013

Short-term hearing loss during childhood may lead to persistent hearing deficits, long after basic auditory sensitivity has returned to normal. The processing of sound in the brain is shaped by early experience. New research ...

Recommended for you

The 'love hormone' may quiet tinnitus

September 23, 2016

(HealthDay)—People suffering from chronic ringing in the ears—called tinnitus—may find some relief by spraying the hormone oxytocin in their nose, a small initial study by Brazilian researchers suggests.

Bile acid uptake inhibitor prevents NASH / fatty liver in mice

September 21, 2016

Drugs that interfere with bile acid recycling can prevent several aspects of NASH (nonalcoholic steatohepatitis) in mice fed a high-fat diet, scientists from Emory University School of Medicine and Children's Healthcare of ...

New therapeutic target for Crohn's disease

September 20, 2016

Research from the Sanford Burnham Prebys Medical Discovery Institute (SBP) identifies a promising new target for future drugs to treat inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). The study, published today in Cell Reports, also indicates ...

Mosquitoes, Zika and biotech regulation

September 19, 2016

In a new Policy Forum article in Science, NC State professor Jennifer Kuzma argues that federal authorities are missing an opportunity to revise outdated regulatory processes not fit for modern innovations in biotechnology, ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.