Patients in 'stroke belt' satisfied with care, but many doctors lack cultural awareness
Most patients in the southeastern United States are satisfied with the care they get from their primary care doctor — though many doctors lack training for dealing with patients of different ethnic backgrounds and often fail to ask important questions that indicate multicultural awareness, according to results of two surveys presented at the American Heart Association's 11th Scientific Forum on Quality of Care and Outcomes Research in Cardiovascular Disease and Stroke.
"Effective communication between patients and their doctors is critical to ensure proper care and treatment is prescribed, and it's especially important in addressing disparities in the care of high risk patients," said Jill A. Foster, M.D., M.P.H., co-author of the study and medical director at CE Outcomes, LLC, in Birmingham, Ala. "Findings from these surveys suggest that neither patients nor doctors may realize they're missing key cultural differences, an oversight that can impede health outcomes."
Foster and colleagues conducted two separate surveys of patients and healthcare providers from the nation's Stroke Belt region (Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee and Virginia), an area of the country where strokes are more common.
The patient survey included 1,189 people (55 percent white, 43 percent black, ages 40-75 years). The respondents' primary care physician (PCP) (70 percent white, 18 percent black) was most often a family physician (69 percent).
In the patient survey:
- Ninety percent said they were satisfied with their care and have trust in their doctors.
- Sixty-one percent reported that their doctors never asked them if they sought advice from family members when making healthcare decisions.
- Fifty-one percent said their PCPs never asked if they wanted to invite family members to participate in such decision-making.
The provider survey queried 697 doctors (70 percent Caucasian/white; 13 percent Asian; 7 percent African American/black; 5 percent Latino/Hispanic, 4 percent multiple/other; and 1 percent Hawaiian/other Pacific islanders).
While 76 percent of the doctors reported some prior multicultural training, 18 percent — nearly one in five — said they consider such training to be of low importance. Although the doctors' average levels of perceived cross-cultural knowledge and skills were moderate, significant deficits were noted in some areas — more than 75 percent of them said they had limited knowledge of the National Standards on Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services (CLAS). The standards, published in 2001, were developed after the 2000 census reflected increased diversity in the U.S. population.
The goal of the CLAS standards is to help ensure that culturally diverse patients receive effective healthcare. Healthcare institutions that receive federal funds are required to follow four of the 14 standards, those covering language assistance services. Individual medical practices are encouraged but not required to follow the standards.
"Doctors involved in primary prevention must motivate patients and make sure they understand the importance of changing unhealthy lifestyle habits, such as smoking, or taking daily medication for conditions like high blood pressure or diabetes long before those things make the patients feel ill," said Yancy, medical director of the Baylor Heart and Vascular Institute and chief of Cardiothoracic Transplantation at Baylor University Medical Center in Dallas, Texas.
Results from both the patient and physician studies found significant differences associated with physicians' ethnic background. In the physician survey, black doctors, on average, were more likely to see themselves as most culturally attuned and prepared for multicultural healthcare delivery, followed by Asian physicians and white physicians in terms of attitudes, and cross-cultural knowledge and skills, Foster said.
The patient survey additionally revealed statistically significant differences between races:
- White patients were more likely than blacks to recall being asked if they used any traditional folk remedies.
- Patients with black physicians were more likely than those with white physicians to report being asked about their family's role in making health decisions and whether family members should be invited to participate in making decisions.
- Similarly, patients with black physicians reported more frequent use of various explanatory behaviors such as: encouraging patients to stop him/her when the patient becomes confused; asking if the patient understands the instructions and repeating them if necessary; and asking if the patient has any other questions before leaving the office.
One possible limitation of the patient survey is that respondents had to have seen their PCPs within the last year. Thus, the survey may not reflect the experiences of patients who have difficulty establishing a primary care relationship or avoid getting healthcare.
Foster characterized the survey findings as first steps to future research, but noted the findings add further support for interventions that make healthcare more culturally appropriate and patient-centered.