New prenatal screening test is easier but raises ethical issues

November 8, 2011 By Carolyn Pennington
Judy Delach, cytogenetics supervisor, and Peter Benn in the Human Genetics Cytogenetics Lab. Credit: Carolyn Pennington/UConn Health Center Photo

(Medical Xpress) -- New technology and innovations in genetic sequencing are dramatically changing the field of prenatal diagnosis and testing. Peter Benn, professor and director of the Diagnostic Human Genetics Laboratories at the Health Center, is at the forefront of researching and monitoring those changes and is known as an international expert on the topic.

The most recent and controversial changes involve a to screen for Down syndrome. The non-invasive procedure could make easier, but it comes with ethical issues and practical problems associated with providing the new test. That’s where Benn, with more than 30 years experience in the field, offers an important voice to the issue.

Benn is chair of an International Society for (ISPD) committee that recommends caution and counseling before women receive the test.

The new test is called MaterniT21 and is now available in major health facilities around the country. All it requires is a small sample of the mother’s blood. Through a complex form of DNA sequencing, the test can detect a large proportion of Down syndrome-affected pregnancies. A study published in the journal Genetics in Medicine indicates a Down syndrome detection rate of 98.6 percent.

Up until now, women had to undergo potentially risky procedures called amniocentesis or chorionic villus sampling to detect genetic abnormalities. These invasive tests require tapping into the mother’s womb with a needle and carry a small risk of miscarriage.

Benn says ISPD recognizes that the development of the new test will offer substantial opportunities to improve screening. But for now, the committee recommends caution against the ad-hoc use of the test in women at lower risk of Down syndrome-affected pregnancies.

For women who are found to be at high risk using one of the currently accepted protocols, Benn recommends detailed genetic counseling to explain the benefits and limitations of the new test.

Gender Issues

The development of other easier and earlier prenatal screening methods also raise serious concerns about non-medical uses. For example, fetal sex identification for the purpose of gender selection. 

Benn and colleagues at the Health Center, bioethicist Audrey Chapman and maternal-fetal medicine expert Dr. James Egan, worked together on a study to determine whether there is gender selection based on ultrasound results.

Their findings, published in the journal Prenatal Diagnosis, found that Asian-American mothers, especially with third pregnancies, had more boys than girls in ratios strongly suggesting prenatal sex selection, similar to that which occurs in China and India.

New screening tests have been developed that allow parents to find out their child’s sex even earlier than with ultrasound. Benn wonders whether that may lead to an even greater gender imbalance in countries such as China and India.

Some fetal DNA test-manufacturers are trying to discourage sex selection by not selling in China and India, and requiring customers to sign waivers saying that is not their motivation.

But the simplicity of the testing may make it tough to regulate. “If you can send off a blood sample to a laboratory and find out the sex of the baby and go somewhere else to request a pregnancy termination – no one will ask why,” explains Benn.

Rocket Scientist or Rock Star?

While the new MaterniT21 test is currently aimed at testing for , the technology is in place to identify many more conditions. That means an enormous amount of information will be available about an unborn baby.  “Just think of the implications,” adds Benn.

If testing for mild or late-onset genetic conditions becomes a routine part of prenatal exams, parents will then have to make the difficult decision of whether to carry the ‘unhealthy’ fetus to term.

But it goes beyond genetic abnormalities or gender, it’s everything. What would you like to know about your baby – sports ability, physical appearance, intelligence? And what if your baby doesn’t have the characteristics you had hoped for?

“As the technology has developed, there are these really big ethical issues that are emerging and most clinicians are not ready to deal with them,” says Benn. “Part of my interest has been to draw attention to these and in having a discussion about what is the right way to use the .”

Explore further: Study shows that new DNA test to identify Down syndrome in pregnancy is ready for clinical use

Related Stories

Study shows that new DNA test to identify Down syndrome in pregnancy is ready for clinical use

October 17, 2011
A new DNA-based prenatal blood test that can strikingly reduce the number of risky diagnostic procedures needed to identify a pregnancy with Down syndrome is ready to be introduced into clinical practice. The test can be ...

Boy or girl? A simple test raises ethical concerns

August 10, 2011
(AP) -- Boy or girl? A simple blood test in mothers-to-be can answer that question with surprising accuracy at about seven weeks, a research analysis has found.

Recommended for you

Expert: Be concerned about how apps collect, share health data

October 20, 2017
As of 2016 there were more than 165,000 health and wellness apps available though the Apple App Store alone. According to Rice University medical media expert Kirsten Ostherr, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates ...

Three million Americans carry loaded handguns daily, study finds

October 19, 2017
An estimated 3 million adult American handgun owners carry a firearm loaded and on their person on a daily basis, and 9 million do so on a monthly basis, new research indicates. The vast majority cited protection as their ...

More teens than ever aren't getting enough sleep

October 19, 2017
If you're a young person who can't seem to get enough sleep, you're not alone: A new study led by San Diego State University Professor of Psychology Jean Twenge finds that adolescents today are sleeping fewer hours per night ...

Across Asia, liver cancer is linked to herbal remedies: study

October 18, 2017
Researchers have uncovered widespread evidence of a link between traditional Chinese herbal remedies and liver cancer across Asia, a study said Wednesday.

Eating better throughout adult years improves physical fitness in old age, suggests study

October 18, 2017
People who have a healthier diet throughout their adult lives are more likely to be stronger and fitter in older age than those who don't, according to a new study led by the University of Southampton.

Global calcium consumption appears low, especially in Asia

October 18, 2017
Daily calcium intake among adults appears to vary quite widely around the world in distinct regional patterns, according to a new systematic review of research data ahead of World Osteoporosis Day on Friday, Oct. 20.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.