Smokescreen lifted on tobacco industry tactics

June 7, 2012, Cancer Research UK
Smokescreen lifted on tobacco industry tactics

(Medical Xpress) -- A new report published today (Thursday) reveals how tobacco companies worked to prevent the strengthening of European tobacco legislation such as  improvements to tobacco labelling and the removal of misleading terms such as ‘light’ and ‘mild’.

The report was commissioned by the Smoke Free Partnership (SFP) through a Cancer Research UK grant and carried out by academic researchers at the University of Bath, University of Edinburgh, and London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. It is being released on World No Tobacco Day which is themed “Tobacco Industry Interference”.

Researchers reviewed previously secret corporate documents released after legal action in America. These were examined to understand the tactics used by the tobacco industry when the European Union was developing the Tobacco Products Directive (TPD) in 1999. The TPD is currently under review which makes this report particularly pertinent, as many of the same tactics are being employed once again.

Direct lobbying of politicians and civil servants who were seen to have particular influence over the shape of the new legislation was a key tactic. The German government and MEPs played an important role in this respect.

Indirect lobbying was also done through tobacco farmers, suppliers and distributors as well as engaging with trade organizations.

Three key arguments were used to argue against the legislation.

The legal argument was that the proposed measures to control tobacco were outside the EU’s jurisdiction and that the directive was in breach of free trade agreements.

The economic argument stated that the TPD was a threat to jobs, with tobacco industry reports exaggerating job losses while ignoring the potential health benefits.

Scientific arguments exploited the lack of technical expertise within the European Commission on the complex issues surrounding the Directive. This enabled tobacco industry representatives to gain direct access to officials.

The tobacco industry made at least five legal challenges against the Directive. Despite these efforts the TPD was successfully adopted in 2001.

Documents also reveal that the were not entirely united in their approach to TPD. While some favoured tactics aiming to ‘block, amend or delay’ the directive others preferred a ‘constructive engagement’ approach.

The report provides a timely warning over tobacco industry tactics and the global WHO treaty on tobacco control, which was enacted after the TPD came into force, provides clear guidance for officials to avoid conflict of interests by meeting with the tobacco industry only when absolutely necessary . It also shows the public health community that it needs to strengthen its expertise in the areas of trade agreements, economics and science.

Jean King, Cancer Research UK’s director of tobacco control, said: “This report provides a timely reminder of tactics used by the tobacco industry. Attempting to better regulate how tobacco is sold is key to reducing the deadly impact that smoking has. The UK could become the first country in Europe to remove the glitzy, slickly designed packs currently used to market cigarettes. It’s important that Governments and the public are aware of tactics and arguments that are used to fight against proposals designed to help control a product that will kill half of all long term smokers.

“We know the tobacco industry fears the introduction of plain packaging but we believe it will give millions of children one less reason to start smoking. To make this happen we need to show public support for plain packaging, so every single name on our petition counts, please join us.”

Florence Berteletti, director of the Smoke Free Partnership, said: “It’s very important that members of parliament, civil servants and the public are aware of how the tobacco industry tries to interfere with tobacco regulation. It is interesting to see that the industry is using the same tactics - block, amend, and delay legislation - today as it did ten years ago to influence the upcoming review of the Tobacco Products Directive, but with additional resources and at a larger scale.

“While the industry’s tactics have not changed in the last 12 years, support for tobacco control has definitely increased. The Framework Convention on , the world’s first international health treaty, has set out clear guidance on the best practice in public policy.The has powers but no legitimacy any longer. More and more policy makers recognize this and we look forward to working with them to ensure that the second revision of the Directive reflects the political commitment to combat tobacco use at EU level.”

Explore further: Researchers launch Facebook site to monitor tobacco industry tactics

Related Stories

Researchers launch Facebook site to monitor tobacco industry tactics

May 14, 2012
The University’s Tobacco Control Research Group (TCRG) has identified several methods used by transnational tobacco companies in response to the changes within the global tobacco market.

Cigarette firms slowing anti-tobacco fight: report

March 20, 2012
Alleged "interference" by cigarette firms in public health policies is slowing down a UN-backed global campaign against tobacco use and its related health risks, a report said Tuesday.

Tobacco industry a devious enemy: WHO chief

March 20, 2012
World Health Organisation (WHO) chief Margaret Chan on Tuesday decried the tobacco industry as a "ruthless and devious enemy" and urged governments and civil society groups to unite against cigarette firms.

WHO chief accuses 'big tobacco' of dirty tricks

October 10, 2011
The World Health Organization's chief on Monday urged governments to unite against "big tobacco", as she accused the industry of dirty tricks, bullying and immorality in its quest to keep people smoking.

Recommended for you

Marijuana use may not aid patients in opioid addiction treatment

December 4, 2017
Many patients who are being treated for opioid addiction in a medication-assisted treatment clinic use marijuana to help manage their pain and mood symptoms.

For opiate addiction, study finds drug-assisted treatment is more effective than detox

November 23, 2017
Say you're a publicly insured Californian with an addiction to heroin, fentanyl or prescription narcotics, and you want to quit.

Study finds medical cannabis is effective at reducing opioid addiction

November 17, 2017
A new study conducted by researchers at The University of New Mexico, involving medical cannabis and prescription opioid use among chronic pain patients, found a distinct connection between having the legal ability to use ...

Insomnia linked to alcohol-use frequency among early adolescents, says new psychology study

November 8, 2017
Insomnia is linked to frequency of alcohol use among early adolescents, according to new Rutgers University–Camden research.

Large declines seen in teen substance abuse, delinquency

October 25, 2017
More than a decade of data indicates teens have become far less likely to abuse alcohol, nicotine and illicit drugs, and they also are less likely to engage in delinquent behaviors, such as fighting and stealing, according ...

Trying to get sober? NIH offers tool to help find good care

October 3, 2017
The phone calls come—from fellow scientists and desperate strangers—with a single question for the alcohol chief at the National Institutes of Health: Where can my loved one find good care to get sober?

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jun 07, 2012
The tobacco industry set the mold for the energy (coal, oil) industry to follow regarding pollution standards and global warming.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.