Sugar fights still simmer as new brain study finds fructose might stimulate appetite

January 14, 2013 by Jeffrey Norris

Fructose, a sugar much maligned in recent years, recently took another hit when a preliminary study by Yale University found that it might stimulate appetite more than other sugar types. The results came as no surprise to Robert Lustig, MD, a pediatric endocrinologist at the UCSF Benioff Children's Hospital who's made headlines for years with his public health crusade against excess sugar consumption.

In the Jan. 2 study published in the (), researchers used (MRI) techniques to demonstrate that ingested fructose affects blood flow differently than glucose in the brainregions associated with feeding behavior, including the hippocampus and the . The Yale researchers concluded that fructose consumption might be more likely to stimulate rather than curb appetite, similar to what was found in earlier .

In fact, on average, the 20 normal-weight, young adults who participated in the study reported that hunger was sated by glucose, but not by fructose, although the study does not demonstrate that fructose causes obesity.

At UCSF, where many researchers and physicians are trying to understand obesity and its causes, Lustig stands out for his concern over the physiological effects of sugar consumption. He's also a strong advocate of policy changes that would lessen what he believes are 's contribution to the obesity epidemic in the United States.

Lustig, currently on a media tour for his new book "Fat Chance: Beating the Odds Against Sugar, Processed Food, Obesity, and Disease," said he would have been surprised if the Yale researchers had found no differences in the effect from sugar types.

"It's one more nail in the coffin" for the argument that fructose and glucose act the same, that calories count the same no matter where they come from, Lustig said.

Fructose in pure form is not in our diets

However, he noted, it would have been more relevant to compare sucrose to starch because people don't really eat pure fructose.

Sucrose is made up of equal parts glucose and fructose. High-fructose corn syrup is not much different than sucrose, as it contains roughly 55 percent fructose. Consumption of fructose in these forms has been trending upward for decades. The other main sugar in the diet is starch, made of glucose.

Lustig has long argued that table sugar is metabolized differently than starch. Controversially, he says research shows that insulin release triggered by sugar consumptions blocks signals sent by another hormone, leptin, and thereby fools our brains into thinking that we are not yet full.

Furthermore, according to Lustig, sugar consumption, like alcohol, is a major contributor to fatty liver disease, which has been on the rise.

The video will load shortly

The conclusion that elevated levels of insulin in the blood is a driver of obesity rather than simply a consequence of excessive weight gain—at least in mice—is shared by University of British Columbia researchers led by James Johnson, PhD, who found in a study published in the December 2012 issue of Cell Metabolism that mice genetically protected from rising insulin secretion with age also did not become obese.  Fat cells in the mice genetically programmed to secrete less insulin burned more energy.

While Lustig's views remain controversial, his arguments are more widely heard than they might have been in years past. A YouTube video of one of his UCSF lectures, "Sugar: The Bitter Truth," has received more than 3 million views.

His arguments also have found an audience with some major politicians, including New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg, who has spearheaded a successful drive to ban restaurant and concession stand sales of sugary drinks bigger than 16 ounces. Earlier this month, in the United Kingdom – which has one of the highest child obesity rates in Europe – the health secretary of the opposition Labour party, Andy Burnham, made headlines by calling for a ban on the sale of breakfast cereals with more than 30 percent sugar.

In the U.S., where public support for even bedrock public health programs such as universal vaccination seems to be weakening – perhaps evidenced by recent upticks in the incidence of serious infectious diseases such a measles and whooping cough – Lustig is nonetheless ready to do battle. He is not one to be cowed by those who complain about "nanny state" regulations.

Lustig argues that a failure to address obesity and associated blood fat abnormalities, high blood pressure and insulin resistance – risk factors for heart disease and diabetes collectively known as the metabolic syndrome – will bankrupt Medicare in due time.

"There is no prevention of metabolic syndrome if we don't fix the food supply," he said.

Food calories might not all count the same

A decade ago, the "a calorie is a calorie" paradigm was firmly in place in the medical mainstream, and rarely challenged. Last week, along with the Yale study, JAMA prominently published an editorial by two Oregon Health Science University researchers that emphatically did challenge that paradigm:

"When results of studies manipulating a dietary element show adverse effects on food intake leading to increased body weight, a common counterargument is that it is the excess calories that are important, not the food. Simply put: just eat less. The reality, however, is that hunger and fullness are major determinants of how much humans eat, just as thirst determines how much humans drink."

Explore further: Sugar as a potential health risk is getting a closer look

More information: … px?articleid=1555133 … -4131%2812%2900453-6

Related Stories

Sugar as a potential health risk is getting a closer look

May 4, 2011
Robert Lustig, MD, a UCSF pediatrician and clinical researcher, is an outspoken iconoclast when it comes to diet and metabolism.

Study offers insight to how fructose causes obesity, metabolic syndrome

February 27, 2012
A group of scientists from across the world have come together in a just-published study that provides new insights into how fructose causes obesity and metabolic syndrome, more commonly known as diabetes.

Sugar: Just how bad is it?

May 4, 2011
A couple of weeks ago, science writer Gary Taubes — author of the book “Why We Get Fat” — wrote an article for the New York Times magazine in which he analyzed the debate over whether sugar and high-fructose ...

Tasting fructose with the pancreas

February 6, 2012
Taste receptors on the tongue help us distinguish between safe food and food that's spoiled or toxic. But taste receptors are now being found in other organs, too. In a study published online the week of February 6 by the ...

Fructose consumption increases risk factors for heart disease

July 28, 2011
A recent study accepted for publication in The Endocrine Society's Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism (JCEM) found that adults who consumed high fructose corn syrup for two weeks as 25 percent of their daily calorie ...

Recommended for you

Parents have critical role in preventing teen drinking

July 20, 2017
Fewer teenagers are drinking alcohol but more needs to be done to curb the drinking habits of Australian school students, based on the findings of the latest study by Adelaide researchers.

Aging Americans enjoy longer life, better health when avoiding three risky behaviors

July 20, 2017
We've heard it before from our doctors and other health experts: Keep your weight down, don't smoke and cut back on the alcohol if you want to live longer.

Fresh fish oil lowers diabetes risk in rat offspring

July 19, 2017
Fresh fish oil given to overweight pregnant rats prevented their offspring from developing a major diabetes risk factor, Auckland researchers have found.

High-dose vitamin D doesn't appear to reduce the winter sniffles for children

July 18, 2017
Giving children high doses of vitamin D doesn't appear to reduce the winter sniffles, a new study has found.

Scientists develop new supplement that can repair, rejuvenate muscles in older adults

July 18, 2017
Whey protein supplements aren't just for gym buffs according to new research from McMaster university. When taken on a regular basis, a combination of these and other ingredients in a ready-to-drink formula have been found ...

Study: Eating at 'wrong time' affects body weight, circadian rhythms

July 18, 2017
A new high-precision feeding system for lab mice reinforces the idea that the time of day food is eaten is more critical to weight loss than the amount of calories ingested.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jan 21, 2013
Another epi observational study is just that, another epi observational study. No cause relationship here. Give me a call when you have one.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.