3 Questions: MIT biologist on new resveratrol study

March 7, 2013 by Anne Trafton
3 Questions: MIT biologist on new resveratrol study
New research has shown for the first time that resveratrol, a compound found in grapes and red wine that can counteract the effects of aging, acts by directly activating sirtuins.

In the early 1990s, MIT professor Leonard Guarente discovered that sirtuins, a class of proteins found in nearly all animals, protect against the effects of aging in yeast; similar effects have since been seen in many other organisms. In 2003, David Sinclair, who had been a postdoc in Guarente's lab, found that resveratrol, a compound found in grapes and red wine, can also counteract the effects of aging. Since then, many scientists have tried to tease out the exact relationship among sirtuins, resveratrol and aging.

In a paper appearing this week in Science, a team led by Sinclair, now a professor of genetics at Harvard Medical School, shows for the first time that resveratrol and similar compounds act by directly activating sirtuins. Guarente, the Professor of Biology at MIT, discusses the significance of the new finding.

Q: There has been some scientific disagreement over whether resveratrol helps sirtuins to slow the aging process. What is the basis of this disagreement?

A: Between 10 and 15 years ago, we and others proposed three features of sirtuins that we thought were demonstrated at that time. One is that they regulate aging; the second is that they mediate the of ; and the third is that they can be activated by small molecules like . In the intervening decade or so, all three of those claims were challenged, one way or another. There was a paper published a few years ago that said basically the don't work. In recent years, one by one the original claims are being upheld.

Regarding resveratrol and related compounds, there are three schools of thought. One is the compounds don't do anything vis-à-vis sirtuins, but deliver benefits as . Another is that they're activating sirt1 (the major mammalian sirtuin) in cells, but it's an indirect effect of something else that they're doing in cells. The third possibility is that they're having a direct effect on .

Some people have doubted this last possibility, because most small molecules that act as drugs inhibit enzymes, instead of activating them. It's easy to see how you could get a small molecule in the wrong place and block an , but to see it activating an enzyme is more rare. So people said these compounds don't really work that way in living cells, and they must be doing something else.

Q: How does the new study help to resolve that question?

This paper, I think, provides findings that are very difficult to interpret in any way other than direct activation by the compounds. The strongest evidence in the paper is that they found they could change one amino acid of the protein, from glutamate to lysine, and that change had no effect at all on the catalytic properties of the enzyme—the enzyme still works the same way as far as you can measure, there's no difference between the mutant and the control. However, the mutant is completely dead with regard to activation by resveratrol. They also tested some of the newer compounds—I believe it was about 100 of them—and found the same thing. The mutant enzyme was either inactive or much less activatable than the normal version.

They then engineered cells that would express either normal sirt1 enzyme or the enzyme that has the single amino-acid change. The cells that express the normal enzyme respond to the activation with real biological readouts, like activation of mitochondria, which is one of the things sirt1 is known to do, whereas cells with the mutant enzyme do not respond.

So if you put all this together—the studies in the test tube, and in cells, I think it makes a convincing case that all of these compounds, including resveratrol, must act directly on the enzyme to boost its activity.

Q: What would be the potential benefits of taking drugs that mimic the effects of resveratrol?

A: We think that aging is a component of many diseases or conditions, such as diabetes, Alzheimer's disease and arthritis. Generally speaking, these occur late in life. The idea is that if you could target a molecule that could regulate the , you could control these diseases. There's a lot of genetic data in mice that shows you can activate sirt1 genetically, and that is protective against all of these age-related diseases. So the logical surmise would be that any compound that could activate sirt1 might have benefit against those diseases.

The initial study by Sinclair and Howitz 10 years ago identified resveratrol and other natural products that were of a class called polyphenols. They're found in plants and in grapes, and in . That sparked the biotech industry to develop new synthetic compounds that are not natural products, and that work better than resveratrol. There are hundreds of those now. These are the lead compounds for what are being tested in human clinical trials now for protection against diseases of aging.

People who develop drugs always want to make sure they understand what the real targets of the drugs are. The idea that resveratrol—but moreover, the newer compounds that are being developed for humans—are directly hitting sirt1 as the target, I think will be a green light for further drug development.

Explore further: New study validates longevity pathway: Findings identify universal mechanism for activating anti-aging pathway

More information: medicalxpress.com/news/2013-03-validates-longevity-pathway-universal-mechanism.html

Related Stories

More evidence for longevity pathway

May 1, 2012

New research reinforces the claim that resveratrol—a compound found in plants and food groups, notably red wine—prolongs lifespan and health-span by boosting the activity of mitochondria, the cell's energy supplier.

Recommended for you

Discovery offers new hope to repair spinal cord injuries

April 24, 2017

Scientists at the Gladstone Institutes created a special type of neuron from human stem cells that could potentially repair spinal cord injuries. These cells, called V2a interneurons, transmit signals in the spinal cord to ...

Motion sickness drug worsens motion perception

April 24, 2017

A new study led by Massachusetts Eye and Ear researchers found that oral promethazine, a drug commonly taken to alleviate motion sickness, temporarily worsened vestibular perception thresholds by 31 percent, lowering one's ...

Macrophages shown to be essential to a healthy heart rhythm

April 20, 2017

A Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH)-led research team has identified a surprising new role for macrophages, the white blood cells primarily known for removing pathogens, cellular debris and other unwanted materials. In ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (2) Mar 07, 2013
Can anyone say what dosage of resveratol, in mg/kg, was used in the initial positive in vitro study?

1 / 5 (2) Mar 08, 2013
Why do they always say wine, I though grape juice has 10x the resveratrol or something.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.