Condemned man's wish raises ethical questions

November 15, 2013 by Amanda Lee Myers

(AP)—An eleventh-hour request by a death row inmate to donate his organs is raising troubling moral and medical questions among transplant experts and ethicists.

Less than a day before child killer Ronald Phillips was set to die by lethal injection, Republican Gov. John Kasich on Wednesday postponed the execution to look into Phillips' request.

Phillips, 40, wants to give relatives a kidney before he is put to death and his heart afterward.

The governor said he is open to the possibility of Phillips donating a kidney or other non-vital organs before he is executed. But Kasich appeared to rule out a post-execution donation.

"I realize this is a bit of uncharted territory for Ohio," Kasich said in a statement, "but if another life can be saved by his willingness to donate his organs and tissues, then we should allow for that to happen."

Some medical experts and others warn that execution chemicals could render organs unusable. They are also deeply disturbed by the prospect of death row inmates donating organs, even if can ease shortages so severe that patients die while on the waiting list.

They question whether the condemned can freely give consent, or are desperately hoping to win clemency. They worry that such practices would make judges and juries more likely to hand out death sentences. And they are troubled by the notion of using inmates for spare parts.

Medical ethicist Arthur Caplan of New York University said organ donation is incompatible with the goals of punishment.

"It's unethical because this guy who's being executed raped and killed a 3-year-old. When you donate your organs, there's a kind of redemption," Caplan said. "Punishment and organ donation don't go well together. I don't think the kinds of people we're executing we want to make in any way heroic."

Yet it's not unheard of for a death row inmate to become an organ donor.

Condemned Delaware inmate Steven Shelton was allowed to donate a kidney to his mother in 1995, though his execution wasn't imminent.

In 1996, the Alabama Supreme Court halted David Larry Nelson's execution so he could donate a kidney to his sick brother. His brother was too ill for surgery and later died.

Requests in other states, including Texas, have been rejected. All involved so-called live donations, never donation of a vital organ like a heart.

Richard Dieter, executive director of the Washington-based Death Penalty Information Center, which opposes capital punishment, said the practice raises troubling concerns.

"Once you put the person into the death row or execution category, then their life becomes less in the equation of things," he said. "That's a slippery slope of one life being used to save another."

Anne Paschke, a spokeswoman for the United Network for Organ Sharing, said in a statement that her organization's ethics committee in 2007 deemed the practice "morally reprehensible."

She said the committee sees extreme difficulty "in ensuring that a condemned prisoner could give proper informed consent for donation, free from any coercion or consideration of personal gain."

Caplan said keeping vital organs viable during executions would require avoiding , electrocution and other methods that would harm them.

Utah murderer Gary Gilmore, executed by firing squad in 1977, agreed to donate his eyes, kidneys, liver and pituitary gland for medical use. His kidneys proved unusable because of bullet wounds.

"The only way I can think of to get organs out of prisoners is to shoot them in the head or guillotine them," Caplan said. "Are we really going to have witnessed executions of that type? I don't think so."

Dr. Brooks Edwards, the director of the Mayo Clinic Transplant Center and a transplant cardiologist, said it would be possible to use some organs after an execution, including the liver and kidney, but not the heart.

Even so, he said he is opposed to the idea, saying it could lead a judge or jury to believe that handing down a death sentence could help save another's life.

"One would worry that the enticement of organ donation could somehow be perceived, even subconsciously, as some kind of perverse incentive. I think that's wrong," Edwards said. "There are certainly accusations of prisoners being executed in other countries for organ donation, and we have to be well above that."

States such as California, Utah, Arizona, Oklahoma and Texas have nonetheless considered policies promoting among inmates. Some proposals would shorten sentences in exchange for organ or bone marrow donations.

Some transplant recipients think such donations could be a good thing.

"I don't know who my donor is and I really don't care," said John Afek, a 57-year-old accountant and financial adviser who underwent a heart transplant nearly two years ago. "It gave me my life back, and I'm a single dad with a couple kids who suddenly got their father back."

He said an inmate's crime shouldn't even be a part of the conversation.

"How many people die waiting on a list?" Afek said. "If they want to do it, God bless them. We need the organs."

Explore further: China to phase out prisoner organ donation

Related Stories

China to phase out prisoner organ donation

March 23, 2012
(AP) -- China will abolish the transplanting of organs from executed prisoners within five years and try to spur more citizens to donate, a top health official says.

China begins phasing out prisoner organs next year

November 2, 2012
China will start phasing out its reliance on organs from executed prisoners for transplants early next year as a new national donation system is implemented, a government-appointed expert has said.

Death-row inmates main source of organs in China: report

March 7, 2012
Executed prisoners were still the main source of organs used in transplant operations in China due to the lack of voluntary donations, a top health official was quoted saying Wednesday.

Cultural attitudes impede organ donations in China

May 17, 2013
(AP)—China is phasing out its reliance on executed prisoners for donated organs, but an architect of the country's transplant system said Friday that ingrained cultural attitudes are impeding the rise of donations among ...

Poll shows half of Americans would consider donating a kidney to a stranger

April 18, 2013
Good news for anyone needing a transplant; a new Mayo Clinic survey shows that the public's support for both living and deceased organ donation is increasing. Eighty-four percent of respondents said they would be very or ...

China to stop relying on prisoner organs: minister

November 22, 2012
China will no longer rely on executed prisoners as a source of transplant organs within two years, a health minister said according to state media Thursday.

Recommended for you

Exploring the potential of human echolocation

June 25, 2017
People who are visually impaired will often use a cane to feel out their surroundings. With training and practice, people can learn to use the pitch, loudness and timbre of echoes from the cane or other sounds to navigate ...

Team eradicates hepatitis C in 10 patients following lifesaving transplants from infected donors

April 30, 2017
Ten patients at Penn Medicine have been cured of the Hepatitis C virus (HCV) following lifesaving kidney transplants from deceased donors who were infected with the disease. The findings point to new strategies for increasing ...

'bench to bedside to bench': Scientists call for closer basic-clinical collaborations

March 24, 2017
In the era of genome sequencing, it's time to update the old "bench-to-bedside" shorthand for how basic research discoveries inform clinical practice, researchers from The Jackson Laboratory (JAX), National Human Genome Research ...

The ethics of tracking athletes' biometric data

January 18, 2017
(Medical Xpress)—Whether it is a FitBit or a heart rate monitor, biometric technologies have become household devices. Professional sports leagues use some of the most technologically advanced biodata tracking systems to ...

Financial ties between researchers and drug industry linked to positive trial results

January 18, 2017
Financial ties between researchers and companies that make the drugs they are studying are independently associated with positive trial results, suggesting bias in the evidence base, concludes a study published by The BMJ ...

Best of Last Year – The top Medical Xpress articles of 2016

December 23, 2016
(Medical Xpress)—It was a big year for research involving overall health issues, starting with a team led by researchers at the UNC School of Medicine and the National Institutes of Health who unearthed more evidence that ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.