Safety checklists for surgery may not lower deaths, complications

March 12, 2014 by Steven Reinberg, Healthday Reporter
Safety checklists for surgery may not lower deaths, complications: study
But Canadian program wasn't voluntary and that may have affected results, researchers say.

(HealthDay)—Surgical safety checklists have been hailed as powerful tools that help reduce deaths and complications, but these lists may not be all they're cracked up to be, Canadian researchers report.

Despite earlier studies that showed a 50 percent reduction in deaths by using such checklists for surgeries, these researchers found no significant difference in the rate of deaths and before and after the checklists were introduced.

The checklists were designed to get the surgical team to work together and to take the time to be sure of the patient's identity, the procedure to be done and what equipment will be needed. Also included was an accounting of all the after the operation.

"We couldn't identify a measurable improvement with checklists," said lead researcher Dr. David Urbach, a professor of surgery and at the University of Toronto.

One problem might be mandating the use of a checklist, as was done in Canada, without getting hospitals to buy into the program, he said.

"It's one thing if hospitals develop these things on their own, where people are motivated and engaged," Urbach said. "That can transform a culture and make it more safety-conscious. If it is mandated, it may not achieve the same result."

It could also be that the first studies done on the benefits of checklists painted too rosy a picture of their benefit, Urbach said. "It may not be possible to achieve the results detected in those studies," he said.

Those first studies suggested that checklists could cut the risk of dying in half. "That's a really big effect," Urbach said. "Very few things reduce something by 50 percent."

Urbach said he still believes in the value of checklists as a way of bringing the surgical team together to talk about the patient. "There is probably a lot of value in checklists, even if it can't be measured in terms of reducing the risk of bad outcomes," he said.

The report was published in the March 13 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine.

Dr. Lucian Leape, an adjunct professor of health policy at the Harvard School of Public Health, wrote an editorial accompanying the study in the journal. "The surgical checklist is a powerful tool for reducing complications and deaths, but it only works if you use it right," Leape said.

Implementing the use of a checklist is not easy, he said. "It requires people to change a lot of the ways they do things. It's difficult to do, and it takes time to see the effects," he said.

The checklist most commonly used is one created by the World Health Organization. Its list is divided into three parts.

The first part includes steps to be taken before anesthesia, including verifying the patient's identity, medical condition and the procedure.

The second part, called a "timeout," takes place before the first incision. During this time, everybody introduces themselves. The surgeon and others confirm what they are going to do and check that all necessary medications and any special patient needs are in place.

Finally, before the patient leaves the operating room, all instruments and sponges are accounted for, any blood for lab tests is labeled and any problems are discussed. The doctor reviews any concerns about the patient's recovery and management.

Leape said the WHO checklist is a guide, and each hospital needs to adjust it to make it work for them. "The point is to make it your own," he said. "In the process of making it your own, you really develop a lot more teamwork, and that's what I think really makes a difference."

The problem in all areas of patient safety is how to get hospitals to improve their performance, Leape said.

"We are still looking for the answer for that," he said. "It's a culture change, and culture change has to be driven by the leadership."

He said some combination of incentives and sanctions might be needed.

For the study, Urbach and his colleagues surveyed all hospitals that perform surgery in Canada's Ontario Province. They took data on deaths and , comparing the three months before and the three months after checklists were introduced.

During the three months before checklists were used, there were about 109,000 procedures. In the three months after checklists were put in place, there were about 106,000.

The researchers found that before the use of checklists, 0.71 percent of surgical patients died in the hospital or in the month after their operation. After the checklists were introduced, 0.65 percent of patients died.

The rate of complications was 3.86 percent before the use of checklists and 3.82 percent after, they said.

Explore further: Patient participation in surgical safety checklist effective

More information: Visit the U.S. National Library of Medicine for more on patient safety.

Related Stories

Patient participation in surgical safety checklist effective

January 27, 2014
Patients feel safer – and likely are safer – when they receive a surgical safety checklist and request that their health care providers use it, suggests a pilot study being presented at the American Society of Anesthesiologists ...

Checklists in operating rooms improve performance during crises

January 16, 2013
In an airplane crisis—an engine failure, a fire—pilots pull out a checklist to help with their decision-making. But in an operating room crisis—massive bleeding, a patient's heart stops—surgical teams don't. Given ...

Many US hospitals fall short in preventing infections

February 19, 2014
(HealthDay)—Many U.S. hospitals don't follow rules meant to protect patients from preventable and potentially deadly infections, a new study shows.

Surgical checklists save lives

November 15, 2011
(Medical Xpress) -- Using checklists to improve work practices has long been normal in the aviation and oil industry. Checklists are now also implemented worldwide in the operating room.

Checklists can effectively assess work-related risk of musculoskeletal injuries

October 10, 2012
A new paper by Thomas J. Albin, PE, CPE, of High Plains Engineering Services in Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA, confirms that observational assessment tools, often called checklists, used to assess risk factors such as wrist ...

Recommended for you

World's first child hand transplant a 'success'

July 19, 2017
The first child in the world to undergo a double hand transplant is now able to write, feed and dress himself, doctors said Tuesday, declaring the ground-breaking operation a success after 18 months.

Knee surgery—have we been doing it wrong?

July 18, 2017
A team of University at Buffalo medical doctors have published a study that challenges a surgical practice used for decades during arthroscopic knee surgery.

New tools help surgeons find liver tumors, not nick blood vessels

July 17, 2017
The liver is a particularly squishy, slippery organ, prone to shifting both deadly tumors and life-preserving blood vessels by inches between the time they're discovered on a CT scan and when the patient is lying on an operating ...

Researchers discover indicator of lung transplant rejection

July 13, 2017
Research by scientists at Dignity Health St. Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center's Norton Thoracic Institute was published in the July 12, 2017 issue of Science Translational Medicine titled "Zbtb7a induction in alveolar ...

New device could make closing surgical incisions a cinch

July 7, 2017
Like many surgeons, Dr. Jason Spector is often faced with the challenge of securely closing the abdominal wall without injuring the intestines. If the process goes awry, there can be serious consequences for patients, including ...

Success with first 20 patients undergoing minimally invasive pancreatic transplant surgery

June 29, 2017
Surgeons at Johns Hopkins Medicine report that their first series of a minimally invasive procedure to treat chronic pancreas disease, known as severe pancreatitis, resulted in shorter hospital stays, less need for opioids ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.