New study finds inhaler reminders dramatically improve asthma controller adherence

May 21, 2014, American Thoracic Society

Reminders prompting asthma patients to take their control inhalers if they miss a dose significantly improve medication adherence, according to a primary-care based study conducted by a research team in Australia. In this six-month investigation, patients receiving reminders took on average 73% of their prescribed doses compared to only 46% in patients who did not have reminders.

The results of the cluster randomized controlled trial were presented at the ATS 2014 International Conference. Given the fact that poor adherence is an important contributor to poor and that implementing strategies for improving medication-taking is sometimes impractical in primary-care settings, the study aimed to develop and test a set of adherence intervention tools that would be feasible for use by general practitioners (GPs).

"Adherence is often inhibited by patients' concerns about medication effectiveness and short- and long-term treatment safety," said lead author Juliet Foster, PhD, a research psychologist at the Woolcock Institute of Medical Research in Sydney. "Also to blame are the modern, busy lives that we all lead, which can make taking medication a challenge for people with asthma and other chronic conditions."

In total, the 43 GPs who volunteered for the study enrolled 143 patients between the ages of 14 and 65 who had been prescribed a twice-daily control inhaler for at least one month and scored sub-optimally (<19) on the Asthma Control Test, a five-question self-assessment tool used to measure asthma control. Individuals who had had a recent asthma exacerbation or who suffered from other chronic respiratory diseases were excluded from the trial. The researchers tested the effectiveness of two GP-delivered interventions designed to tackle forgetfulness and/or patients concerns about inhaler use. The study participants were split into four groups: one group received twice-daily inhaler reminders for missed does with adherence feedback through a device that allowed for customization of ringtones and ring times; a second group engaged in personalized adherence discussions with their doctors about key barriers to medication-taking; a third group received both interventions; and a control group received active usual care, a routine treatment based on an Australian government-incentivized primary care asthma management program.

All patients used an electronic inhaler monitor called SmartTrack that recorded the date and time of each puff and uploaded that information to a secure website. Reminder patients and their GPs could visit the site at any time to review their medication use, but data were collected covertly for those in the non-reminder groups to enable the researchers to reliably measure differences in adherence between intervention groups.

Patients in the personalized discussion groups completed a short questionnaire about barriers to controller inhaler use before talking to their doctor about their personal treatment concerns, setting asthma-management goals and identifying strategies with which to achieve them. GPs who delivered personalized discussions attended a two-hour in-person workshop on empathic communication and engaged in additional training by phone over the course of the study. GPs in this group also received a set of communication tools to help them support their patients and understand their treatment perspectives.

"Our study demonstrates that provision of reminders and feedback could be extremely effective for changing controller medication-taking behavior in significant and positive ways," said Dr. Foster, who worked on the trial with Professor Helen Reddel and other investigators. "There could also be an important place for personalized adherence discussions in primary care, as GPs were very positive about the tools we provided, but longer studies may be needed to show statistically significant effects over and above active usual care."

The researchers found that while adherence was significantly higher in the reminder groups than non-reminder groups, and both interventions improved asthma control, there was no significant difference in asthma control between the four study groups or between the reminder and non-reminder groups.

"While we were initially surprised by this, when we investigated further, we saw that, in line with prescribing patterns in Australia, patients were prescribed high controller doses at baseline," Dr. Foster explained. "The modest adherence in the non-reminder groups may have been enough to cause change in asthma control from baseline, with higher adherence rates in reminder groups unable to produce further improvement. Improvement in asthma control from baseline in all groups could also potentially have been due to the active usual care interventions, although the effect of inhaler technique education is short-lived if not repeated frequently."

She also noted that several factors likely influenced the results of the reminder and feedback intervention: patients could see in real-time on the SmartTrack screen when they had last taken a dose; the device prompted patients to take missed doses; and patients and GPs could discuss medication-use data together.

"Patients in reminder groups had access to accurate data on their own controller-taking patterns, probably for the first time in their lives," Dr. Foster explained. "This, combined with other factors, likely encouraged and reinforced more effective medication habits and routines." And while the study's findings about reminders and feedback are encouraging, she cautions that additional and potentially longer trials are needed to replicate their data.

"Our findings add to previous research by demonstrating that reminders and feedback for controller inhaler use significantly improve treatment , for at least six months, and are considered acceptable and feasible by and GPs in real-world primary care settings," Dr. Foster concluded. "Primary-care-based studies like this one are so important because they provide essential information on the feasibility and effectiveness of interventions when delivered in the very setting in which they may be implemented. While difficult to fund, these trials are key to translating research findings into routine care."

Explore further: Facilitation improves PCP adherence to asthma guidelines

More information: Abstract 49603
A Cluster Randomised Controlled Trial Of Inhaler Reminders And/Or Personalised Adherence Discussions For Improving Adherence And Asthma Control Demonstrates The Effectiveness And Acceptability Of Reminders In Primary Care Settings
Type: Scientific Abstract
Category: 02.01 - Adherence (BSHSR)
Authors: J.M. Foster1, L. Smith2, T. Usherwood2, W. Xuan3, S.M. Sawyer4, C.S. Rand5, H.K. Reddel1; 1Woolcock Institute of Medical Research - Sydney/AU, 2University of Sydney - Sydney/AU, 3University of New South Wales - Sydney/AU, 4Centre for Adolescent Health, Royal Children's Hospital Melbourne - Melbourne/AU, 5Johns Hopkins School of Medicine - Baltimore, MD/US

Related Stories

Facilitation improves PCP adherence to asthma guidelines

May 14, 2014
(HealthDay)—Adding practice facilitation (PF) to other strategies may improve adherence to asthma guidelines in the primary care setting, according to research published in the May/June issue of the Annals of Family Medicine.

Can text messaging improve medication adherence?

May 24, 2011
Text messaging and adolescents don’t always mix well, but researchers at National Jewish Health hope text messages can spur teenagers to take their asthma medications more reliably. The study is testing whether health ...

Info, motivation, behavioral skill affect med adherence

March 12, 2014
(HealthDay)—Patients' adherence-related information, motivation, and behavioral skills (IMB) are important targets for interventions promoting adherence to diabetes medications, according to a study published online March ...

Texting heart medication reminders improved patient adherence

November 18, 2013
Getting reminder texts helped patients take their heart medicines (anti-platelet and cholesterol-lowering drugs) more regularly, according to research presented at the American Heart Association's Scientific Sessions 2013.

Medication adherence after hospitalization for acute coronary syndrome

November 18, 2013
Patients better adhered to their medication regimens in the year following hospitalization for acute coronary syndrome (ACS) when they were part of a program that included personalized attention from a pharmacist compared ...

Alternative medicine doesn't affect asthma care in children

April 10, 2012
(HealthDay) -- Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) is not associated with adherence to pediatric asthma treatment, according to a study published online April 9 in Pediatrics.

Recommended for you

Chronic inflammation causes loss of muscle mass during aging

January 12, 2018
People start losing muscle mass at the age of 40—about some 10 percent of the total muscle mass for each 10-year period, which may lead to fall-related injuries, slowing metabolism and reduced quality of life. Today, very ...

Breathing exercises help asthma patients with quality of life

December 13, 2017
A study led by the University of Southampton has found that people who continue to get problems from their asthma, despite receiving standard treatment, experience an improved quality of life when they are taught breathing ...

Study highlights the need for research into prevention of inflammatory bowel disease

December 7, 2017
Countries in Africa, Asia, the Middle East and South America have seen a rise in incidence of inflammatory bowel disease as they have become increasingly industrialised and westernised, a new study has found.

Air pollution can increase asthma risk in adults, even at low levels

November 24, 2017
Living close to a busy road can be bad for your respiratory health if you are middle aged, new Australian research has found.

Evidence found of oral bacteria contributing to bowel disorders

October 20, 2017
(Medical Xpress)—An international team of researchers has found evidence that suggests certain types of oral bacteria may cause or exacerbate bowel disorders. In their paper published in the journal Science, the group describes ...

New compound discovered in fight against inflammatory disease

September 22, 2017
A 10-year study by University of Manchester scientists for a new chemical compound that is able to block a key component in inflammatory illness has ended in success.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.