Babies feel pain 'like adults'

April 21, 2015
Credit: Anna Langova/public domain

The brains of babies 'light up' in a very similar way to adults when exposed to the same painful stimulus, a pioneering Oxford University brain scanning study has discovered. It suggests that babies experience pain much like adults.

The study looked at 10 healthy infants aged between one and six days old and 10 healthy aged 23-36 years. Infants were recruited from the John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford (UK) and adult volunteers were Oxford University staff or students.

During the research , accompanied by parents and clinical staff, were placed in a Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) scanner where they usually fell asleep. MRI scans were then taken of the babies' brains as they were 'poked' on the bottom of their feet with a special retracting rod creating a sensation 'like being poked with a pencil' - mild enough that it did not wake them up. These scans were then compared with brain scans of adults exposed to the same pain stimulus.

The researchers found that 18 of the 20 brain regions active in adults experiencing pain were active in babies. Scans also showed that babies' brains had the same response to a weak 'poke' (of force 128mN) as adults did to a stimulus four times as strong (512mN). The findings suggest that not only do babies experience pain much like adults but that they also have a much lower pain threshold.

The research was funded by the Wellcome Trust and is reported in the journal eLife.

'Up until recently people didn't think it was possible to study pain in babies using MRI because, unlike adults, they don't keep still in the scanner!' said Dr Rebeccah Slater of Oxford University's Department of Paediatrics, lead author of the report. 'However, as babies that are less than a week old are more docile than older babies, we found that their parents were able to get them to fall asleep inside a scanner so that, for the first time, we could study pain in the infant brain using MRI.

'This is particularly important when it comes to pain: obviously babies can't tell us about their experience of pain and it is difficult to infer pain from visual observations. In fact some people have argued that babies' brains are not developed enough for them to really 'feel' pain, any reaction being just a reflex - our study provides the first really strong evidence that this is not the case.'

The researchers say that it is now possible to see pain 'happening' inside the infant brain and it looks a lot like pain in adults.

As recently as the 1980s it was common practice for babies to be given neuromuscular blocks but no medication during surgery [1]. In 2014 a review of neonatal practice in intensive care highlighted that although such infants experience an average of 11 painful procedures per day 60% of babies do not receive any kind of pain medication [2].

'Thousands of babies across the UK undergo painful procedures every day but there are often no local pain management guidelines to help clinicians. Our study suggests that not only do babies experience pain but they may be more sensitive to it than adults,' said Dr Slater. 'We have to think that if we would provide pain relief for an older child undergoing a procedure then we should look at giving pain relief to an infant undergoing a similar procedure.'

Dr Slater added: 'Recent studies in adults have shown that it is possible to detect a neurological signature of pain using MRI. In the future we hope to develop similar systems to detect the 'pain signature' in babies' brains: this could enable us to test different pain relief treatments and see what would be most effective for this vulnerable population who can't speak for themselves.'

Rachel Edwards, who is 33 and from Oxford, gave permission for her son Alex to take part in the study. Alex was the first baby to be placed in the MRI scanner:

Rachel Edwards said: 'People know so little about how babies feel , you can tell they are in distress from their reaction and I was curious about why they react in the way they do.

'Before Alex went in I got to feel all the things he would feel as part of the study including the pencil-like retracting rod: it wasn't particularly painful, it was more of a precise feeling of touch.

'It was really reassuring how highly skilled the staff were and how good they were at calming and handling him.

'I fed him and put him down on this special bean bag that they suck all the air out of to help keep the babies' heads still. Then they put on earphones that cut out some of the sound but I think the noise actually soothed him. He was out for the count, he didn't wake up during the scanning and seemed really content afterwards.'

Explore further: New method of infant pain assessment

More information: A report of the research is published in the journal eLife: dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.06356

Notes:

[1] Anand KJ, and Hickey PR. Pain and its effects in the human neonate and fetus. The New England journal of medicine. 1987;317(21):1321-9.

[2] Roofthooft DW, Simons SH, Anand KJ, Tibboel D, and van Dijk M. Eight years later, are we still hurting newborn infants? Neonatology. 2014;105(3):218-26.

Related Stories

New method of infant pain assessment

December 21, 2011

Recently, the accuracy of current methods of pain assessment in babies have been called into question. New research from London-area hospitals and the University of Oxford measures brain activity in infants to better understand ...

Babies distinguish pain from touch at 35-37 weeks

September 8, 2011

Babies can distinguish painful stimuli as different from general touch from around 35-37 weeks gestation – just before an infant would normally be born – according to new research.

Pain management for infant injections

December 6, 2013

According to pain management specialist Professor Denise Harrison, an Honorary Senior Fellow at the University of Melbourne, breastfeeding and the use of sweet water can help to calm babies during immunisation.

Recommended for you

Study shows there's a positive side to worrying

April 27, 2017

Worry - it does a body good. And, the mind as well. A new paper by Kate Sweeny, psychology professor at the University of California, Riverside, argues there's an upside to worrying.

Study links cannabis use in adolescence to schizophrenia

April 26, 2017

Scientists believe that schizophrenia, a disorder caused by an imbalance in the brain's chemical reactions, is triggered by a genetic interaction with environmental factors. A new Tel Aviv University study published in Human ...

3 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

24volts
not rated yet Apr 21, 2015
Why would doctors even think that babies don't feel pain the same way an adult does? This had got to be one of the stupidest ideas doctors have had I have ever heard in my entire life.
RobertKarlStonjek
not rated yet Apr 22, 2015
In adults there is an overriding pain sensation caused by expectation, imagination, anticipation and distraction.

Adults may experience pain in anticipation of a pain stimulus. This has been measured in burn patients who undergo a painful stimulus each day as part of their treatment.
Distraction may remove pain sensation altogether regardless of how strong the stimulus is if the distraction is strong enough.

Adults may experience regular pain sensations even when the regular stimulus is removed.

Babies are unlikely to experience all of these levels that result from higher conscious information processing and feel only the stimulus *in the moment* and no more or less. Adults, for instance, don't burst out crying upon feeling a pain sensation.

Thus the experience sudden pain stimulus will be similar, but aches and other types of pain will *subjectively* be quite different, especially when it comes to the emotional and subjectively conscious components.
RobertKarlStonjek
not rated yet Apr 22, 2015
The annoying thing about studies like this one is the unwarranted conclusions drawn. Doing an objective test on brain activity does not indicate subjective experience. The researchers apparently made no attempt to explore the probe the psychology and cognitive science literature on the subjective experience of pain and simply made the leap with no supporting evidence whatsoever, a huge insult to all of those who actually study pain and try to treat those who have problems relating to pain.

Clearly these neuroscientists felt such a degree of superiority that even mentioning the fact of a science outside their own studying this area was unnecessary.

If scientists have such utter contempt for other branches of science then how do they expect the public to have respect for and sanction funding for science?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.