Discount food and restaurants stand out as major factors in the obesity epidemic

April 24, 2015 by Charles Courtemanche, The Conversation
Discount food and restaurants stand out as major factors in the obesity epidemic
Do warehouse stories contribute to the obesity epidemic? Ryan Ozawa/Flickr, CC BY-NC-SA

Obesity has reached epidemic proportions in the United States. The proportion of US adults who are obese – defined as a body mass index (BMI), a measure of body fat based on height and weight – of at least 30, has risen from 13% in 1960 to 35% in 2011-2012. Estimates of the annual costs of obesity include 112,000 lives lost and US$190 billion in medical expenses.

Economists have been trying to pinpoint some of the that could have contributed to this rise in adult for years.

Some have examined the role of cheaper and more readily available food, as measured by grocery food prices, restaurant prices, access to restaurants, access to supercenters, or receipt of food stamps. Others have focused on incentives related to physical activity. For instance, cheaper gasoline may lead to more driving and less walking, while urban sprawl reduces community walkability.

Still other studies ask whether tobacco control measures such as cigarette taxes and smoking bans may have had the unintended consequence of contributing to the rise in obesity, since nicotine can be a metabolic stimulant and appetite suppressant. Finally, another category of studies estimates the role of changing characteristics of the labor force, such as the rise in female labor participation (which might lead to an increased reliance on convenience food) and the increasingly sedentary nature of jobs.

These are some of the numerous different factors that could have played a role in the skyrocketing obesity rate. But which ones have the greatest influence? To figure that out my colleagues and I compared 24 factors attributed to the rise in to understand which ones had the biggest effect.

So what factors have the most influence on obesity?

In a working paper recently released by the National Bureau of Economic Research, Joshua Pinkston, Christopher Ruhm, George Wehby and I combine these factors and others into a single model to figure out which ones have contributed to obesity the most.

To do this we matched state-level data on 24 different economic factors to data on 2.9 million people from the CDC's Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System from 1990 through 2010. After controlling for demographics, state and year, we were able estimate the effects of these economic factors on weight outcomes.

All of these factors contribute to obesity epidemic, but some have more of an effect than others. Credit: Charles Courtemanche/NBER, Author provided

The analysis is essentially a "statistical horse race" to see which, if any, of the these factors that are alleged to have contributed to the obesity epidemic stand out once all the possible contributors are mixed together and analyzed statistically.

All factors play a role in obesity

Taken together, we estimate that these 24 economic variables together explain 37% of the rise in BMI across the country, 43% of the rise in obesity, and 59% of the rise of what is called moderate and , defined as a BMI of 35 of higher (called class II/III obesity).

We calculated these percentages by estimating the effects of the economic factors on each weight outcome (eg BMI), and then we multiplied these effects by the observed changes in the economic variables during the sample period. Then we divided the result by the overall change in the weight outcome during the sample period.

This means that how people respond to changing economic incentives appears to explain a lot of the upward trend in weight. And this especially large influence on the rise in severe obesity is particularly important, as the severe obesity threshold is where the increased mortality risk from obesity begins to appear. In other words, economic incentives do not affect BMI uniformly throughout the population. The impact is concentrated among those who already obese.

More restaurants and gigantic grocery stores

When we look at these factors on their own, two stand out as the "winners" of the horse race.

First is the increase in restaurants per capita, which by itself explains 12% in BMI, 14% of the rise in moderate obesity, and 23% of the increases severe obesity. Greater availability of restaurant food likely increases obesity because more people are substituting relatively unhealthy restaurant meals for home-cooked meals. And fast food is not the lone culprit. If we split the restaurant variable into fast-food and full-service restaurants, their estimated effects are similar.

The second major contributor is the increase in superstores, like Walmart SuperCenters and warehouse club chains like Costco, Sam's Club and BJ's Wholesale Club, per capita. This factor accounts for 17% of the rise in BMI, 16% of the rise in moderate obesity, and 24% of the growth in severe obesity.

Perhaps the most likely explanation for the impact of these stores on obesity is that they sell food at a discount of around 20% relative to a traditional grocery store. It's also possible that buying food in bulk contributes to overeating.

But if we split the superstore variable and look at certain stores on their own, we find that Walmart Supercenters have roughly the same effect as warehouse clubs, which often sell food in bulk. And since Walmart Supercenters sell food in traditional package sizes, this seems to rule out bulk-buying as being the leading explanation.

Cheap food isn't a bad thing

While restaurants, supercenters and warehouse clubs appear to have contributed substantially to the rise in obesity, this doesn't necessarily mean that they are bad for society. The availability and affordability of brought about by these businesses are undoubtedly of substantial benefit to consumers. Our results simply suggest that progress comes at a cost. Future research should investigate the reasons why restaurants and superstores contribute to obesity with the aim of helping policymakers develop targeted solutions.

Explore further: New study questions role of breast milk in obesity prevention

Related Stories

New study questions role of breast milk in obesity prevention

April 7, 2015
A new study supports human milk as the optimal first food for babies, but the study raises questions about whether breast milk protects children from becoming obese.

Who's to blame for obesity? Policymakers, the food industry, or individuals?

January 22, 2014
Fast food restaurants take a lot of heat for the rise in obesity in the United States, but is it really their fault? A research survey conducted by two food economists revealed that most people believe individuals are to ...

Obesity costs more than $8 bn in lost US productivity

November 15, 2014
Obesity among workers in the United States is costing the nation $8.65 billion a year in lost productivity, according to a study released Friday.

Nearly 30% of world population is overweight: study

November 20, 2014
More than 2.1 billion people globally—or nearly 30 percent of the world's population—are now overweight or obese, with the figure set to rise further by 2030, according to a study published Thursday.

Retail investment: A barometer for teen obesity?

September 23, 2013
When it comes to addressing the obesity epidemic, fast food restaurants are a favorite target, with some communities, such as the city of Los Angeles, going so far as to ban the construction of new, standalone fast food restaurants ...

Recommended for you

Fat cells seem to remember unhealthy diet

April 23, 2018
It only takes 24 hours for a so-called precursor fat cell to reprogram its epigenetic recipe for developing into a fat cell. This change occurs when the cell is put into contact with the fatty acid palmitate or the hormone ...

Bias keeps women with higher body weights away from the doctor: study

April 23, 2018
A study out of Drexel University's Dornsife School of Public Health linked past experiences with bias and discrimination and avoidance of doctors in women with higher body weights.

Wide waist with 'normal weight' bigger risk than obesity: study

April 20, 2018
People of "normal" weight who sport a wide waist are more at risk of heart problems than obese people, said researchers Friday, urging a rethink of healthy weight guidelines.

Lack of sleep leads to obesity in children and adolescents

April 16, 2018
Children who get less than the recommended amount of sleep for their age are at a higher risk of developing obesity.

Getting kids to a good weight by 13 may help avoid diabetes

April 4, 2018
There may be a critical window for overweight kids to get to a healthy level. Those who shed their extra pounds by age 13 had the same risk of developing diabetes in adulthood as others who had never weighed too much, a large ...

Obesity is shifting cancer to young adults

March 26, 2018
A Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine researcher has compiled evidence from more than 100 publications to show how obesity increases risk of 13 different cancers in young adults. The meta-analysis describes ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.