Needle exchanges can prevent more HIV outbreaks like one in Indiana

June 24, 2015, Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg School of Public Health
HIV, the AIDS virus (yellow), infecting a human immune cell. Credit: Seth Pincus, Elizabeth Fischer and Austin Athman, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health.

Congress needs to immediately lift the ban on federal funding for needle exchange programs to counter the threat of HIV outbreaks among injection drug users like the one that has seen an alarming number of new cases erupt in a single rural Indiana county.

So say Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health Professor Chris Beyrer, MD, MPH, and Steffanie A. Strathdee, PhD, director of the Institute of Global Health at the University of California-San Diego, in a commentary published online June 24 in The New England Journal of Medicine.

"There are going to be more of these outbreaks and what's urgently needed is a public health response before things get even worse," says Beyrer, who is also president of the International AIDS Society. "Now is the time to implement needle and syringe exchange programs, wherever they are needed. We can't put politics above public health. We have a cheap tool to prevent this."

The story of Scott County, Ind., a rural region of the state near the Kentucky border, is one that had feared. In the past decade, the face of drug abuse has changed. No longer is it an exclusively urban, male, African-American problem. It is now mainly concentrated mainly in rural white communities and roughly equally among men and women.

Often, they start out abusing prescription drugs, sometimes by mouth but often by injection, which then can be a gateway to heroin. In 25 states, over-the-counter syringe purchase is illegal without a prescription. Across the country, in states where needle exchanges are legal, programs are prohibited from using federal funds due to a ban that was lifted, in 2009, and then reinstated by Congress in 2011. It's a recipe ripe for HIV and hepatitis C infections to be transmitted quickly through a community, the researchers say.

Southeast Indiana had previously recorded only about five new cases of HIV a year. By June 10 of this year, 169 people had been newly diagnosed and more than 80 percent were also infected with the hepatitis C virus.

Needle exchanges are illegal in Indiana.

The state's governor has made an exception to allow for needle exchanges in the affected county, but says he will only allow other counties to start programs once they show a need.

"Regrettably in the case of NEPs [needle exchange programs], other Indiana counties contemplating authorizing them must first demonstrate the existence of a emergency - a requirement that ensures that they can only respond to, rather than prevent, new outbreaks," they write.

Another troubling aspect, the authors note, is that to get clean needles, people must give their initials and date of birth, a registration process that could deter use. And the programs are only open until 6 p.m. most evenings.

Other ways to counter the epidemic, Beyrer says, are to screen more people for HIV and ask them about their drug use, including white women, a demographic that may have been overlooked in prior screening. Beyrer says poor screening efforts mean fewer people in treatment for HIV. Identifying those with HIV earlier can lead to earlier treatment and suppression of viral load, making those with HIV less infectious to others.

Greater use of opioid replacement therapies - that is, replacing those drugs with methadone and buprenorphine, which are less dangerous - could also aid the battle.

These types of actions have worked in the past, Beyrer says. An explosive HIV outbreak among that hit Vancouver, British Columbia, was controlled by the expansion of needle exchange programs, providing opioid replacement therapy and providing highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) free of charge through Canada's universal health care system.

"Drug use is changing and before this gets any worse, we need to change our approach to fighting it," Beyrer says.

Explore further: Indiana governor extends needle-exchange program to curb HIV

More information: "Threading the Needle - How to Stop the HIV Outbreak in Rural Indiana" The New England Journal of Medicine, 2015.

Related Stories

Indiana governor extends needle-exchange program to curb HIV

April 20, 2015
Indiana Gov. Mike Pence has extended a needle-exchange program in a southern Indiana county to help combat an HIV outbreak.

Indiana officials hopeful HIV outbreak may be nearly over

May 7, 2015
A top Indiana health official says the dwindling number of new HIV cases in a rural southern county could mean the state's largest-ever HIV outbreak is ending.

Indiana lawmakers OK needle exchange programs

April 30, 2015
Lawmakers looking to prevent a repeat of an HIV outbreak that has rocked a southern Indiana county sent Republican Gov. Mike Pence a measure Wednesday that would allow communities to implement needle-exchange programs if ...

Rural Indiana county's HIV outbreak tops 100 cases

April 10, 2015
State health officials say more than 100 people have tested positive for HIV in an outbreak of the virus among intravenous drug users in southeastern Indiana.

Indiana allows needle exchange program to stem HIV outbreak

March 26, 2015
Indiana's governor authorized a short-term needle-exchange program and other steps Thursday to help contain the spread of HIV in a county tied to 79 new infections since January, all of them linked to intravenous drug use.

24 new HIV cases reported in Indiana outbreak, 130 total

April 17, 2015
Indiana health officials say there are two dozen new HIV cases in southeastern Indiana, bringing the outbreak's total cases to 130.

Recommended for you

HIV vaccine protects non-human primates from infection

December 14, 2018
For more than 20 years, scientists at Scripps Research have chipped away at the challenges of designing an HIV vaccine. Now new research, published in Immunity, shows that their experimental vaccine strategy works in non-human ...

Roadmap reveals shortcut to recreate key HIV antibody for vaccines

December 11, 2018
HIV evades the body's immune defenses through a multitude of mutations, and antibodies produced by the host's immune system to fight HIV also follow convoluted evolutionary pathways that have been challenging to track.

Eliminating the latent reservoir of HIV

December 7, 2018
A new study suggests that a genetic switch that causes latent HIV inside cells to begin to replicate can be manipulated to completely eradicate the virus from the human body. Cells harboring latent HIV are "invisible" to ...

New research highlights why HIV-infected patients suffer higher rates of cancer

December 5, 2018
AIDS patients suffer higher rates of cancer because they have fewer T-cells in their bodies to fight disease. But new research examines why HIV-infected patients have higher rates of cancer—among the leading causes of death ...

Focus on resistance to HIV offers insight into how to fight the virus

November 30, 2018
Of the 40 million people around the world infected with HIV, less than one per cent have immune systems strong enough to suppress the virus for extended periods of time. These special immune systems are known as "elite controllers." ...

Patients with rare natural ability to suppress HIV shed light on potential functional cure

November 27, 2018
Researchers at Johns Hopkins have identified two patients with HIV whose immune cells behave differently than others with the virus and actually appear to help control viral load even years after infection. Moreover, both ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.