Is tailgating toxic?

Is tailgating toxic?
Charcoal grills are associated with higher emissions than gas grills. Credit: North Carolina State University

While tailgating this football season you may want to take a step back from the grill and generator—for your health.

NC State researchers found that pollution rises in tailgating lots before and after major football games most often due to large charcoal grills, old generators and idling vehicles.

During the 2015 football season, College of Natural Resources assistant professor Kyle Bunds and associate professor Jonathan Casper teamed up with College of Engineering professor Chris Frey to monitor in and around NC State's Carter-Finley Stadium before, during and after all six home football games.

"No one has looked at this issue of what kind of exposures you have in a tailgating situation, and it's one where there could be high exposures," said Frey, who has conducted years of air pollution research.

With mobile and stationary air monitors, researchers gathered roughly 21,000 data points per game on temperature, relative humidity, ozone, carbon monoxide (CO), carbon dioxide (CO2) and PM2.5, which is fine particulate matter suspected of posing the greatest risk to human health.

While the results indicated good air quality inside the stadium and during the game, overall air quality around the stadium worsened immediately after the game as thousands load into vehicles, which often idle in traffic leaving stadium parking lots. Even after traffic subsides, air monitors indicated that elevated levels of PM2.5 linger, sometimes not returning to normal pre-game levels until the following morning.

Is tailgating toxic?
Researchers strategically placed stationary air quality monitors in each of the major tailgating lots. Credit: North Carolina State University

"People trickle in before the game. After the game, everybody leaves at the same time," Casper said. "This is often the case at collegiate football games as well as most other major sporting events."

Populations who are sensitive to would reduce their exposure by leaving before the game ends or staying in the stadium until the bulk of traffic subsides, Casper said.

The study also identified isolated spikes in air pollution, in particular next to large charcoal grills.

"You don't want to be standing next to those for long periods of time," Casper said. "There's more and more evidence that short-term exposure in high dosages can be detrimental."

Fans can reduce exposure by avoiding close or downwind proximity to grills, especially charcoal grills that are associated with higher emissions than gas grills.

"The closer you are to the source, the higher the exposure," Frey said.

Is tailgating toxic?
Before, during and after football games, a small team of researchers carried the mobile air monitor in a backpack equipped with GPS location devices. Video cameras collected visual data that allowed researchers to identify sources of any recorded increases in emissions. Credit: North Carolina State University

The mobile monitor also recorded spikes in air pollutants when next to old generators and large, idling vehicles. Air quality can be improved by upgrading to a newer model generator and turning off vehicle engines instead of idling, Bunds said.

Funded by a grant from NC State's Faculty Research and Professional Development program, the study is a pioneering look into pollutant exposure experienced by fans.

"These findings aren't surprising but what's unique is that we could quantify it," Frey said. "This quantification is important. It provides information that enables people to make informed decisions about exposures."

This fall, stationary air monitors will be placed at a few tailgating sites to determine if and how long the spikes in air pollutants are sustained. Bunds and Casper, who study the impacts of large sporting and entertainment events, hope to replicate the study at additional stadiums.

"Our main goal was to understand what level of certain that event spectators were exposed to," Bunds said. "This can help us understand what policy implementations can be made to help positively curb the impact of unhealthy air in and around stadiums."

Explore further

Sitting in traffic jams is officially bad for you

Citation: Is tailgating toxic? (2016, August 26) retrieved 23 January 2020 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments