Opinion: Why young women need to be given a louder voice in the obesity debate

November 23, 2016 by Jessica Francombe-Webb, The Conversation
This is an image of a weight scale. Credit: CDC/Debora Cartagena

Young women are at the centre of myriad public health concerns about their bodies. Fears about obesity, inactivity, unhappiness and social media have driven policy responses that target young women and their "problem" behaviours. But far too often these issues are seen as having competing agendas. In this complex environment, isn't it time for more joined-up thinking and for the voices of young women to be more clearly heard?

In August 2016, the publication of the British government's long awaited plan to tackle childhood obesity coincided with the launch of The Children Society's Good Childhood Report 2016. While one of these reports focused, among other things, on the need for increased monitoring and measurement of children's weight, the other highlighted the increase in 's unhappiness as a result of significant appearance concerns. These reports should be seen as highlighting complex interwoven health issues.

However, it seems that disproportionate attention continues to be given to an apparent obesity "crisis". The British government's plan for dealing with was received with mixed reviews. The strategy was described in some quarters as a missed opportunity to "tackle the culture of unhealthy eating that is crippling the NHS". Others criticised policy makers for failing to take significant action to tackle the problem.

Criticism levelled at the report for not advocating strong enough action demonstrates the framing of obesity as a "moral crisis" and as the priority public health agenda upon which policy makers need to be seen to be acting.

Our research suggests that this urgency can come with serious risks. What is the evidence base upon which to act? The science of obesity remains uncertain, contradictory and lacks consensus over crucial issues such as the causes and most effective actions to counter it. The one thing we can say for definite on the subject is that it is complex.

So, in rethinking strategy, policymakers need to consider not just if interventions are effective, but also the potential harms and unintended consequences. Over the past decade, the framing of obesity through hyperbolic language of a "crisis" has not only strengthened the imperative to act quickly on the basis of whatever evidence is available, but has fuelled a moral panic which has led to increased surveillance of young people's weight, bodies and lifestyles, contributing not only to increased weight stigma but disordered eating and exercise practices.

We need to reject the separation of the mind and the body to properly reflect on the rising rates of ill health among young women who struggle with disordered eating and exercise – an often silenced part of the obesity debate.

Weight limits

Despite significant gaps in knowledge, there have been a series of policy responses and interventions which often share a weight-centric approach. Healthy bodies are generally seen as "slender bodies", with minimal visible "excess" flesh. The National Child Measurement Programme and the Childhood Obesity strategy's requirement to make it a "default" for to "weigh everyone", will only strengthen this view.

This epitomises a broader trend towards reducing complex health issues to simple data categories and a focus on measuring weight and body size. Research demonstrates that not only are these methods of intervention problematic in terms of their reliance on blunt measurements, but they can also have harmful effects on young people in terms of their mental health, well-being and body confidence.

This is especially the case for young women.

The Good Childhood Report revealed that 34% of girls in the UK are unhappy with their appearance. A separate report from Girl Guiding UK (2016) found that young women's "fear of their bodies being criticised holds them back from doing everyday things they'd like to do". This included sports and physical activities that, ironically, are often suggested as key methods of tackling obesity.

Concerns over their own appearance, body shape and size are exacerbated by the bodies young women see on television, magazines, , computer games and health and fitness apps.

Add to that the continuous reminders of the need to measure their weight, to work on their bodies and to inspect what they eat, and we have a toxic culture of body surveillance that young women are expected to navigate daily. Is it any wonder that levels of unhappiness, anxiety and depression are increasing?

Their bodies, their voices

The British government's strategy raises further questions about who has the authority to speak for children. Whose knowledge counts when tackling the issue of childhood obesity? The Good Childhood Report and the Girl Guiding Survey are refreshing in their use of young people's subjective experiences. These voices are sadly absent from the official report.

Far more attention needs to be paid to the views and experiences of the children and young people whose lives these strategies and policies will affect. Social action projects can be a more effective way for local authorities to involve young people in making community decisions that affect them, listening to their views and taking appropriate action. Research with and for young people to imagine policy responses within the context of their everyday lives, could be the first step in developing more sustainable, youth-centred interventions. This is an approach to policy making that cannot happen in isolation.

Democratic policy processes need to provide safe spaces where can voice their health concerns and through which we can better understand how health is not simply the result of individual choice, but shaped by social context and inequalities associated with culture, social class, sexuality, geography, gender and ethnicity. We need to see these approaches increasingly adopted in the public domain.

Explore further: Opinion: Government's Childhood Obesity Strategy 'disappointing'

Related Stories

Opinion: Government's Childhood Obesity Strategy 'disappointing'

August 18, 2016
Dr Emma Boyland is a Lecturer in appetite and obesity at the University of Liverpool's Institute of Psychology, Health and Society and Trustee of the UK Association for the Study of Obesity.

Three in four don't know obesity causes cancer

September 9, 2016
Three out of four (75 per cent) people in the UK are unaware of the link between obesity and cancer, according to a new Cancer Research UK report published today (Friday).

New study explores weight stigmatization on Twitter

April 19, 2016
A new study by researchers at Virginia Commonwealth University, Yale School of Medicine and American University has found that weight stigma—or negative attitudes about people simply because they are overweight—is ...

New research shows how to tackle obesity

April 18, 2015
One size does not fit all when it comes to tackling obesity, according to a new study by the University of Sheffield.

Obese preschoolers have 60 percent higher healthcare costs than healthy weight children

July 6, 2016
Obese children aged two to five years old are 2-3 times more likely to be admitted to hospital and have 60 per cent higher healthcare costs than healthy weight children, a study by the University of Sydney's School of Public ...

Childhood obesity, malnutrition connected to mom's perception of child's weight

April 20, 2016
A new study from the University of Houston Department of Health and Human Performance finds a child's risk for obesity or malnutrition may be tied to the mother's misperception of her child's weight status. A key to understanding ...

Recommended for you

Evening hours may pose higher risk for overeating, especially when under stress, study finds

January 16, 2018
Experiments with a small group of overweight men and women have added to evidence that "hunger hormone" levels rise and "satiety (or fullness) hormone" levels decrease in the evening. The findings also suggest that stress ...

Bariatric surgery prolongs lifespan in obese

January 16, 2018
Obese, middle-age men and women who had bariatric surgery have half the death rate of those who had traditional medical treatment over a 10-year period, reports a study that answers questions about the long-term risk of the ...

Sugar-sweetened drinks linked to overweight and obesity in children, adults: Analysis of new studies

December 23, 2017
A new review of the latest evidence on sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs)- which includes 30 new studies published between 2013 and 2015 (and none of them industry sponsored) - concludes that SSB consumption is associated with ...

As income rises, women get slimmer—but not men

December 21, 2017
(HealthDay)—A comprehensive survey on the widening American waistline finds that as paychecks get bigger, women's average weight tends to drop.

Policy and early intervention can curb obesity rates

December 18, 2017
More information and emphasis on dietary lifestyle changes that prevent obesity, and its comorbidities, have not reduced the rise in obesity in U.S. adults and adolescents, according to a recent study in the New England Journal ...

Warning labels can help reduce soda consumption and obesity, new study suggests

December 15, 2017
Labels that warn people about the risks of drinking soda and other sugar-sweetened beverages can lower obesity and overweight prevalence, suggests a new Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health study.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.