Singapore court denies full compensation to woman in IVF mix-up

March 22, 2017
In a long-running lawsuit in Singapore that began in 2012, a woman sued a private hospital, its fertility clinic and two fertility doctors after she was inseminated with the wrong sperm

A Singaporean woman inseminated with a stranger's sperm in a startling in-vitro fertilisation (IVF) mistake cannot be compensated in full for raising the child, the city-state's top court ruled Wednesday.

Allowing the woman compensation would go against on one's obligations as a parent, the Court of Appeal said, adding that the expenses incurred in raising the should not be considered as a loss.

"The duty to maintain one's child is a duty which lies at the very heart of parenthood, and thus the expenses which are incurred... are not capable of characterisation as a loss," the five-judge appeals court wrote in a 141-page ruling.

In a long-running lawsuit that started in 2012, the woman sued a private hospital, its fertility clinic and two fertility doctors after she was inseminated with the wrong sperm.

According to , it was the second time that the ethnic Chinese Singaporean woman had IVF treatment at the privately-owned clinic. Her German husband is of Caucasian descent.

But she was mistakenly inseminated with the sperm of a complete stranger, an Indian man.

The surfaced only after the child was born and her parents realised she had a different skin tone from her brother.

Worried she might have a genetic problem, the child—known as Baby P in court proceedings—was sent for tests which revealed the mix-up.

The hospital admitted to its mistake—there had been two sets of sperm in the processing area—and was fined Sg$20,000 ($14,300) in 2011.

The mother sued for damages in 2012 for mental distress as well as pain and suffering relating to the pregnancy, and for upkeep of the child.

This was dismissed by a lower court and upheld by the appeals court on Wednesday.

The judges noted that Baby P was a healthy child who was planned for and that allowing a claim would mean recognising the birth as a mistake.

However, the also ruled that the had suffered a loss of "genetic affinity" with the child and should be awarded damages which come up to 30 percent of the cost of raising Baby P.

"This loss of 'affinity' can also result in social stigma and embarrassment arising out of the misperceptions of others, as was the case here."

The girl, who will be seven this year, is attending an international school in Beijing where the family is now based.

Explore further: Dutch medical centre probes suspected IVF sperm mix-up

Related Stories

Dutch medical centre probes suspected IVF sperm mix-up

December 27, 2016
A Dutch medical institution announced an investigation Tuesday after discovering that up to 26 women may have been fertilised by the wrong sperm cells at its IVF treatment laboratory.

No maternity leave for women using surrogates: EU top court

March 18, 2014
Women who use surrogate mothers to have a child do not have a legal right to maternity leave when the baby is born, the European Court of Justice ruled on Tuesday.

Woman can use dead husband's sperm: French court

May 31, 2016
A Spanish woman whose husband died in France last year won the right Tuesday to use his frozen sperm and continue the in vitro treatment the couple had started before he died.

French court orders hospital to continue baby's treatment

March 8, 2017
A French court has ordered a hospital to continue life-prolonging treatment for a baby girl who has been in a medically induced coma for months after suffering what doctors say is "irreversible" neurological damage.

Doctors raise concerns after elderly Indian woman gives birth

May 11, 2016
Doctors in India on Wednesday raised ethical and health concerns after a woman gave birth to her first child in her 70s, following two years of IVF treatment.

Recommended for you

Scientists discover critical molecular biomarkers of preeclampsia

February 21, 2018
Preeclampsia, a sudden pregnancy complication that can interfere with the blood flow to the placenta and possibly to the fetus, can lead to low birth weight, prematurity and even death. It is also a leading cause of maternal ...

Transgender women can breastfeed, first case study shows

February 16, 2018
The first scientific case study has been published describing how a US transgender woman was able to breastfeed her adopted infant by taking hormones that induce lactation.

Controversial pregnancy test drug shows deformities in zebrafish embryos within hours of exposure

February 13, 2018
The components of a controversial drug, allegedly linked to birth defects in the 1960s and '70s, caused deformations to fish embryos just hours after they received a dose in new studies by researchers at the University of ...

Direct link between glands and implanting embryos critical to pregnancy

February 9, 2018
Researchers used 3D imaging with molecular testing to uncover new insight into the earliest stages of mammalian pregnancy—offering clues to unsolved questions in pregnancy.

Lab-grown eggs could pave way towards new fertility treatments

February 8, 2018
Human eggs have been fully grown in a laboratory, in a move that could lead to improved fertility treatments.

Ibuprofen in the first three months of pregnancy may harm future fertility of baby girls

February 2, 2018
Pregnant women who take the pain killer ibuprofen in the first 24 weeks of their pregnancy may be reducing the store of eggs in the ovaries of their daughters.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.