How useful is the glycemic index?

January 8, 2018 by Taylor Mcneil, Tufts University
Credit: Tufts University

If you could rank foods from best to worst and base your eating decisions on that, it would certainly make healthy eating easier. For some people, the glycemic index seems to offer just that possibility, assigning scores to foods with carbohydrates based on the effects on a person's blood sugar level.

If you are, say, diabetic, it helps to know that a standard portion of wheat berry salad is much lower on the 100-point scale—and thus has less of an effect on blood —than brown rice. And for losing weight, said Susan Roberts, a professor at the Friedman School, low-glycemic- diets tend to work better than high glycemic index diets, especially for people who tend to secrete a lot of insulin.

So far, so good. But dig a little deeper into the glycemic index, and you'll find complexity—and controversy. For starters, individual foods can vary in the glycemic response they elicit. A ripe banana is different than an unripe one, and a mashed banana is different still; pasta that's al dente creates a lower glycemic response than more fully cooked pasta.

The more processed foods are, too, the more likely they are higher on the scale, and studies have shown that glycemic response varies by the individual and by individual . And then there's the fact that a Snickers bar shows up significantly lower on the scale than green beans.

All that complexity and variability weakens the glycemic index's value, said Alice H. Lichtenstein, Gershoff Professor of Nutrition Science and Policy at the Friedman School, who has led a number of studies on it. Too much focus on the index, she said, can detract from the fundamentals: People should be thinking about their total calories, the relative balance of fat and carbohydrate in their diets, and carbohydrate quality. There are only "a limited number of messages that we can give people in terms of guidance for choosing various items," Lichtenstein said, "and I think we really need to keep the focus on what's simple and what's from a general perspective most efficacious for individuals."

Still, there is value in the index, other researchers say. "As I see it, the absolute numbers don't matter that much," said Roberts, director of the Energy Metabolism Laboratory at the Jean Mayer USDA Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging and who is currently leading two studies on low-glycemic-index diets. "What matters is how a food is relative to other foods—then the glycemic index becomes much more useful."

Take that Snickers bar. "It has a lower GI because it's full of fat more than carbohydrates, and the sugar in it actually has a lower GI than starch," Roberts said. "That doesn't invalidate the use of glycemic index; it just says it's not the only thing." If she had diabetes, Roberts said, she would "absolutely be on a low-GI diet."

Although complex, the is "incredibly powerful" conceptually, added Dariush Mozaffarian, dean of the Friedman School and Jean Mayer Professor of Nutrition and Medicine. That's because it highlights the fact that starch "is a hidden sugar," he said. "If you don't think about how rapidly starch and sugar in the foods that you are eating are digested, you are going to make incorrect eating decisions."

That makes it "absolutely crucial," Mozaffarian said. "The dose and rapid digestion of starches and sugars in our foods—this is one of the things driving the obesity and diabetes epidemic."

Explore further: Low glycemic index diet linked to drop in uric acid levels

Related Stories

Low glycemic index diet linked to drop in uric acid levels

June 3, 2016
(HealthDay)—Reducing the dietary glycemic index is associated with a reduction in uric acid levels among overweight and obese adults, according to a study published in the May issue of Arthritis & Rheumatology.

High variability suggests glycemic index is unreliable indicator of blood sugar response

September 8, 2016
The glycemic index of a given food, a value that aims to quantify how fast blood sugar rises after eating it, can vary by an average of 20 percent within an individual and 25 percent among individuals, report scientists from ...

Glycemic index foods at breakfast can control blood sugar throughout the day

April 4, 2012
Eating foods at breakfast that have a low glycemic index may help prevent a spike in blood sugar throughout the morning and after the next meal of the day, researchers said at the Institute of Food Technologists' Wellness ...

High glycemic index/load diet linked to acne vulgaris

June 23, 2016
(HealthDay)—Patients with acne vulgaris have significantly higher glycemic index and glycemic load levels and significantly lower serum adiponectin levels, according to a study published in the July issue of the Journal ...

Healthy eaters, ignore glycemic index: Clinical trial shows no beneficial effects on heart disease, diabetes risk

December 16, 2014
Good news for people who are already following a diet rich in fruits, vegetables and whole grains, and low in sweets: New research suggests these heart-healthy eaters don't need to worry about choosing low glycemic index ...

Expert discusses whether avoiding gluten offers health benefits to the general population

September 25, 2017
Sales of gluten-free foods continue to soar, reflecting a widespread belief that eliminating gluten from a person's diet can produce health benefits, even for those without gluten sensitivity or celiac disease.

Recommended for you

A novel insulin accelerant

October 17, 2018
Insulin levels rise after eating a meal, signaling uptake of circulating glucose by skeletal muscle. In individuals with diabetes this process is often impaired—a condition known as insulin resistance.

Fat tissue may play a crucial role in the progression of diabetes, challenging long established notions

October 12, 2018
A new study by Australian researchers, out today, is challenging what we know about the causes of diabetes. The new research points to fat tissue as a source of disease, and widens our understanding beyond the traditional ...

Does breastfeeding hormone protect against type 2 diabetes?

October 12, 2018
(HealthDay)—The hormone prolactin—most commonly associated with breastfeeding—may play a role in reducing the risk of type 2 diabetes, a new study suggests.

Markers of dairy fat consumption linked to lower risk of type two diabetes

October 10, 2018
Higher levels of biomarkers of dairy fat consumption are associated with a lower risk of developing type 2 diabetes, according to new research published today in PLOS Medicine. The study, in more than 60,000 adults, was undertaken ...

Planned intermittent fasting may help reverse type 2 diabetes, suggest doctors

October 10, 2018
Planned intermittent fasting may help to reverse type 2 diabetes, suggest doctors writing in the journal BMJ Case Reports after three patients in their care, who did this, were able to cut out the need for insulin treatment ...

New discovery restores insulin cell function in type 2 diabetes

October 8, 2018
By blocking a protein, VDAC1, in the insulin-producing beta cells, it is possible to restore their normal function in case of type 2 diabetes. In preclinical experiments, the researchers behind a new study have also shown ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.