Breakthrough cancer therapy raises tough questions about drug costs, value

February 8, 2018 by Marie Mccullough, The Philadelphia Inquirer

Imagine a drug that, a month after a single intravenous dose, wipes out all evidence of leukemia in 80 percent of deathly ill children who receive it.

Now, imagine that the takes a month to make from each patient's own immune cells, that many children die waiting, that it causes terrible temporary side effects, that it costs $475,000, and that the accompanying medical care adds vastly to that price tag.

Finally, imagine that a year later, the has roared back in half of the children who had astounding remissions.

This isn't fantasy. This is the profile of Novartis' Kymriah, the first-of-its-kind CAR T-cell therapy. No wonder it has inspired awe, as well as deep concerns, that the benefits have been overstated and overpriced.

Novartis partnered with the University of Pennsylvania and Children's Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP) after researchers at those centers pioneered the technology to genetically engineer each patient's immune T cells to attack blood cancer cells. On Feb. 1, the New England Journal of Medicine published updated results from the global clinical trial of 95 youngsters that led to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's August approval of Kymriah to treat recurrent .

Reactions to the latest results reflect the scientific, economic, and emotional complexity of the breakthrough.

Vinay Prasad, an oncologist and drug development researcher at Oregon Health and Science University in Portland, said the update confirms his skeptical view of Kymriah's value. He faulted the researchers for inflating their one-year survival rate to 50 percent by excluding kids who gave their T cells but never got treated because of manufacturing problems or because they died before they could get the therapy. By including those children—a standard statistical practice to minimize bias—Prasad calculated the one-year survival rate is 40 percent.

"It's just a cheap way to increase your success rate that does not help patients navigate the decision of 'how likely am I to benefit?'" Prasad said. "The math shows most patients who qualify for this do not benefit. And many other patients will not qualify. So CAR-T is good. It's better than what we've done before, but not great."

John P. Leonard, an oncologist and lymphoma specialist at Weill Cornell Medical College in New York City, agreed that the survival data should reflect the fact that some patients who undergo T cell collection don't get the therapy.

"When you leave out people who didn't get the drug, it doesn't get counted against the drug," Leonard said. Including them "puts it in a little less rosy light. I think it would be valuable to present the data both ways."

Dana Lee of Ocean Township, N.J., looks at the statistics "a little differently," having seen the ravages of chemotherapy, radiation, and bone marrow transplantation on children like her 14-year-old daughter, Tori.

Almost five years ago, Tori became the 10th child to get the T-cell therapy in a pilot study at CHOP. She suffered the characteristic reaction—severe but treatable immune overstimulation, involving high fever, low blood pressure, muscle pain, neurologic symptoms.

She's now an eighth-grade honor roll student who loves basketball—and dislikes getting attention for accidentally being a medical trailblazer.

"One hundred percent of those children were not going to make it," Lee said. "All options were gone. So it gave hope to parents and children who had no hope."

About 6,000 cases of pediatric lymphoblastic leukemia are diagnosed each year in the U.S. and in Europe, where Kymriah approval is imminent. Standard therapies cure 85 percent. For those that repeatedly relapse, the prognosis is grim.

David Mitchell, who has an incurable blood cancer called multiple myeloma, understands the power of desperation, and is thrilled by the advent of CAR T-cell therapies that might one day help him.

But as the founder of the advocacy organization Patients for Affordable Drugs, Mitchell says Kymriah – developed with government subsidies—is overpriced by "hundreds of thousands of dollars." That sets a dangerous precedent, he said, given that dozens of CAR T drugs are in the pipeline. (Two pricey gene therapies were approved after Kymriah: Kite Pharma's $375,000 Yescarta for a type of lymphoma, and Philadelphia-based Spark Therapeutics' $850,000 Luxturna for an inherited form of blindness.)

"The key question is not: What's it worth to save a child's life?" Mitchell said. "If that was the question, then the polio (vaccine) they gave me when I was 6 years old would have cost a million dollars. The right question is: What is the price that will maximize accessibility and affordability, while maintaining a robust R&D pipeline?"

In contrast, another organization that assesses drug effectiveness and value, the Institute for Clinical and Economic Review, concludes that Kymriah is cost-effective: "On average, using Kymriah in a pediatric population instead of traditional chemotherapy increases health care costs by approximately $400,000, but extends life by eight years."

Anticipating controversy over the price, Novartis announced that it wouldn't charge for Kymriah if the patient doesn't respond within a month of treatment. (Penn and some of the key scientists stand to benefit financially from the Kymriah partnership, according to the university.) But critics say that deal is rigged, since 80 percent of patients go into remission, even though at least half later relapse.

Controversy has not dampened demand for Kymriah. Stephan Grupp, the CHOP oncologist who has overseen clinical testing of the drug, traveled widely to set up the global trial, conducted at 25 specialized medical centers in North America, Europe, Japan, and Australia. Now, invitations are coming from other parts of the world—rich and poor countries alike. Because of the complexities involved in making and administering the drug, only hospitals certified by Novartis can offer it.

"I have been traveling far more than my wife would approve," Grupp said recently by phone from Dubai in the United Arab Emirates. "We (CHOP and Penn) get all these emails from parents across the world. We're trying to look at access. We're really interested in figuring out how to help patients who won't have access in their own countries, at least not for years."

Explore further: FDA approves personalized cellular therapy for advanced leukemia

Related Stories

FDA approves personalized cellular therapy for advanced leukemia

August 30, 2017
In a landmark decision for the field of cancer immunotherapy, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) today approved a personalized cellular therapy developed by the University of Pennsylvania and Children's Hospital ...

Breakthrough cancer treatment brings hope and challenges

October 2, 2017
The first gene therapy for cancer, approved by the Food Drug Administration in August, will transform the treatment of a particular kind of cancer in children and young adults. It's transformative because it uses a patient's ...

Study: CAR T-cell therapy safe and effective in youth with leukemia

February 1, 2018
Results of the global, multicenter, pivotal phase 2 study that led to the first FDA approval of a gene therapy/cell therapy approach known as CAR T-cell therapy, were published today in the New England Journal of Medicine. ...

Global CAR T therapy trial shows high rates of durable remission for NHL

December 10, 2017
In a pair of clinical trials stretching from Philadelphia to Tokyo, the chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cell therapy Kymriah (formerly known as CTL019) demonstrated long-lasting remissions in non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) ...

Expensive new cancer therapy may be cost effective

December 20, 2017
Researchers from the University of Colorado Skaggs School of Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences, selected to estimate the cost-effectiveness of the newly approved CAR-T therapies, have found the clinical benefit may justify ...

US clears breakthrough gene therapy for childhood leukemia

August 31, 2017
Opening a new era in cancer care, U.S. health officials have approved a breakthrough treatment that genetically engineers patients' own blood cells into an army of assassins to seek and destroy childhood leukemia.

Recommended for you

Researchers identify a mechanism that fuels cancer cells' growth

November 14, 2018
Scientists at the UCLA Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center have identified sodium glucose transporter 2, or SGLT2, as a mechanism that lung cancer cells can utilize to obtain glucose, which is key to their survival and promotes ...

A new approach to detecting cancer earlier from blood tests: study

November 14, 2018
Cancer scientists led by principal investigator Dr. Daniel De Carvalho at Princess Margaret Cancer Centre have combined "liquid biopsy", epigenetic alterations and machine learning to develop a blood test to detect and classify ...

New antibody breakthrough to lead the fight against cancer

November 14, 2018
Scientists at the University of Southampton have developed a new antibody that could hold the key to unlocking cancer's defence against the body's immune system.

Photoacoustic imaging may help doctors detect ovarian tumors earlier

November 14, 2018
Ovarian cancer claims the lives of more than 14,000 in the U.S. each year, ranking fifth among cancer deaths in women. A multidisciplinary team at Washington University in St. Louis has found an innovative way to use sound ...

Solving the mystery of NPM1 in acute myeloid leukemia

November 13, 2018
Although it has long been recognized that mutations of gene NPM1 play an important role in acute myeloid leukemia, no one has determined how the normal and the mutated forms of the protein NPM1 function.

Cognitive decline—radiation—brain tumor prevented by temporarily shutting down immune response

November 13, 2018
Treating brain tumors comes at a steep cost, especially for children. More than half of patients who endure radiation therapy for these tumors experience irreversible cognitive decline, a side-effect that has particularly ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.