No proof at-home 'cranial stimulation' eases depression

February 13, 2018 by Amy Norton, Healthday Reporter

(HealthDay)—Devices that send electrical pulses to the brain—in the comfort of your own home—are a treatment option for depression and certain other conditions. But a new research review finds little evidence they work.

The —known as cranial electrical stimulation (CES)—involves a handheld that delivers low-intensity electrical currents through electrodes placed on the head.

The new review, of 26 , found "low-strength" evidence that the therapy can help people with both depression and anxiety.

But there was no proof it was effective for depression alone, insomnia, joint pain or chronic headaches.

However, the review doesn't prove the therapy doesn't work, either.

Researchers said the issue is that most of the studies were small, short-term or had other limitations.

"The evidence was insufficient that these devices are effective. But that's not the same as saying that they don't work," said lead researcher Dr. Paul Shekelle, chief of general internal medicine at the VA West Los Angeles Medical Center.

Dr. Wayne Jonas called the findings "disappointing," but agreed they are not the final word on cranial electrical stimulation.

"There's just not enough evidence there for us to know whether it works," said Jonas, of Samueli Integrative Health Programs, in Alexandria, Va.

Jonas wrote an editorial published with the review in the Feb. 13 online edition of Annals of Internal Medicine.

A number of CES devices are approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for people to use at home, with a doctor's prescription.

However, they are easily purchased online—on sites where they are sold second-hand, for example.

Jonas advised against that. "This is supposed to be something a doctor prescribes for you, not something you buy off the internet," he said.

And given the uncertainty around CES, Jonas said, it's important that people talk to their doctor about all of their treatment options.

Shekelle agreed. The devices themselves are powered by a 9-volt battery, he noted. The concern is not so much that CES will directly harm people.

The main worry, Shekelle said, is that people will "self-treat" with CES, and not get therapies that have good evidence to back them up.

The findings are based on an analysis of 26 clinical trials, most involving fewer than 30 patients.

Most studies tested CES against a "placebo," meaning an inactive device. A few pitted it against standard treatment.

One relatively larger trial—of more than 100 patients—focused on people with both depression and anxiety. And it found that CES appeared more effective than a placebo version.

But, Shekelle said, it had limitations. It was only five weeks long, for one.

There was no clear evidence the stimulation therapy was better than a placebo when it came to other conditions. These included depression alone, insomnia, and chronic pain conditions such as fibromyalgia, headache and achy joints.

On the bright side, the therapy seemed fairly safe. Side effects were mainly mild skin tingling or irritation, and sleepiness.

"The risk of harm appears to be pretty low, as long as you use an FDA-cleared device," Jonas said.

But like Shekelle, he said the main potential "harm" is that people will bypass proven therapies in favor of CES.

And that includes other non-drug options, Jonas stressed.

When it comes to low back pain, for instance, treatment guidelines say people should first try tactics such as heat wraps, acupuncture and yoga before turning to medication.

If CES does help people with combined depression and anxiety—or any other disorder—it's not clear why.

Early animal studies suggested it might alter certain "chemical messengers" in the brain. More recently, research has shown it might temporarily change the "connectivity" among certain brain cells, according to Shekelle's team.

Jonas suspects CES works mainly by "inducing relaxation."

What about people who are already using the therapy?

"If you are using this under medical supervision, and feel that it's helping, then by all means keep using it," Shekelle said.

On the other hand, he added, if the therapy has not eased your symptoms, it may be time to discuss other options with your doctor.

For people who are considering CES, cost is another factor. Insurance may cover it, but there may be a hefty co-pay. Jonas said he works at a military hospital where active-duty personnel can get a CES device for free—while those not on active duty have a co-pay of about $300.

Explore further: Chiropractors not magicians when it comes to chronic back pain

More information: Paul Shekelle, M.D., chief, general internal medicine, VA West Los Angeles Healthcare System, and professor, medicine, University of California Los Angeles School of Medicine; Wayne Jonas, M.D., executive director, Samueli Integrative Health Programs, Alexandria, VA, and professor, medicine, Georgetown University, Washington, D.C.; Feb. 13, 2018 Annals of Internal Medicine online.
Abstract/Full Text (subscription or payment may be required)
Editorial (subscription or payment may be required)

The U.S. National Institute of Mental Health has more on brain stimulation therapies.

Related Stories

Chiropractors not magicians when it comes to chronic back pain

April 11, 2017
(HealthDay)—Chiropractors can help ease some cases of low back pain, though their treatments may be no better than taking an over-the-counter pain reliever, a new analysis finds.

Electrical stimulation improves paralyzed patients' function

September 15, 2017
Nearly 282,000 people in the U.S. live with paralysis following a spinal cord injury (SCI). A review of more than 90 studies found that electrical stimulation may help restore function in those paralyzed after SCI. The article ...

Cognitive behavior therapy significantly reduced depression and anxiety in chronic pain patients

June 15, 2017
The results of a study presented today at the Annual European Congress of Rheumatology (EULAR) 2017 has shown that Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, a form of cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) that focuses on psychological ...

Spinal cord stimulation is a safe, effective drug-free treatment for chronic pain

July 14, 2016
Chronic pain affects up to 20% of people in developed countries, and represents not only a profound impact on individuals and their families but also a sizeable burden on employers, health care systems, and society in general. ...

Light therapy effective for depression, study reports

November 18, 2015
New research finds that light therapy can treat non-seasonal depression and improve the overall wellbeing of people suffering from the disease.

Yoga is an effective alternative to physical therapy for easing low back pain

June 19, 2017
A study of 320 predominantly low-income, racially diverse adults with chronic low back pain found that yoga was as safe and effective as physical therapy for restoring function and relieving pain. Compared to an education ...

Recommended for you

Unprecedented study identifies 44 genetic risk factors for major depression

April 26, 2018
A global research project has mapped out the genetic basis of major depression, identifying 44 genetic variants which are risk factors for depression, 30 of which are newly discovered. The study, by the Psychiatric Genomics ...

Three-minute version of brain stimulation therapy effective for hard-to-treat depression

April 26, 2018
In the largest study of its kind, a three-minute version of a brain stimulation treatment was shown to be just as effective as the standard 37-minute version for hard-to-treat depression.

Millennial men value altruism and self-care above traditional male qualities

April 25, 2018
Contrary to popular stereotypes, young men today are likely to be selfless, socially engaged and health-conscious, according to a new study from the University of British Columbia and Intensions Consulting, a Vancouver-based ...

Indications of psychosis appear in cortical folding

April 25, 2018
Imaging techniques can be used to detect the development of psychosis in the brains of high-risk patients at an early stage, as reported by researchers from the University of Basel and Western University in the journal JAMA ...

Maternal binge drinking linked to mood problems and alcohol abuse in offspring

April 25, 2018
Binge drinking by pregnant and lactating mothers can impair the mental health of their offspring, reports a study published today in Frontiers in Psychiatry. In a rat model, Italian researchers find that while habitual drinking ...

Engaging in physical activity decreases people's chance of developing depression

April 24, 2018
An international team including researchers from King's College London have found physical activity can protect against the emergence of depression, regardless of age and geographical region.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.